Playing the saxophone Practice ban

Colin the Bear

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,093
Location
Burnley bb9 9dn
Level
50yr self taught gigger
A professional saxophone player has had his practice ban overturned by magistrates in Bradford (City of Culture)
 
I'm loving the statement by the council's lawyer.. "wot? Me? No idea! It's my colleagues case and he's done a runner"

I wonder if it failed as a preexisting noise issues?

He is a professional musician who has, for many years, has practiced his bass saxophone at this property

The reporting is a bit thin.
 
English law is based a lot on precedent and if my memory serves me well there was a case a few years ago.
In London the owner of one apartment complained about the two children in the adjoining one playing the piano but the court said they had the right to practice.
I can't remember the exact details but no doubt it will be on the internet somewhere.
That didn't take long, a few others came up as well.

"District Judge Elizabeth Roscoe ruled at Westminster magistrates’ court that ‘Play is absolutely an entitlement unless its extent makes it a nuisance.’ She set a limit of five hours playing per day on Mondays to Saturdays between 9am and 9pm, with three hours on Sundays ending by 5pm, and up to 1030 pm on certain exceptional occasions.
This appears to be a precendetial judgement for all musicians, professional and amateur, who need to practise at home."
 
I think playing a bass saxophone enters into new territory that the law hasn't considered but in general, at least in London, you are allowed to practice a musical instrument between 10.00 am and 10 pm. You get people who bring these cases and they always lose and sometimes get lumbered with worse conditions than they had before. I know somebody who had this happen to him and he was the winner but the guy who brought the case was so aggressive that he just moved out anyway. I always stop at 20.00, time to make dinner, so anybody who wants to complain can go stuff themselves.
 
On a slightly related subject - Buskers banned after judge says public singing is 'psychological torture':

That picture shows what I dislike about some buskers, they 'claim' a large area on a public walkway and use amplification that can be heard 'miles away' and are quite simply a noisy nuisance.
 
The movie, Begin Again, had well done street playing. 👍👍
First time I heard the word busking, I thought they were talking about picking fresh corn, for the campfire.
Never heard an amp in Central Park, until the Pignose was unleashed.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom