Tech/maintenance Pad opening adjustment: altissimo F / E

MandyH

Sax-Mad fiend!
Messages
3,245
Location
The Malverns, Worcs
Hi all

I am working on a piece which goes …C E F E C A …above the stave.
It seems the neatest fingering to achieve this uses the front fork F and E.
But whilst the F sounds fine, the E is awful.
I’ve noticed that the pad near the top of the sax which opens wide on the F palm key barely opens at all on the fork F.

Is this something that I can rectify at home?
Or does it need lots of tech balancing work?

My sax is booked in for a service in 6 weeks time, but I’d like to start practicing this fingering now.

Thanks.
 
Solution
Is this something that I can rectify at home?
This is like that on purpose and is supposed to work better like that. It is not acting like a normal key opening, rather it acts like an octave pip vent to interfere with the sound wave and create an overtone. The top F is an overtone of A (don't ask why the interval is a minor 6th not a 5th, I don't know but probably due to some acoustic anomaly.)

The E is often out, it probably wasn't even considered when the aux F was invented.

But it may be worth messing with some bits of cork to see what you can do....

See here for more info:


Also see a post by jbtsax here...
Is this something that I can rectify at home?
This is like that on purpose and is supposed to work better like that. It is not acting like a normal key opening, rather it acts like an octave pip vent to interfere with the sound wave and create an overtone. The top F is an overtone of A (don't ask why the interval is a minor 6th not a 5th, I don't know but probably due to some acoustic anomaly.)

The E is often out, it probably wasn't even considered when the aux F was invented.

But it may be worth messing with some bits of cork to see what you can do....

See here for more info:


Also see a post by jbtsax here:


And



In my Saxophone High Tones book by Eugene Rousseau, he actually advise a modification to make the aux F open less in order to improve the note
aux-f-vent-key-mod.jpg
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 1
Solution
Each saxophone works best with a particular opening of that pad. Some of mine like it pretty fully open, others like it just barely cracked open. The "best" setting of this is a compromise amongst tuning and response of the four notes most concerned with it: E, F, F#, and G.

Unlike Pete's experience I find front E to be a thick-toned note with good projection. Its tuning varies amongst my different horns, from not very good to spot-on.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
On my SX90 tenor the front F needs to open as much as it does when using the palm key F,
If not those front F altissimo played E, F and F# notes don't sound clean and play a little flat.
Fiddle about, fiddle about. 😀 😱
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
On my SX90 tenor the front F needs to open as much as it does when using the palm key F,
If not those front F altissimo played E, F and F# notes don't sound clean and play a little flat.
Fiddle about, fiddle about. 😀 😱
I have (so far) trialled a smidge of folded paper to pack out the cork, which worked well.
Then I tied a few wraps of extra thick sewing thread around the F rocker arm, where the cork leans against it. That seems to be doing the job for the moment. So hopefully will be enough until the tech can get his hands on it.

My F pad seemed to need to be open quite wide to get a large sound on the E (it was previously sounding like I had the sax in a bucket of socks :rofl: )
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Each saxophone works best with a particular opening of that pad. Some of mine like it pretty fully open, others like it just barely cracked open. The "best" setting of this is a compromise amongst tuning and response of the four notes most concerned with it: E, F, F#, and G.

Unlike Pete's experience I find front E to be a thick-toned note with good projection. Its tuning varies amongst my different horns, from not very good to spot-on.

This is also my experience of front E.... however, I also have a horn where the F key opens quite far with the fork. This makes G and F# harder, however I got around that by practising them just cracking the F slightly via the palm key and fingering a B until I had the voicing down, then gradually opening up the F more. Now I can hit G and F# well via the fork even with it opening quite far.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
This is like that on purpose and is supposed to work better like that.

Fiddle about, fiddle about.

My F pad seemed to need to be open quite wide to get a large sound on the E
So it seems it's a case of trial and error. Although the science says it should just be open a smidge, people are finding in reality it can be the other way.

One thing that's worth bearing in mind is that for this note, the octave key should not be open. That's because it's an unnecessary vent as the octave key is there to facilitate the 1st overtone, whereas this venting key is there for the (albeit semitone sharp) 2nd overtone.

Oh how we miss jbtsax.
 
Vote:
Upvote 1
Is this something that I can rectify at home?
It needs to be that way.
If the key opens too far, high notes don't work.
This is especially true for Altissimo G and G#.

See this thread:


BTW:
One could also finger High E with G# with OK and High E key (right top side key) and F by opening ring finger.

How E sounds with Aux Key also depends on how large the tone hole is.
(It's small on Mark VI, Yamaha and large on new Selmers and Yanagisawas). So E with Aux fingering sounds really awful and very sharp on some horns.
That goes for Tenor, I think it is better on Alto.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
The notes are all semiquavers, so the E and F will indeed only be a fleeting note. But the fingerings will be far less clunky that trying to do all the palm keys.
Personally I find the front keys to be clunky with chromatic movement and prefer the palm keys. But the main consideration for me is matching the tone of a palm D, D#, say, against the front E.

I was wrong to describe the tone of my front E as “poor” (@turf3) - more that it bothers me when compared to the D for example. Front F doesn’t bother me in the same way. It seems less of an anomaly on tenor compared to alto.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Personally I find the front keys to be clunky with chromatic movement and prefer the palm keys. But the main consideration for me is matching the tone of a palm D, D#, say, against the front E.

I was wrong to describe the tone of my front E as “poor” (@turf3) - more that it bothers me when compared to the D for example. Front F doesn’t bother me in the same way. It seems less of an anomaly on tenor compared to alto.
Well, the tone and response of the front E are inherently going to be different than those of palm key D#; in one case you're playing the first harmonic (octave) of a note formed by a very short tube, and in the other you're playing a second harmonic (octave and a half) of a longer note (G) which is also forced sharp by the large size of the tone hole you're using as a vent.

Front F is much the same, but where front E sounds a whole step sharp from its theoretical pitch, front F sounds only a half step sharp - so we can expect the characteristics of even these two notes to be different.

As I always say, "your assignment as a musician, should you choose to accept it, is to PRACTICE until the tone quality and pitch of each note played with each of its alternate fingerings matches as closely as possible those of its neighbors." Clarinetists accept this assignment with alacrity and assiduously woodshed the break between throat A and Bb and all-closed B and C, until they can get a good clear open tone on all. Saxophonists are spoiled; our instrument is so good that we just assume fiddling around with the equipment can fix everything. Nope, still gotta PRACTICE.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,524
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom