Saxophones Quiz: I bought this today... what saxophone came with it?

Bought in Japan on a whim, the UK seller plays alto but couldn't get on with tenor so packed it back up in its case.

99% mint condition, lovely pop test sound. I've yet to try it side by side with my MkI 62, but I'm strangely drawn to it over the rather "common" 62. I'll be interested to see if my meagre tenor abilities can show any differences. Plastic pearls on the 22 disliked, but once again I'm kinda loathed to change them to something nice.

I bought it from this one photo, thinking it would be scrappy and would be fodder for my new pads...

Screenshot 2023-04-22 at 22.50.10.png


Thought I'd maybe soda blast it same as its smaller cousin the knackered YAS-21 I bought a few months ago.
But that would be sacrilege!

Needs a new crook cork, but I have some...
 
Last edited:
22 neck cork replaced now, so I gave it a blow along with my 62 today.

After an hour switching between them... I couldn't tell any difference. The 62 has just been serviced by Paul Carrington. The 22 as it came out of the case after maybe ten years, but it plays perfectly.

20230427_182428.webp


I switched the 22's purple logo crook onto the 62 and the 62's black logo crook onto the 22. I thought I maybe preferred the 22's crook on both... they are different - the 22's has a solid rectangular profile brace under whereas the 62's has a shallow hollow brace. But I can't be certain which crook or horn I preferred and, unusually, I was playing well on tenor today (possible due to the 62 not having been serviced the previous time I played it).

20230427_182325.webp


So, I'm thinking I'm either not good enough to bring out the fine nuances of the 62, or there really is nothing to choose between them.

One thing... I do prefer the real MOP key touches on the 62 as I thought. The 22's plastic ones became slippery as always. They'd have to go.

Tricky one, which to keep? The 62 is fancier and ought to be better for me at some stage if I play more tenor. But the 22 has an unusual charm, being rarer here. I'll try them some more, perhaps record the same tune on each for you to critique.
 
Well, I did record a track on both (and messed up the recording levels) but in any case I decided the newcomer 22 shouldn't replace my 62, and so it's in Yardsale now.

I just couldn't bear to part with a MkI 62 every bit a minty as the 22. I know I'd regret it.

Mind you, I don't play tenor enough to justify one let alone the four I'm left with but those need work.

It was interesting to handle one of the original Japanese market horns though, and its reputation as an innovative horn at the time is now completely understood.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,578
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom