Miscellaneous Phil Collins calls it a day

rudjarl

Senile Member. Scandinavian Ambassadour of CaSLM
Messages
475
Location
Løten, Norway
Phil Collins is retiring

Sad, but in many ways a happier ending of a musical career than many of the other greats we have heard of lately.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The only thing wrong with your post, Mr. Norwegian CaSLM Ambassador, is the word "sad".

Due to the fact that Nordic people, and Norwegians in particular, are slightly less sophisticated (apparently) than proper Brits, the word sad stands. Tremendous though the High Council of the CaSLM might be, I feel that marking the end of Phil Collins career as 'not sad' is a neglect of all the memorable moments he has given us. (Sadly, none of which I'm able to mention at the moment.) 🙂))
 
My favourite Phil Collins track (and there aren't many I like) is 'I wish it would rain' with Eric Clapton on lead guitar...

Collins is a good musician, but not really my style. Saw him once about 15 years ago, he had an amazing horn section, and a second drummer who was as good (better?) than him. Concert left me cold, though.
 
Etiquette, OG. Ambassadors are not "Mr", they are either Your Excellency or Sir.

As to Phil Collins, quite a good drummer and average singer. Some not bad songs. Didn't do justice to Groovy Kind of Love, but then neither did anyone from Dianne and Annita, the Mindbenders or anyone else who covered it do justice to Clementi's beautifully simple melody.
YC
 
When I saw him on Jools Holland's "Later" I thought that his voice had gone (just like Marianne Faithful, Neil Diamond and others) so I'm not surprised. After Gabriel left Genesis was no longer the same, though I did like some of his later stuff - "Roof is Leaking" - but too MOR overall

Tom
 
I can't imagine why Phil Collins attracts so much bad feeling, even on this forum,he has always been a great favourite of mine and when we go touring in the old jallopy his cd's are a must take and great listening. Why does everyone want to knock him?...john
 
Cos he is Phil Collins and seriously uncool..............:shocked::w00t:;}

Next question...................

Love
Tom


I remember asking my wife (3 years my junior) who it was that was performing the music she had just put on the cassette deck. "Genesis", she replied. "No it is not", I proclaimed. She showed me the cassette box. I was confused.......:shocked:;}
 
I can't imagine why Phil Collins attracts so much bad feeling, even on this forum,he has always been a great favourite of mine and when we go touring in the old jallopy his cd's are a must take and great listening. Why does everyone want to knock him?...john

For me it's not music, just noise, sorry but my point of view. I don't care about cool or not (sorry Tom), just what turns me on - or off in his case.
 
I loved early Genesis and when Gabriel left whoever came next was a sitting duck. I saw his last solo tour "in the round" when he came to Geordie Land and although i went because my wife wanted to go, the band were sensational and he was ok too. He was clever enough to have a light show beyond belief which complimented the show rather than being the show.

How about this though but, on the last Genesis tour the band hadn't played live for 14 years and over 200,000 people turned up to see them in Roma. Quite a legacy. Or is it? Over to you guys.
 
I can't imagine why Phil Collins attracts so much bad feeling, even on this forum,he has always been a great favourite of mine

Well, he's never been a great favourite of mine but I am surprised that a forum made up of people who are, or profess to be, musicians can barely bring themselves to even grudgingly acknowledge that, like his commercial records or not, he is at least a very accomplished and successful one who has also brought a lot of work for other musicians, not least sax players.

Personally, I wish him the best and I am sure he will not spend his retirement fretting over whether he was ever cool or not.
 
Spot on ...

Well said mate ... :thankyou:

PS - I don't really like or dislike him or his music ...

But I certainly acknowledge his success and with it the joy that many others gain from it ...

Cor ... I'm starvin ... (())
 
Well, he's never been a great favourite of mine but I am surprised that a forum made up of people who are, or profess to be, musicians

Not me, Squire. I play at playing the saxophone, flute, guitar, banjo, keyboard, melodeon and EWI.

As for Mr. Collins financial success, no argument but does that mean we all have to like his style and products? You write that you don't. One man's meat is another man's poison but enough of the cliches, the original remarks were, no doubt, intended to be humorous.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,576
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom