Reeds Plastic reeds

Synthetic reeds come in all sorts these days : I have tried many: Fibracell, Bari, Legere, Woodstone and Hartmann.

They are all good ,fit to a purpose, one way or other, but they are all rather different among themselves and compared to any cane.

The Bari has to be the oldest one (in terms of concept) of the group. I bought it because it was the cheapest synthetic baritone reed for me and I wanted to try a loud reed. The reed was very narrow and performed not very well on the mouthpieces that I had, it didn't really help my efforts on a Baritone and I hated it. I then gave to someone who then used it on a tenor.

I first used fibracell many years ago, when I first went into saxophone playing , the reed suited my " style" which was, at that time, playing as loud as possible (oh foolish days !) with a Berg Larsen mouthpiece, it certainly did that ! I have acquired another one later for my tenor. I keep it in my reed holder, just in case, I take it out and try it every now and again, then I remember why I put it there and didn't use it in the first place and quickly put it back where it belongs ,again.

Legere and Foreststone are rather similar although the colour of the second is said to have been determined by bamboo dust in the synthetic compound.........I rather doubt that that is the only reason for the colour. They are way " softer" than other synthetic reeds and in my opinion a very good reed substitute . They can be a tad on the soft (sound-wise) side for one's taste but I generally like them. Watch out with the choice of strength they are , in general, thicker than what you think. Some shops have a trial policy and if you have some sort of proof of your purchase you can in many countries but not everywhere, exchange them by paying a small fee.

Hartmann Carbon fibre was bought on a Whim and it is a very special reed. If you look for the " buzz" in a reed this is it! But it is a very particular sound resembling somehow a better version of a fibracell. The Reed is very hard indeed and has relatively sharp edges , the tip can chip off and Hartmann will replace it if you have bought your reed, as I did, directly from them.

Legere and Hartmann have both replaced their reeds easily with me , I must commend their customer's care!
 
Here's what I wrote on "the other forum" about my experience with Forestone:

I am trying a Forestone bari reed at the moment, in strenght F2.5. Usually I play LaVoz MH, and strenghtwise these seem to be comparable. I am not convinced yet (after two weeks of trying). Compared to a cane reed, the Forestone feels slick and a bit lifeless, but I can live with that. However, I don't really like the response and sound. "Boomy" is the first English word that comes to my mind in describing them. It lacks the subtleness of a good cane reed. It makes the sound bigger, especially in the lower register, but also less complex.

Since I am only trying one reed, I don't know yet how consistent they are.
 
I have posted previously about Hahn reeds, which were great for the band as they were so loud and free blowing, trouble i found is that they don'y have much finesse.
I have a plasticover and dont like it at all.
Recently use a legere synthetic, started with a 2.25 but moved up to a 3 which i find works for me. But honestly i still prefer my vandoren java 3's. They are tonally more acceptable to my ear. But that is my preference.
I do use the legere as it does give my chops a good workout but for the band and doing solos i think i will stick with the Vandorens.
Something i have noticed is that as i improve i can generally get more out of older reeds which i previously had problems with, maybe that is why now i am more discerning.
But as i said this is only my personal experience.
Phil
 
I would recommend Bari reeds to anyone - ive been playing them 6 years or so - they just work and sound ok for my RnR ska gigs.
BUT i don;t think anyone should try plastic reeds until they have been playing at least 3/4 years - you should just try and play cane first..
Just my opinion
 
I had Bari* reeds on both Alto and Tenor for a while. They played easily enough but just did not like the tone of them compared to the reeds I used - little bit too sterile. Useful as a practice tool, though, and a good back up reed.

Kind regards
Tom
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway πŸ˜€

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,569
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom