Saxophone beginners Reed strength difference between Alto & Tenor?

Freddie

Member
Messages
70
Location
Southern Caribbean
Hi, I’ve been blowing a Tenor for a couple of years & recently picked up an Alto, to give it a try!
It’s still in Blighty, but being collected before the end of November.
So my question is, should I go with the same strength & make the I use on the Tenor, is there a difference?
I ask, as I live in the southern Caribbean & there are no music shops to pop to.
Also since Hurricane Beryl, I’m on the Island hardest hit, shipping is very hit & miss ( mostly miss).
 
Hi, I’ve been blowing a Tenor for a couple of years & recently picked up an Alto, to give it a try!
It’s still in Blighty, but being collected before the end of November.
So my question is, should I go with the same strength & make the I use on the Tenor, is there a difference?
I ask, as I live in the southern Caribbean & there are no music shops to pop to.
Also since Hurricane Beryl, I’m on the Island hardest hit, shipping is very hit & miss ( mostly miss).
Providing you don't use widely differing facings on your mouthpieces I'd go for the same. And by facings I mean the combination of facing curve length and tip width, although assuming a medium curve then tip dimensions may be a reasonable guide.

It is said that wider tips and short facings need lower reedstrength - it is only a very very rough guide.I use a 5 on alto, 7 on baritone and 9* on tenor, all with 2.25 reeds.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I play baritone reeds on tenor and baritone. I use to play .120" baritone mouthpiece with #3 plasticover and .130" tenor with #4-5 plasticover. I play baritone in a different way compared to tenor.

If it's hard to get reeds you can learn to prepare reeds. Buy hard baritone reeds and try to "convert" them to fit your tenor mouthpiece. I don't prepare plasticover reeds.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Providing you don't use widely differing facings on your mouthpieces I'd go for the same. And by facings I mean the combination of facing curve length and tip width, although assuming a medium curve then tip dimensions may be a reasonable guide.

It is said that wider tips and short facings need lower reedstrength - it is only a very very rough guide.I use a 5 on alto, 7 on baritone and 9* on tenor, all with 2.25 reeds.
Thanks Pete, I’ve hedged a little, there’s a Yam 6C, plus what ever came with the horn. I’ve got some Vandoren Trad 2’s & 2.5’s coming with it.
I use similar on the Tenor, so hopefully a decent starting point.
I play baritone reeds on tenor and baritone. I use to play .120" baritone mouthpiece with #3 plasticover and .130" tenor with #4-5 plasticover. I play baritone in a different way compared to tenor.

If it's hard to get reeds you can learn to prepare reeds. Buy hard baritone reeds and try to "convert" them to fit your tenor mouthpiece. I don't prepare plasticover reeds.
its food for thought & I thank you for the advice.
There are friends coming & going, so getting reeds is not a problem, i just wanted to find out if there was a general rule of thumb. It would appear to be use the same ( ish) strength reed & go from there.
I may try to adapt a discarded or passed over tenor reed if the reeds I have coming don’t work for me.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I think that coming from the unknown, matching reeds is the logical thing.

Personally, I would always err towards a reed on the soft side as it will always be playable for most things.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
For anyone, but not least of all someone with dodgy access to reed shopping, I'd'v though getting on top of reed adjustment would be a good idea. There's tones of YouTube advice, threads here... Even, when you're in the UK, maybe finding someone to give you a tutorial.
And making sure you have the tools - though there's plenty of opinion between sanding and scraping, reed geeking; and clipping.

The easiest manoeuvre is softening a reed, if it's a tad hard. There are other reed rescue techniques...
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Got to agree with @mizmar , learn how to make adjustments to your reeds. Do you have a reed trimmer? If a reed is too soft, by clipping a little off the end can firm it up a little. I keep various grades of sandpaper with me, so I can tweak reeds. Then you can fix a reed to your liking. It takes a little learning to know how much and what part of the reed to sand.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
For anyone, but not least of all someone with dodgy access to reed shopping, I'd'v though getting on top of reed adjustment would be a good idea. There's tones of YouTube advice, threads here... Even, when you're in the UK, maybe finding someone to give you a tutorial.
And making sure you have the tools - though there's plenty of opinion between sanding and scraping, reed geeking; and clipping.

The easiest manoeuvre is softening a reed, if it's a tad hard. There are other reed rescue techniques...
I won’t be in the UK for a year or more.
Seen some of the YouTube channels & advice.
Seeking advice here too.
I’d rather not do too much work on a reed.
Rather like owning a dog , then barking yourself!
Got to agree with @mizmar , learn how to make adjustments to your reeds. Do you have a reed trimmer? If a reed is too soft, by clipping a little off the end can firm it up a little. I keep various grades of sandpaper with me, so I can tweak reeds. Then you can fix a reed to your liking. It takes a little learning to know how much and what part of the reed to sand.
yes I have a trimmer & more sandpaper & sanding tools than you can shake a stick at.
Needed a starting point & as I live on a boat, time is an issue.
So if I don’t need to……
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Rather like owning a dog , then barking yourself!
Respectfully, I'm not sure that's true.
Maybe more like owning a cat (does anyone ever actually own a cat?) and barking because you wanted a dog?

No reed is perfect. Even plastic ones.
Either people put up with it, or can adjust themselves or can adjust the Reed... Within some tolerance.

Actually, right now, I have two plastic reeds. One is softer than I'd like, the other stiffer. So I alternate every few days. On average, over the week, it's fine.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Hi @Freddie I came to tenor from alto, but in my experience with similar mouthpiece opening I could play harder reeds on tenor than I ever could on alto. I never felt comfortable with 3.0 on alto while that was my go to strength on tenor.

When I read Pete say he uses 2.25 on all alto, tenor and bari, I noticed he mentioned 5 on alto, 9* on tenor and 7 on bari. So that tends to corroborate my own experience.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
When I read Pete say he uses 2.25 on all alto, tenor and bari, I noticed he mentioned 5 on alto, 9* on tenor
Bearing in mind that an Alto 5 is very much on the smaller tip side and Tenor 9* is very much on the large side - yet reed strength remains 2.25.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
OK, well, for a given manufacturer, it seems generally their intention is for mouthpieces of the same facing number to exhibit generally similar facing-based resistance. So for example, my Meyer #8 baritone, my Meyer #8 tenor, and my Meyer #7 alto mouthpiece all seem, TO ME, to have generally similar playing characteristics, even though the actual measurement of tip opening is not the same.

Personally, I find that when I play these mouthpieces with Vandoren #3 reeds, which are my standard, yes, they do play similarly, keeping in mind of course that they're powering different instruments.

Now once you start changing variables, then the outputs start changing. Different reeds, different mouthpiece models, different saxophones will change things.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
OK, well, for a given manufacturer, it seems generally their intention is for mouthpieces of the same facing number to exhibit generally similar facing-based resistance. So for example, my Meyer #8 baritone, my Meyer #8 tenor, and my Meyer #7 alto mouthpiece all seem, TO ME, to have generally similar playing characteristics, even though the actual measurement of tip opening is not the same.

Personally, I find that when I play these mouthpieces with Vandoren #3 reeds, which are my standard, yes, they do play similarly, keeping in mind of course that they're powering different instruments.

Now once you start changing variables, then the outputs start changing. Different reeds, different mouthpiece models, different saxophones will change things.
Thanks. I seem to be on the right course, then.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I’d rather not do too much work on a reed.
Rather like owning a dog , then barking yourself!
Lot of people think like this. But reeds are all a little different. Would a guitar player refuse to trim the extra length of the strings because that’s how they were made? Or not stretch them after installation because it would ruin them?

You get the point. All consumable items on an instrument require a little adjustment. Reeds are no different.

Regarding the dog, you still have to feed it and clean up after it…. That’s all reed adjustment is.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,433
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom