Reeds reed geek

OK, soooo, some of you think it's a mistake to fork out 28quid for a hunk of metal. Firstly let me say to Tom, I'm a newbie on here,not to sax playing, I've been doing that for 40years as I've said. The one thing that has got well and truly up my pipe since starting out, is the fact that I spend in the region of the same 28quid for a box of reeds that I maybe get 2 good ones from, if I'm lucky. Now I accept that I may be looking for the holy grail here, but I have tried ALL the methods for re - manufacturing my reeds, from glass paper to just roughed up glass, through single edged razor blades, to Oboe knives. all with varying degress of success. So, this little gizmo may not be any better, but I like the look of it, and at least it's portable! if it does what it says on the tin, then it will be a good addition to my toolkit, if it doesn't, then all I've really lost out on is a couple of reeds, and I'll still have a blade, albeit an expensive one, to use on my reeds anyway. Of course IF it is somewhere near the 'Holy Grail'then you Guys and Gals will get to know right here, if it isn't then Tom or Johnboy can start another thread entitled I TOLD YOU SO!

Hi Mick,
I'm sorry but we seem to have got off on the wrong foot here, which was certainly not my intention, this being a very friendly forum :welldone
While watching the video of the 'Reed Geek', it was obvious to me that there was a problem with the way it was being used, i.e. the very short strokes. There was nothing shown that the use of a Stanley blade couldn't accomplish! While thinking about it, the other pitfalls became apparent, and I felt it neccessary to point them out.
I couldn't and wouldn't say "I told you so", you had already placed the order before my post.
Anyway lets 'Shake Hands' metaphorically speeking, and look forward to more fun on the forum ;}

John
 
You do need someone to be bold and buy/try these new inventions, and who knows it may work and if it does then that will benefit us newbies, reed care is a minefield one saying 'this works for me' another saying 'i do this' if an aid becomes available and works it will save me as a newbie a lot of time/expense/and effort, as it's no good me buying one and trying it as i know very little on reed care, it needs someone with more experience to try it out. If it does work, great i'll buy one. 🙂

You can be sure that it won't work any better than a Stanley knife blade.
 
John
It looks like we both started on the wrong foot. As I said to Tom, I didn't take offence, I just thought I would explain why I did what I did. The remark about the TOLD YOU SO bit was a JOKE, it was said tongue in cheek so to speak, but it's always difficult to translate that in a word document, I must remember to put little icons in like you guys do! I'm a very laid back Guy and love the kind of disscussion this started. I hope you Guys will get to know me better and realise that I do have a dry sense of humour, or so I've been told, but it takes time for people to catch on, especially in forums where there is only the written word. so, let me say this out loud, I DIDN'T TAKE ANY OFFENCE AT THE REMARKS ON THIS THREAD!!!! I took it all in the fun way it was intended.
 
John
Yeah, Likewise, BTW Hows life in Spain? trumpet player friend of mine did some years in Spain, but he went back to blighty, didn't get enough gigs for the band he started. Good player, we played together for some years in the same band. How you getting on? playing gigs and that.
 
Not the Met, no, Surrey Police but I was attached to the Met for 3 months when we took over Staines. Ahhh understand, why not? the wife does it all the time!!!!!!!
Again no, Tadpole isn't an anagram of Eat Plod LOL, but wish I'd thought of it!!
 
John
Yeah, Likewise, BTW Hows life in Spain? trumpet player friend of mine did some years in Spain, but he went back to blighty, didn't get enough gigs for the band he started. Good player, we played together for some years in the same band. How you getting on? playing gigs and that.

That's the trouble, in Spain, they don't need bands during the summer, 'cos the tourists are here, filling the bars. Winter time there's more work for bands, and that's to try and pull people in. Musicians (quite a few are in their 20's), on the whole, are on the bread line! Being retired, I have a wonderful life and wouldn't live anywhere else!!!!!!!!
I play R&B/Blues with four or five bands (all Spanish), but the only firm gig is on a Thursday night (12.30 kick off). It's then that the other guys come in and tell me of any other gigs. At the moment this week, it's Thursday and Friday night. The Spanish audiences are superb in their support, and really know how to party, especially in Alicante, where it's heaving at 2a.m.

John.
 
to whom are you referring Sunray?

I think I may well of meant those gentlemen who came across so unprofessional in the video ... Well I thought so anyway ...

For an advert for a product they were marketing - I thought it was very weak, lacked planing and preparation, wasn't very punchy and certainly didn't sell the product to any real success ...

David Sanborn was repeating much of what was said "rather parrot fashion" and to top it all - And this is my view and mine alone - I thought the whole thing came over as if they didn't really know how to do the job - using their own tool ...

I was referring to Mr Sanborn and the other chap ...

By the way - I thought the flip comment from David Sanborn saying "He was the village idiot" influenced my wording in my initial remarks ...
imgres
imgres
http://www.google.co.uk/imgres?imgu...e=5&ndsp=30&ved=1t:429,r:26,s:120&tx=15&ty=11


---------------------

Having re-read the original post by yourself zoots ...

I can see that you may have thought I was digging at you mate ...

I am very sorry - I should have made myself plainer and I can only say that I didn't ever consider that of you ... :blush:

Please accept my apologies for causing you concern ... I promise you my snipe was solely aimed at the video and its cast - not at you mate ...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I would never do that - I was just playfully summarising what some folks seem to be saying. I have never spent any money at all on trying to change the reeds that I have bought, just stick to certain brands which seem permanently playable - Francois Louis Excellence, Alexander DC, Marca Jazz and Rico Jazz Selects Unfiled, which I prepare in the way recommended on the Alexander Superial website - www.superial.com/mainten_breakin.html . I am always slightly wary of professional endorsements and will not be buying the new Saxworks Sanborn Alto mouthpiece at $500 either!

Apologies for any offence caused.
Kind regards
Tom😎

apologies for cutting in on conversation, just a quick thanks to Tom, for that link - I have tended to just blast away with new reeds and not gradually play them for longer periods

Regards

Lee
 
Sunray, I agree with you on the video. Maybe it's a good product, I've no idea. DS looked like he was on another planet, They made a lot of very little, and failed to show/discuss the notches or how to do the other side of the reed. Big fail for me, despite the big name endorsement.

And for the guys already using something else, like sandpaper/knives/blades, a good demo/statement of why it was so much better than their methods would have helped.
 
Tickling the lip stick ...

I must admit to searching for more information of the ReedGeek thingy - both on their "empty" website and via watching more endorsing videos on UTube ...

But after watching two or three more of "much of the same" low quality advertising and presentation ... 🙁

I got rather bored and left ... :confused:

I certainly won't bother buying one ...

Instead - I'm after a "Gold Plated" Johnboy tickling Blade - for the princely sum of £0.10 ... 🙂))
 
I must admit to searching for more information of the ReedGeek thingy - both on their "empty" website and via watching more endorsing videos on UTube ...

But after watching two or three more of "much of the same" low quality advertising and presentation ... 🙁

I got rather bored and left ... :confused:

I certainly won't bother buying one ...

Instead - I'm after a "Gold Plated" Johnboy tickling Blade - for the princely sum of £0.10 ... 🙂))

Hey Sunray, 'Gold Plated'? We could have one as an annual trophy. The guy who ruins the most reeds in a year, and provides the most beer on the day, WINS!
The presentation would be at your 'pile', with a marquee an'all :w00t:
Tom could provide the lamb for the spit roast :welldone

John :cheers:
 
I don’t get all this palaver about reeds! Geez! All I do to prepare a reed is:

1. Crack open a pack of Rico La Voz MS Tenor Reeds
2. Soak them all in lukewarm water for 5 minutes
3. Play them all mf or less for 5 minutes put them all in order of soft to hard
4. Next day play them all again for 5 minutes and place in my reed box
5. Any that are too hard, I push my thumb very gentle on the middle of the rear slope a few times – test playing after every push (which helps loosen the fibres up a tadge).
6. If the reed is still too hard then I take a ‘Reed Rush’ to the vamp!

Out of a box of ten reeds, 10 play! Viola! No reed is too soft ;}

Simples!

As for the Video I agree with Sunray, very unprofessional!

Happy blowing,

The Fozster 😎
 
I don’t get all this palaver about reeds! Geez! All I do to prepare a reed is:

1. Crack open a pack of Rico La Voz MS Tenor Reeds
2. Soak them all in lukewarm water for 5 minutes
3. Play them all mf or less for 5 minutes put them all in order of soft to hard
4. Next day play them all again for 5 minutes and place in my reed box
5. Any that are too hard, I push my thumb very gentle on the middle of the rear slope a few times – test playing after every push (which helps loosen the fibres up a tadge).
6. If the reed is still too hard then I take a ‘Reed Rush’ to the vamp!

Out of a box of ten reeds, 10 play! Viola! No reed is too soft ;}

Simples!

As for the Video I agree with Sunray, very unprofessional!

Happy blowing,

The Fozster 😎

Paul, it all depends on what you are prepared to accept in tonal quality, and how much effort you are putting into blowing the thing.
I have heard over the years lots of people playing the sax, and to be honest they could play the notes o.k. but you can hear from the lack of tone/vibrato, that the reeds are too hard and that they are blowing far harder than necessary, and they don't even know it.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom