Playing the saxophone Reed/Mouthpiece Combos

IGoddard

Member
Messages
140
Location
UK
I'm a frequent window shopper of saxophone gear, primarily mouthpieces and often find some that have a minimum tip opening of 7. This got me thinking; for those of us that are comfortable in the 6* and below openings - is there a difference in sound and playability of reaching for those higher tips openings but reducing the reed strength to compensate?

Hypothetically, if reed strength was in some way relational to tip opening size. Would playing a 6 mouthpiece on a 3 reed require the same strength and control as a 7 mouthpiece with a 2.5 reed, or an 8 mouthpiece with a 2 reed and so on?
 
It’s not that simple. People concentrate on tip opening because that’s what manufacturers do. But the length and shape of the facing curve (and whether it is smooth and straight vs. bumpy and/or crooked) has as much to do with playability and what reeds feel good as anything else. More open tips tend to have longer facings - some like Vandoren are clear about this, others are silent. Berg Larsen attempted to distinguish facing length, but the markings on their pieces cannot be relied on. Meyers also indicate facing length, but I’ve never heard of anything but “M”.

Regardless of tip opening and facing properties, you just have to find what works for you. On tenor, I play a 7* (0.105”) with a Rico 3.5 reed. This plays freely and smoothly for me. I also use Rico 3.5 (or equivalent) on alto and soprano, but that is a little too hard for me on my 7 tip opening alto piece (0.085”). On my 6 it’s perfect. On soprano, I play a 6.

Rico 3.5 is about a 3 strong or 3 medium in Rigotti, or a 3 medium in Select Jazz. The reeds I have are older, all pre-D’Addario, and might be a little harder than the current ones.

I have excellent mouthpieces with very easy-blowing facings that are meticulous. 10MFan and Phil-Tone.
 
This is interesting. Facing is not something I've considered or known much about, mainly as it's rarely something listed in mouthpiece descriptions.
I'm currently playing a SYOS smoky 6 and have for some time been trying to make the step up to a D'addario Select Jazz 6* - I love this mouthpiece for the extra punch it can offer over the SYOS but the 6* is the minimum tip opening and I've been baffled how swapping between the two, the SJ really kicks my butt in terms of embouchure effort required.

Comparing the two it looks like the SYOS has a long facing vs a medium or even a short facing for the SJ. But what has really surprised me is that the breakpoint for the SJ is a good 7-10mm longer



WhatsApp Image 2024-02-20 at 09.12.07.webp
WhatsApp Image 2024-02-20 at 09.12.07 (1).webp
 
I often see the advice to pull the reed back from the MP tip if you want to make it easier to play, or do the opposite to make a less stiff reed more so, the reason given that you are changing how much of the thicker part of the reed is allowed to vibrate. I guess tihs simulates changing the facing length?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom