Reeds Playing Tenor w/ Bari Reeds and Alto w/ Tenor reeds

Going from Pete's perspective - has anyone tried somehow shaving back the vamp towards the butt on a reed to make the vamp longer? I appreciate this may be difficult to do accurately and consistently without some sort of jig.

It strikes me as the only functional difference that occurs with using a reed designed for a bigger instrument is that the thinner section of the reed laying against the table of the mouthpiece is longer which should make it vibrate differently - I'm thinking of an analogy like holding a ruler on the edge of the desk and 'twanging' it - the difference would be placing your finger that is holding the ruler in line with the edge of the desk versus moving it back away from the edge.
 
Going from Pete's perspective - has anyone tried somehow shaving back the vamp towards the butt on a reed to make the vamp longer? I appreciate this may be difficult to do accurately and consistently without some sort of jig.
All you need is some sandpaper.

But all the texts I've seen on reed softening says to stay away from the heart. I actually have that in the TTS article:


reed3.gif
 
A bari reed on a tenor mpc works best for me on a Rovner mpc.

Rovner is a long mpc so the reed is laying against the small table. I don't need to cut off the reed. I just file down/narrow the side of the reed to make it fit better. I use some kin of wet stone. Of course, the wet stone and the reed should be wet when you prepare reeds.

A ligature that leaves most of the reed open is also better for me.

I really can't explain what happens when I play a bari reed on my Rovner. I just get a bigger tone and I also play in a more relaxed way.

tenorvsbarireed.webp
barireedrovner.webp
MPC.webp
 
A ligature that leaves most of the reed open is also better for me
So maybe the vamp which extends past the facing curve is where there would normally be where the bark is. I suppose it's possible that this means there may be some vibrating going on there that could cause a difference. Who knows?
 
All you need is some sandpaper.

But all the texts I've seen on reed softening says to stay away from the heart. I actually have that in the TTS article:


reed3.gif
After looking at the profiles of different reeds, the cut in the heart area varies.
All the old school players insisted that any adjustment should stay away from the heart.
However me being me, I find a minimal heart scrape, on a french filed reed has a dramatic affect to bring a tough blow into a playable area, especially after clipping.
You can't ruin a reed that won't play.
 
All you need is some sandpaper.

But all the texts I've seen on reed softening says to stay away from the heart. I actually have that in the TTS article:


reed3.gif

I'm not talking about regular reed adjustment - I'm thinking specifically targeting the heart and extending the whole vamp section rearward
 
im sure I read somewhere Johnny Hodges did this on his alto.
On the Internet;
"Johnny Hodges used a Brilhart mouthpiece modified to implement a tenor reed. This gave him the ability to smear notes to an incredible minor 3rd.Aug 26, 2005"

Alto reed on alto and bari reed on tenor has been done by many players through the years going back to the big band era from some notes that I have read over the years. My dad played tenor in the swing era and he told me about it and said that some of the players had their m/p's modified for both volume and tone due to no PA systems for the bands. So adjustments have been around for a while.

Mr. Plas Johnson (on the "Pink Panther") was the first time I had heard about the reed change. It works for some players and not so for others. Once in a while you can see photos of players where the reed comes way back towards the neck cork indicating an oversized reed both on alto and tenor.

There are a lot of different setups by players that work for them but may not work for others; no octave key used in the upper range for split octaves, m/p turned to the right more than usual for more volume, neckpiece turned to the right more than usual for more volume, neck screw changed out for a larger one or the neckscrew not tightened at all to allow more vibration, tuning the m/p a bit higher for a very relaxed jaw for more volume and flexibility of gliss's, note bending and the list goes on. Some of these are not suggested for classical music performance.

Someone mentioned Mr. Earl Bostic using tenor reeds on alto. His drummer apparently indicated during an interview (on the Internet) that Mr. Bostic used alto reeds on alto. Historical notes also indicate that Mr. Bostic used a razor for a homemade baffle. So we may never know what is fact or fiction.

At any rate, if it works for you that is all that matters! :clapping: have a fun gig!
 
Isn’t the most likely reason going to be that the reed is bigger, therefore more reed is vibrating leading to a different sonority? At least nobody has asked for a scientific proof that they sound different.
 
Nah! But you can have my word. If that’s no good give it a try for yourself and then try to tell me you can’t hear a difference. Might change your life.
 
Based on another thread about using bari reeds on a tenor mouthpiece, posted a while ago... I gave it a go

What made me stop, after a few seconds, was the lip-pinching discomfort of the reed overlapping the mouthpiece table... And my sound was worse
 
Apologies if I missed it in the thread, but when I saw James Moody in the 90s/early oughts, he was playing a baritone reed on tenor. I've dabbled with it, and it seems to spread the tone a bit, but in a way that would only be really apparent to the player. The web seems to have infused the gearhead mentality to a ridiculous point in some regards. Going back to the OP, try it. If you like it, do it. Please YOUR ears, first. That's really all that matters.
 
Jimmy Ford story:

One night on the bandstand Jimmy leaned over to the bari player and snapped "Gimme a reed!" The bari player, wondering what an alto player wanted with a baritone reed, handed him one - whereupon Jimmy whipped out a little carton of ice cream and ate it using the baritone reed as a spoon.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom