Reeds Playing Tenor w/ Bari Reeds and Alto w/ Tenor reeds

Given that most of what we know of Plas Johnson is his studio performance, having a loud sound in a studio is not helpful because mics and preamps just overload and the engineer has to turn it down anyway.
I've never been in a studio and play on a recording!!!! I try to avoid microphones. Of course, a bari reed on tenor mpc gives me a different timbre. And I like that. I'm not searching for acceptance for my set-up. I do my thing; playing in the woodshed on my own, sometimes play at a blues&rock jam and hopefully to re-start our pubrock band. The only thing I've in common with Plas Johnson's that we both played Larry Williams song. Johnson in a studio, me on the floor in a pub/jam. And I borrow some licks and tricks. I don't try to copy, because Johnson is a heck of player! I can't see any wrong in doing this? Here is Plas Johnson playing with Sonny Lowery in a rockabilly influenced song called "Goodbye Baby Goodbye". Maybe Johnson did a double break? Playing sax in rockabilly and with bari reed on his tenor mpc. I don't know what kind of set-up Johnson played in 1958? I hope bari reeds because it makes the story even more interesting!!!!!
View: https://youtu.be/DWpJVef6vsk
 
Of course, a bari reed on tenor mpc gives me a different timbre.

Yes that to me would be the advantage. And the chances are it could be the different timbre that makes it louder.
And I borrow some licks and tricks. I don't try to copy, because Johnson is a heck of player! I can't see any wrong in doing this?

Absolutely not
 
And the chances are it could be the different timbre that makes it louder.
Depends what you mean with "louder"? I had/played a more "fat", "filthy", full-toned", "heavy", "juicy", "large", "more bottom", "open", "powerful", "punchy", "solid", "thick", "dark", "wide" ..... tone with a bari reed on my Rovner tenor. With tenor reed on tenor mpc I had a more "attackful", "bright", "brilliant", "compact", "cracking", "distinct", "hard", "hissing", "peppery", "pointed", "raucous", "screaming", "keen", "shrill" ...... tone. With or without bari reeds my tone was "bellow", "brutal", "coarse", "cutting", "explosive", "hard", "harsh", "intensive", "piercing", "rocky", "rough", "sharp" ..... because of the design of my mouthpiece (high baffle, wide tip opening). Yes, the timbre makes it "louder". But not loud as blowing into a microphone/ applied. With bari reed I was using the low and mid register more. And with less pressure as well,
 
Yes, the timbre makes it "louder". But not loud as blowing into a microphone/ applied.
Yes I mean louder gives the impression of being louder to the listener, even though the sound level may or may not actually be higher when measured. A mic increases the actual measurable sound level, ie decibels.

So some timbres may sound louder than others even when the measured level (volume) is the same
 
So by extension all one needs is a Sop which, depending on the size reed one uses, can saould like an Alto or a Tenor thus doing away with the need for those two saxes.

No because the normal fingered range is important

But I don’t think the quoted post was meant seriously anyway
 
Actually, to get to the main reason I just started using tenor reeds on Alto is that I don't have any Alto reeds harder than 3.5 when what I need is a 4, 4.5, or even a 5 for the mouthpiece I'm playing with here at home. Since years back I played at blues jams with Bari reeds on my Tenor and got great results, I decided to try the same larger-size concept on alto. Playing the larger/thicker Tenor reeds on alto means I can play down a cople of sizes (3.5 or 3 depending) which saves me from having to shell out for new alto ones. At the moment that's something that would not be good with the economy the way it is and will more than likely get in the New Year.
 
The beauty of using a reed one step up is that you have a reasonable chance of it fitting. Cutting a tenor reed to fit a soprano looks like a good way to cause some serious damage to your hands, and probably wouldn’t work anyway.
 
On a serious note, are those who use the wrong reed actually cutting them down? The few times I’ve done it and the few I’ve known to do it didn’t cut them, and they still worked fine.
 
The beauty of using a reed one step up is that you have a reasonable chance of it fitting. Cutting a tenor reed to fit a soprano looks like a good way to cause some serious damage to your hands, and probably wouldn’t work anyway.
I've been doing DIY repairs and construction for 69 years and the use of tools is second nature. Thanks for your concern but I'm not worried in the least. As to whether it is worth doing, that's what I expect to find out.
 
I've been doing DIY repairs and construction for 69 years and the use of tools is second nature. Thanks for your concern but I'm not worried in the least. As to whether it is worth doing, that's what I expect to find out.
I don’t see why it should but I look forward to hearing about your findings. They’ll need to be pretty special for it to be worth the trouble.
 
I've done this quite frequently over the years and find it gives me a fuller sound on both instruments. I see nothing wrong with it just like I play bass clarinet with tenor reeds like many people. It also comes in handy as a substitution when you don't have a reed hardness or type that you prefer. For example I don't have any 4 or 5 alto reeds right now so I'm using a tenor 5 instead. Plays great on alto whereas on tenor I can't use it except on my most closed mpcs.

Does anyone else do this? Just curious to see how many others do it too and what your experiences are.
Yes I’do play bari reed on tenor and tenor reed on alto.
im sure I read somewhere Johnny Hodges did this on his alto.
I find a much easier blow minimum effort maximum sound.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom