Tech/maintenance Rose Brass and Acid Treatment

Enjoy the new horn, Ves. It sounds like a good match for you and should meet your needs for many years - "wants" are a whole 'nother matter. 😎
I think there's definitely room for me to grow into it. Yes, those pesky wants are fickle things. Can't want what you didn't know existed. Have to be open.

Thanks again for everyone's comments. Glad to be a member of what seems like a good online community.

Maybe I'll post up a photo occasionally to show how the colorization prices is going.
 
Right... I was insulted... Cause the truth hurts!

No, it was a stupid thing for the salesperson to say. A “professional” what? House cleaner? Plumber? If a professional musician plays a horn with either a lacquer or plated finish, they would have no reason to experience “patina”. Heck, I lived in high desert for 20+ years and hardly ever had to polish my silver plated tenor or my flutes - no humidity, no pollution.

Yeah, you could tell the salesman to rethink his manners, or you could do what a professional would do…. Practice.
 
Well, it's probably true that a professional would know about the surface treatment of this particular horn; but that would be a professional metal-finisher or plater. Not a professional saxophone player. Professional saxophone players don't generally study industrial metal finishing processes unless that's their day gig.
 
No, it was a stupid thing for the salesperson to say. A “professional” what? House cleaner? Plumber? If a professional musician plays a horn with either a lacquer or plated finish, they would have no reason to experience “patina”. Heck, I lived in high desert for 20+ years and hardly ever had to polish my silver plated tenor or my flutes - no humidity, no pollution.

Yeah, you could tell the salesman to rethink his manners, or you could do what a professional would do…. Practice.
Yeah, I pointed out that they should not assume a buyer would know any of this. Clearly they need to clean up their act a bit of they want to be taken seriously.

As someone who's had to deal with the Chinese mentality as it relates to manufacturing and quality control, I've seen a lot of this. Let's face it, many name brand instruments, like my Selmer, are made in or made from parts that come from China. The difference is in the details. And when they miss the details, that first impression is a killer, even with a basically good product.

I definitely learned something here. Hopefully they did too!
 
From experience I can tell you that they very probably didn't. Or if they did, they didn't care.
Bit by the China bug, were you? Yeah, the first one I ordered, from a no name seller, had a bent octave mechanism on the neck, and no matter what I did, I couldn't get the pads to stop sticking. And it had some sharp edges I actually cut myself on. Finally just sent it back. By then the sellers privileges were removed, but eBay resolved it for me. Of course, shoddy workmanship is not just China. I tried buying a 1970 Cleveland, supposedly completely rebuilt, by a guy doing it for 40 years. It looked good in the pics... Cost twice as much as the China sax. Some corks were missing, another big one fell off, then the G# key stuck open... Had to send that one back too. That's when I decided I'm not screwing with it any more and bought the Selmet Aristocrat. The Eastern Music was a curiosity for me. I've been switching between playing the two and honestly, the Eastern Music plays really well. Not sure if it's the rose brass or the fact that it's not lacqueted, or because it has a full rail, or all three, but it definitely has a brighter tone, and seems more responsive.

You win some, you lose some. ‍
 
Bit by the China bug, were you?

Not me personally - but I've acted as a technical advisor in the past and have had first-hand experience of how frustrating it can be to deal with Chinese manufacturers. It's why so many retailers simply gave up trying to source and sell Chinese horns.

I tried buying a 1970 Cleveland, supposedly completely rebuilt, by a guy doing it for 40 years. It looked good in the pics... Cost twice as much as the China sax. Some corks were missing, another big one fell off, then the G# key stuck open... Had to send that one back too.

I found out the hard way that many years in the trade or an 'internet reputation' carries no weight at all. The only way you know whether someone's walking the walk is when you see their workmanship on your own bench.

Not sure if it's the rose brass or the fact that it's not lacqueted, or because it has a full rail, or all three, but it definitely has a brighter tone, and seems more responsive.

It's simply because it's a different horn. It could just have easily been darker and less responsive.
 
A good horn is a good horn.
Some make good horns most of the time and some only occassionally.
Some weed out the lemons and correct or bin them before market. Some send the next one off the line regardless.
The thoroghly inspected ones may be given a different brand name.
Advertising images may bear no relation to what you get.
I think this covers manufacturing in general.

Second hand and restored instruments may have faults that every body has missed.

The post can ruin a good horn in transit.

Caveat emptor.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,717
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom