Saxophones R&C vs Selmer SBA sopranino

They now show up. At the time I attempted access earlier, I received that message from YT, could not view. Perhaps related to my in a different area than you, and took time to be cached on their server near me?
That was my guess, that it's a region specific restriction
 
So I just had a chance to try out a Selmer Mark VI, and both the straight and curved Rampone horns.
Honestly, I preferred the Rampone, but I went home with the Selmer. They are both fantastic horns, but the Selmer seemed to have a darker sound with more core. More warm and maybe a bit richer. The Rampone was more vibrant and cutting.
However, since this horn will be for the Dutch Instrument Funds, and I will just be loaning it, it seemed like the Selmer was the better fit. Down the road if I get a chance to buy one for myself, I'll probably go for a Rampone, or maybe a Buescher or something.
The curved Rampone, unfortunately, didn't play that well. Maybe it just had leaks but the low notes didn't respond well and were quite out of tune. I've only heard positive things about these horns so I'd assume it's just a regulation issue. It's a super cool little horn though!
 
I just found this. A sopranino player records the same piece in two videos, one on a Selmer SBA and one on a Rampone & Cazzani.
Listening to both, to me, the Selmer SBA had a fuller, rounder sound than the R&C, seemed easier blowing. Did he use the same mouthpiece on both, or the one supplied with the instrument?

That may have made a difference. I gather though that once in one's possession, whether one or the other, would learn to make the owned one play its best by how they play it, maybe find a more suitable mouthpiece as a tweak, different reeds and their tweaks, etc. Then, really make it sing.
 
Here's a little comparison of two sopraninos. Confusingly not the twoin question....
I played mostly noodly to avoid showing my bad intonation too much. I'm just curious what yall think of the sound of these two horns.

Tried, but what came up was this:
You have not provided a valid SoundCloud URL. Learn more about using SoundCloud players.
 
I was able to open it here in US without difficulty, even without being logged into my SC account. I think it may be a regional thing, takes perhaps time to update / propagate to all regional servers? I had a similar earlier problem accessing his YT links shortly after he posted, but after a couple hours they were available.

Both recording sounded nice and clean. In the sopranino range, given the shorter tone hole spacing, the tolerances get tighter. My Venus Eb Sopranino "beginner" ebonite clarinet plays in the same range. I am glad to have it, is a total blast to play, IMHO a good doubling instrument for the struggling "Ramen eating" musician. It's tuning is not that great although I can play it in tune.

(I paid under US $100 some 10 or 12 years ago. Said the gold coloured keywork had blemishes, although mine since hasn't developed that, maybe I lucked out.)

Congrats on your purchases of these 2 fine examples of sopranino saxes, @john_dikeman , and listening I thought your intonation as well as tone was spot on. 😎
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,058
Messages
578,315
Members
8,127
Latest member
PJ2116
Back
Top Bottom