Miscellaneous Reporting posts

Do you report offensive posts

  • Yes always

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • Yes sometimes

    Votes: 3 12.0%
  • No I didn't know I could

    Votes: 2 8.0%
  • No I'm happy to ignore posts I don't like

    Votes: 18 72.0%
  • No and it stops me visiting

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    25
The very fact that the café is holding this poll (and your personal example) shows IMHO good awareness of sensitivities that may lead lead to members finding posts intentionally or unintentionally offensive. Either personally or towards others. I'm a member of a couple of forums and this is the first I've seen that addresses the issue of offensiveness and reporting explicitly.

I'm an old white guy and I fully accept that I have ingrained, subliminal and unintentional prejudices. I do my best to become ever more aware of these and change my perceptions and behavior accordingly. I'm a firm supporter of a multi-racial, multi-cultural and multi-religious (or non-religious) society. And I hope other members will 'call me out' if I ever post anything that they find even mildly offensive.

Mike

This is really tricky for use. Terms such as PC, Woke, Snowflake are used pejoratively and I would agree sometimes it may be justified, but more often it is about just showing respect and trying to help people be and feel included and respected.

Times change. Many would agree it's good that wolf whistling, bottom slapping is mostly a thing of the past in many places. I also believe it’s right that some words used to describe people of colour, or disabled people are no longer useable.

There is a difference between
  1. Reports by people who find something offensive to themselves
  2. Reports by people who find something that is offensive to others.

The first example is sometimes more justified because that person may be suffering from something they have personally experienced. It's confusaing because words have different connotations to different people. My friend in New Orleans who is black, despises the word Dixieland and admonished my use of it once. I had no idea it was offensive nor do many. However I respected that because of who he is, due to the prejudice he suffered throughout the 50s, 60s and through to today.

The second example is tricky, because when it is a sort of borderline case, it may be used by someone both sincerely out of trying to make the cafe a respectful place, but also it could be used flippantly or even vexatiously against someone.

I’m not qualified to know all the nuances what may or may not be offensive, hence our role may often err on the side of caution. I ask members to repsect otherwise can be a really time consuming and almost impossible moderation task. We just try to do our best and often you can't please everyone.
 
A couple of recent reports made me wonder if 1 or 2 saw fit to report something were there others that were offended too but didn't report or didn't know you could.

You are right this is a pretty laid back place but I suspect @Jules because we catch stuff early there is a lot you miss. But to be fair there has been little work recently for us in respect of deleting posts which is always a good thing 🙂

Jx
When a post is reported what is the the criteria for it to be deleted, that the mods think that the 'average' person would agree with the reason for the report, (from the comments here most wouldn't be bothered), or only that one member has said they are offended?
 
I think pretty much what we think the average member might feel about it. Not all would report as have said but it doesn't mean they like it. We also have to remember potential new members may be put off joining or staying if they see what they deem to be an offensive or nasty post.

We don't always delete a post because it has been reported and we sometimes delete posts before they are reported if we feel it appropriate.

They are not always offensive as such but some can be rude or inflammatory and argumentative and we take into account who is involved in exchanges and usually speak to them privately if we are going to or have deleted a post. Sometimes members get very passionate and don't realise the impact of their wording on other readers especially when they are in a heated debate. It is hard to keep comments impersonal but the majority of the time our members do get it right. 🙂

Jx
 
When a post is reported what is the the criteria for it to be deleted, that the mods think that the 'average' person would agree with the reason for the report, (from the comments here most wouldn't be bothered), or only that one member has said they are offended?
Several reports will make us feel it's a definite, but there cannot be any hard and fast criteria as context can make a difference. As I said above we may give more weight to a report form somebody who has a reason to be offended themselves.

However often there are borderline areas and we just have to make a decision that could go either way. We are only human.

I know we may seem inconsistent, but I can't think of a way round that apart from writing a very long rule book outlining every possible scenario.

If a member makes more than one "borderline" post and I think we might moderated one, but then given them the benefit of the doubt on another one to balance it up.
 
I have learned my lesson on reporting posts. If I think someone else might be offended, I'm probably wrong. In the future I'll only report posts blatantly offensive directly to me, not those I think may be offensive to others.
 
I have learned my lesson on reporting posts. If I think someone else might be offended, I'm probably wrong.
Not at all. The last report you did was a good one and very useful. If you think a post is offensive, then we are happy that you report it because we can't catch everything by ourselves.

But it is not easy, different people have different concepts of what is offensive.

Unlike many forums, we believe in being open, honest and transparent as possible so we discuss reports with the member that reported. It is one of the nice features of this forum software because in the old days someoene would report and mods discussed by themselves.

Now with this system you have a chance to enter into some dialogue.
 
Hardly your fault.
Absolutely not, but I do try to become more aware of the sensibilities of people that (unlike me) aren't 'old white guys' I've interviewed and photographed many immigrants to NL from all parts of the world. That has given me a much greater understanding of the challenges that immigrants faced in their home countries and in integrating into NL society. And also into their cultural preferences of being photographed or not.

What I've picked up from this experience is that:
  • the mainstream English language 'norms' don't always apply to everyone
  • people from different cultural backgrounds have different 'norms' and 'preferences' regarding what they see and read in media (including café sax) and how they interact.
  • people from different cultural backgrounds differ in terms of (online) 'assertiveness' (in complaining, raising issues, etc.)

Once again, I compliment café saxophone for this poll. It shows great sensitivity to 'non old white guys' who may want to 'flag' certain posts or responses.
 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom