Reeds Reeds wearing out

It's gone - well actually I decided they could all go! For the last few days, I've had lots of sqeaks and sqwarks. I didn't think it was me, but you never know... I decided to give a new reeds a go and see what happened. I got a much fuller sound, and needed to blow a good deal more, so I felt the old reed was beyond redemption.
So 4 reeds have lasted me 7 weeks. I play around 1.5 - 2 hours a day. So that's a smidge less than 2 weeks a reed on average. I must admit I don't think it's any better (or worse) than before.
 
Hi Mandy - Its an ongoing battle, I think eventually you settle down to what suits you best and then of course you need a good standby reed just in case! Within the sax section I find and hear so many different setups, that if must be baffilling to listen to if you dont play a reed instrument!

I hope you find an answer - I have a drawer full of reeds, has cost me a small fortune experamenting.
Good luck in your quest.
Les.
 
Hi Mandy
Just had a dig about in the sax case and have found a couple of unused rico royal No3. If you want to have a try with them just pm me with your address and I'll bung them in the post. It may just sort out your problems.
 
Hi Mandy!

That's a high wastage rate. My reeds last 6 months or more each - I assume you know how to prepare and take care of them - particularly massaging them after playing to remove some of the moisture and to help the fibres settle in one direction, rather than become waterlogged and turn to mush. Let us know if you need any help with this, as reeds are not cheap.

Kind regards
Tom
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi Tom and Mandy,

Yes Tom, that is a very high wastage rate. As you may have seen in my ravings, I have been experimenting with adhesives to seal the reed (in my case after sanding). The results have been excellent, with no moisture getting into them, no deterioration of the reeds, and I have suffered no ill effects!!
The adhesive I use, is a clear one (used for gluing rigid plastics together), only a very small amount being used and rubbed well in, in fact nearly all of it is rubbed off, just leaving a barely discernible film. I have not noticed any difference in the sound after treatment.

John.
 
"Sticky end", very good Tom 🙂. What I'm saying is it works and it must be worth giving it a try. As for the sanding of a reed, I see so many people struggling on here. The latest is Viruskiller, saying his teacher says to use stiffer reeds, so he does and struggles, he's out of breath pushing air through the instrument - WHY? This can't be right!

John.
 
I'm still using the same two Rico Royal No.2 clarinet reeds I was using when this thread started. All of my reeds last and last, and I can't understand why Mandy is having so much trouble. Its worth pointing out that squeaks can be caused by a faulty embouchure. Are you sure yours is OK?

Jim.
 
how can an embouchure be OK for 7 weeks and then fall apart? Well, I guess it could, or maybe I am just really fussy and have a much finer tolerance of what I consider to be an acceptable range of correct? But the reeds are definitely fairly soft by this point.
I know this is true for my contact lenses - I can sense the slightest change in my prescription, my optician is surprised that I can sense it at all, maybe the same is true of my ears and mouth?

I do the reed conditioning before I use them - the soaking and rubbing on a smooth surface , and I rub the moisture out of the reed after use, and put it back in the conditioning case, and cycle to the next reed the next day.
 
I've re-read your original post and see you have been playing for two years. Your embouchure will be just fine, I'm sure. Have you had the sax checked over? Are you happy with the reeds until they go soft on you, or do they feel duff all the time now? A well respected sax player who worked in the music shop I used once asked me how long my reeds lasted? I had just started back playing again and I didn't really know. Anyway I told him at least a month or more and he snapped back that I should be changing them sooner. He would have thought that you are doing it right.

Jim.
 
I've re-read your original post and see you have been playing for two years. Your embouchure will be just fine, I'm sure. Have you had the sax checked over? Are you happy with the reeds until they go soft on you, or do they feel duff all the time now? A well respected sax player who worked in the music shop I used once asked me how long my reeds lasted? I had just started back playing again and I didn't really know. Anyway I told him at least a month or more and he snapped back that I should be changing them sooner. He would have thought that you are doing it right.

Jim.

Yes, my teacher spent a long time improving my embouchure after I took grade 4. She seemed happy with the improvement in tone that this produced, and now she comments on the good tone I produce, so I'd like to think the embouchure is correct.
I haven't had a reed that's duff out of the box, they all seem to play well to start with.
The last time I replaced a reed, it was so soft that when I first blew the new reed I couldn't get a note out of it. This time, I was just getting all sorts of squeaks and thought I'd try a new reed, just to check the squeaks weren't me. The tone with the new reed was immediately fuller and the squeaks were gone, so I concluded the old reed was no longer sufficiently good enough.
I do the reed conditioning preparation as discussed in other threads.
My teacher has said many times in the past that with about 2 hours playing a day, every day then 2 weeks from a reed is about right (as per your acquaintance). The sax is just a year old (this month, I think) a Yani 901. I guess there could be something amiss with it, but I'd be disappointed if there were.
My teacher did suggest last lesson that I might need to move up to Rico Royal 3s, but since I have an exam in 4 weeks time, she also suggested that I wait until after the exam.
I don't personally have a problem with the frequency of reed replacement, I'm more curious to know how others really keep their reeds going, or do they just develop bad habbits to force a note out of an old reed? :confused:
 
I read over all of your posts last night and realised that that your sax and reeds are OK and it's just that you think your reeds should last longer. My reeds last because I don't practce like you. I did at one time, but now I'm a lazy so and so. Three 40 min sessions a day of serious practice is a lot, and a reed is just a wee bit stick. They are mini marvels really. It seems that you are getting your moneys worth from you reeds after all.

Only being able to play for 30/40 mins is a bit of a bummer and I was going to suggest a softer reed. But there you go. We all need fresh free blowing reeds and I don't think anyone could force notes from an old reed. I think that as time goes by we somehow develop a more reed friendly playing style and that's why they last longer.

Jim.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,541
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom