Intonation Not in tune one octave higher...

Benoit

Member
Messages
6
Hi there,
I have been checking my tuning recently and as I do not struggle at all in the low register on my alto, as soon as I hit the octave key my notes are too high. As far as I know, I am not changing my embouchure but that might be where actually I am making a mistake ?

Thanks in advance for any help on this.

Regards,
/Benoit
 
The causes can be several.

A not proper setup of the horn can make the relative intonation of the different octave of the instrument not "relatively" in tune.

And of course a "bad embouchure" (too loose or "pinching" too much) sure doesn't make the intonation even, across the whole instrument.

Regarding the mouthpiece/reed combination... it's difficult to say because it's very subjective.
One test to do... is surely to change the reed or/and the mouthpiece and see what happens.
And (of course) another thing to do to retune the instrument with different notes (for example tune a lower note, like a low E or a low F#).

Also to check if switching from the lower octave and mid octave (example low D ---> mid D... mid A ---> high A) without the octave have an influence.


If the Yamaha has not been really really badly setup... I wouldn't address the issue to the horn.
But a "not good" mouthpiece/reed combination surely doesn't help.
 
Last edited:
Most likely is that the mouthpiece is in the wrong position. Use a tuner and adjust the mouthpiece position so the octaves are the same amount out, sharp or flat, doesn't matter. Once you have this, check over the range of the sax. Then adjust your embouchure to get the right pitch.

What may help as well is to play just the mouthpiece and check the pitch. There are quite a few posts giving 'ideal' mouthpiece pitch, especially from @jbtsax. This will give you a good idea if whether your embouchure is to tight or too loose.

In general you shouldn't be adjusting embouchure for octaves.
 
How wide of an interval can you play on the mouthpiece alone? If you can't slur at least an octave on just the mouthpiece, you'll not have control of your sound and pitch.

How is the pitch when you match overtones (e.g., B3 with B1 fingering)?

That's a pretty middling setup, the problem is almost certainly not that/
 
There is a natural pitch tendency on saxophones that is common to most makes and models simply because of the acoustic tendencies of the instrument and the design compromises that need to be made. More about these can be found in "The Art of Saxophone Playing" by Larry Teal along with fingerings that can help.
  • Low D - slightly flat
  • Middle C# - flat
  • D2 - quite sharp
  • Eb2 - slightly sharp
  • E2 - slightly sharp
  • G2 - slightly sharp
  • G#2 - sharp
  • A2 - very sharp
  • C3 - sharp
  • C#3 - very sharp
On alto I like to tune to low F# (A concert), checking the octave with and without the octave key and fingering low B and overblowing to the 2nd overtone. For embouchure tension I like to play the mouthpiece and neck (crook) alone. The pitch should be Ab concert. When all of these are in place. Then I do one or more of the following to work on the intonation of individual notes (and registers).
  1. Play long tones going up chromatically using a visual tuner.
  2. Play scales along with a fixed pitch instrument listening and matching pitch.
  3. Play scales, etc. along with a "drone" to tune intervals.
I used to tell my students after they tuned their instrument, "Congratulations. You have one note in tune. For all the rest you will have to listen and adjust."
 
Well, well, thanks a lot for your inputs. I was able to confirm that there was no issue with the instrument at all... My embouchure technique is to blame. Although I thought I was not changing anything from the low to the high register by focusing on this issue I could nail it.

The only thing that remains quite clear to me is that I need to be really careful in the high register because I can really be too sharp while in the low register it is always spot on.

Thanks !
 
There is a natural pitch tendency on saxophones that is common to most makes and models simply because of the acoustic tendencies of the instrument and the design compromises that need to be made. More about these can be found in "The Art of Saxophone Playing" by Larry Teal along with fingerings that can help.
  • Low D - slightly flat
  • Middle C# - flat
  • D2 - quite sharp
  • Eb2 - slightly sharp
  • E2 - slightly sharp
  • G2 - slightly sharp
  • G#2 - sharp
  • A2 - very sharp
  • C3 - sharp
  • C#3 - very sharp
On alto I like to tune to low F# (A concert), checking the octave with and without the octave key and fingering low B and overblowing to the 2nd overtone. For embouchure tension I like to play the mouthpiece and neck (crook) alone. The pitch should be Ab concert. When all of these are in place. Then I do one or more of the following to work on the intonation of individual notes (and registers).
  1. Play long tones going up chromatically using a visual tuner.
  2. Play scales along with a fixed pitch instrument listening and matching pitch.
  3. Play scales, etc. along with a "drone" to tune intervals.
I used to tell my students after they tuned their instrument, "Congratulations. You have one note in tune. For all the rest you will have to listen and adjust."
@jbtsax Would it be possible to offer any advice on the following please.
I have some issues with middle D being very sharp, I have followed the above, The pitch with just the neck is spot on Ab concert, Fingering low B is spot on as is overtone F#, Low F# I am a little flat, Middle F# I am spot on. but when I go to Middle D, I am very, very sharp, it is improved without using the Octave key. Do you think this is totally down to me, or can you suggest making any adjustments to the Horn. Thank you for any suggestions you may be able to offer.
 
D2 is always sharp. The way you voice it can help. Not much you can do do bend this note but the way you voice it can make it sound less obviously sharp. If D is the key I'm playing in I pull out a little to get tonic sounding right and bend the rest in. You can always try the side key for D3 without the octave key.

Checking the saxophone against a tuner is always disappointing. The whole personality of the saxophone sound can be one of being slightly out of tune and sliding and bending. Sometimes not quite getting there before moving on and sometimes slipping into the next note.

We have picked an imperfect instrument. In this age of digital accuracy it's easy to get distracted by tonal precision and forget the musical aspect.
 
D2 is always sharp. The way you voice it can help. Not much you can do do bend this note but the way you voice it can make it sound less obviously sharp. If D is the key I'm playing in I pull out a little to get tonic sounding right and bend the rest in. You can always try the side key for D3 without the octave key.

Checking the saxophone against a tuner is always disappointing. The whole personality of the saxophone sound can be one of being slightly out of tune and sliding and bending. Sometimes not quite getting there before moving on and sometimes slipping into the next note.

We have picked an imperfect instrument. In this age of digital accuracy it's easy to get distracted by tonal precision and forget the musical aspect.
Thanks Colin, I am not blessed with great ears so I have recently been using a tuner, you are right it was disappointing. I'll have to try and find a acceptable balance.
 
Thanks Colin, I am not blessed with great ears so I have recently been using a tuner, you are right it was disappointing. I'll have to try and find a acceptable balance.
Sounds to me like the best thing you can do for your tuning/intonation is to work on your ear. Unless you have some physical hearing problem (and maybe even then, I don't know) it's possible to make great improvements in your sense of pitch by practising. These days I spend at least as much time on ear training as on sax practice and it has really paid off over the years.. When you can hear the note you want to play in your head, you will start correcting what your instrument is trying to do without even being aware of how you're doing it.
 
Sounds to me like the best thing you can do for your tuning/intonation is to work on your ear. Unless you have some physical hearing problem (and maybe even then, I don't know) it's possible to make great improvements in your sense of pitch by practising. These days I spend at least as much time on ear training as on sax practice and it has really paid off over the years.. When you can hear the note you want to play in your head, you will start correcting what your instrument is trying to do without even being aware of how you're doing it.
I do use an app called functional ear training, which is definitely helping,. I can sing a note I hear within a couple of cents, just started doing this and I can sing an octave within a couple of cents,. I'll now start singing other intervals. But I don't really hear it when I am playing. What sort of ear training do you do?
 
What sort of ear training do you do?
Theres a nice piece of software calles EarMaster. It's availabe (but not free) on Windows and iOS. I don't know what other platforms. I've mostly worked on interval and chord recognition, and especially melodic dictation: pick a scale, hear the keynote followed by a few notes from the scale and identify the notes. There are some free exercies available online, too:

Teoria ear traing exercises
 
@jbtsax Would it be possible to offer any advice on the following please.
I have some issues with middle D being very sharp, I have followed the above, The pitch with just the neck is spot on Ab concert, Fingering low B is spot on as is overtone F#, Low F# I am a little flat, Middle F# I am spot on. but when I go to Middle D, I am very, very sharp, it is improved without using the Octave key. Do you think this is totally down to me, or can you suggest making any adjustments to the Horn. Thank you for any suggestions you may be able to offer.

I have had some success lowering the low C key a bit to make the D2 less sharp. The trade off is that it can make low D a bit stuffy. Another if you are up to it is to put a crescent in the low C tonehole to move it down a bit. There are a couple of fingering tricks one can use to bring the pitch of the D2 down on long notes in the music:

  • Add the low B key
  • Substitute the D palm key for the octave key
The most often used pitch adjustment of course is the embouchure/voicing. When I get to D going up a G scale, I drop my jaw a bit, open my teeth, and think "AHHH". The important thing to do is to not get used to the D's sharpness. My teacher has me practice scales using a "drone" pitch on the tonic in order to hear and tune the intervals---an exercise that has helped my intonation a lot.
 
There is a natural pitch tendency on saxophones that is common to most makes and models simply because of the acoustic tendencies of the instrument and the design compromises that need to be made. More about these can be found in "The Art of Saxophone Playing" by Larry Teal along with fingerings that can help.
  • Low D - slightly flat
  • Middle C# - flat
  • D2 - quite sharp
  • Eb2 - slightly sharp
  • E2 - slightly sharp
  • G2 - slightly sharp
  • G#2 - sharp
  • A2 - very sharp
  • C3 - sharp
  • C#3 - very sharp
On alto I like to tune to low F# (A concert), checking the octave with and without the octave key and fingering low B and overblowing to the 2nd overtone. For embouchure tension I like to play the mouthpiece and neck (crook) alone. The pitch should be Ab concert. When all of these are in place. Then I do one or more of the following to work on the intonation of individual notes (and registers).
  1. Play long tones going up chromatically using a visual tuner.
  2. Play scales along with a fixed pitch instrument listening and matching pitch.
  3. Play scales, etc. along with a "drone" to tune intervals.
I used to tell my students after they tuned their instrument, "Congratulations. You have one note in tune. For all the rest you will have to listen and adjust."
This is great advice. I have been following this procedure for the last 3 months or so and my intonation and tone have improved dramatically. Thank you so much, @jbtsax .
 
I have had some success lowering the low C key a bit to make the D2 less sharp. The trade off is that it can make low D a bit stuffy. Another if you are up to it is to put a crescent in the low C tonehole to move it down a bit. There are a couple of fingering tricks one can use to bring the pitch of the D2 down on long notes in the music:

  • Add the low B key
  • Substitute the D palm key for the octave key
The most often used pitch adjustment of course is the embouchure/voicing. When I get to D going up a G scale, I drop my jaw a bit, open my teeth, and think "AHHH". The important thing to do is to not get used to the D's sharpness. My teacher has me practice scales using a "drone" pitch on the tonic in order to hear and tune the intervals---an exercise that has helped my intonation a lot.

I have made a temporary crescent using Blu Tack and it has helped, do you think the tuning of this recording sounds acceptable, it is recorded on my phone, that the limit of my technology.

Many Thanks
Russ

recording-20180527-091951.mp3
 
It sounds good on that recording. The D does have a bit of a "closed" sound, especially next to the C# with is so open sounding. Everything having to do with tuning a sax has to do with "compromise" in my experience. You may want to check the pitch of the low D before you make the "crescent" more permanent. Of course if the low D is too flat you can always add the low C# key to open it up a bit.

I am going to steal your "blu tack" idea. Thanks for sharing that.
 
It sounds good on that recording. The D does have a bit of a "closed" sound, especially next to the C# with is so open sounding. Everything having to do with tuning a sax has to do with "compromise" in my experience. You may want to check the pitch of the low D before you make the "crescent" more permanent. Of course if the low D is too flat you can always add the low C# key to open it up a bit.

I am going to steal your "blu tack" idea. Thanks for sharing that.
Thanks, I'm pleased you've got something from me and it's not all one way
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,064
Messages
578,438
Members
8,130
Latest member
tommyliehe
Back
Top Bottom