Tech/maintenance Octave mechanism has taken a knock

saxmad

Member
Messages
110
Location
North Norfolk
As can be seen from the photo, the mechanism is out of alignment - would you carefully bend it back into position or apply heat and bend it back? I personally consider gentle bending but welcome opinions.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0644.webp
    IMG_0644.webp
    44.2 KB · : 293
Gentle bending is the way. Heat is useless - unless you get the part up to red heat (not advised).
Best bet would be to remove the swivel arm first though, and to use parallel-jawed pliers. Skimp on these two caveats and you'll dramatically increase the chance of snapping the key.

More stuff here:

 
It's hard to tell without seeing it for real, but from the picture, I would most likely try to bring it back straight. It doesn't look that bad. I'm no expert, like Stephen, but if there are no signs of fatigue in the metal piece, it will probably come back without damage.

For me, the tell tale sign of danger is fatigue, cracks around the bent area. If there are any, don't do it yourself. Get a tech look at it.

Just my to cents! 😳
 
As can be seen from the photo, the mechanism is out of alignment - would you carefully bend it back into position or apply heat and bend it back? I personally consider gentle bending but welcome opinions.

If you have to ask, then the safest course is to take it to someone with the correct tools and experience. This type of damage is common to saxophones that are put in their cases without an end plug or similar protection.

As Stephen notes, it is best to remove the part before trying to bend it back to "straight".
 
It's hard to tell without seeing it for real, but from the picture, I would most likely try to bring it back straight. It doesn't look that bad. I'm no expert, like Stephen, but if there are no signs of fatigue in the metal piece, it will probably come back without damage.

For me, the tell tale sign of danger is fatigue, cracks around the bent area. If there are any, don't do it yourself. Get a tech look at it.

Just my to cents! 😳
Fatigue occurs due to repeated loading, but cracks can occur in a single instance.

The problem with bending the part back to position without removing it is the loading that occurs on the related parts. You may bend other posts and related parts that were not previously damaged.

Do no (more) harm.
 
Fatigue occurs due to repeated loading, but cracks can occur in a single instance.
Please forgive my french. Fatigue was the only term that came to mind after a long day at work... Anyway, I guess the idea is there.

I'm tempted to apply a saying I learned from Normandy that would translate in 'beware, beware more, beware always...'
 
My mentor taught me an alternative method of straightening brass parts. That is to repeatedly tap the piece in the direction you want it to move similar to dent removal in brass instruments. This moves the metal in many tiny increments and reduces the chance of cracking or breaking.

Tapping on the section that needs to be restored is useful because the bent region is work-hardened and thus more resistant to bending again; the adjacent unbent region will bend more easily. Tapping does not substantially reduce the potential for fatigue, as the mechanism of fatigue directly corresponds to the accumulated plastic strain. Tapping does induce some measure of compressive residual stress at the surface that will impede fatigue crack growth.
 
Tapping on the section that needs to be restored is useful because the bent region is work-hardened and thus more resistant to bending again; the adjacent unbent region will bend more easily. Tapping does not substantially reduce the potential for fatigue, as the mechanism of fatigue directly corresponds to the accumulated plastic strain. Tapping does induce some measure of compressive residual stress at the surface that will impede fatigue crack growth.
Thanks Dr. G. That's everything I needed to know and more. 🙂
 
Thanks Dr. G. That's everything I needed to know and more. 🙂

Hah, yes! I still find mechanisms of mechanical deformation and failure fascinating after all these years. I actually discussed the effects of total deformation vs total plastic deformation in my dissertation (last century). I currently work with a firm whose expertise is evaluating residual stresses. Feel free to reach out if/when you discover that you need to know any more.

Now where’s that hammer???
 
The problem with knocking such a key back into shape is that the bent portion will be fractionally harder than the rest of the key - and what can happen is that as you tap the key, it moves at its softest point rather than in the area where the bend is.
The key ('scuse pun) to realigning a bent key properly is to support those softer areas to ensure they don't bend....rather than the bit you're trying to straighten out.

That's the theory. In practice you take each bent key on an individual basis, making the most appropriate judgement call depending on a subtle blend of experience and extreme violence. In the vast majority of cases you'll be fine just having at it with (ideally) a couple of pairs of pliers - but the modern octave pin key is a tricky case because of the hole drilled in the key arm. It'll either break at this point, or at the joint with the key barrel.
And yeah, sometimes tapping with mallet is the best solution...though I always don the old belt and braces and support part of the key with parallel-jawed pliers.
At least for repairs in-situ. With the key removed I head straight for the bench press..
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,610
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom