Miscellaneous NEWBIE dilemma

Thanks guys, really helpful comments and thanks Mike for giving me some idea how the Dutch system you followed is a bit different. I was beginning to think that the path I’m currently on is helping me to understand the instrument and therefore jbtsax’s observations definitely are a help. I just need to work on my first hat before the second I guess.
 
"I have the great privilege of producing and working with a fabulous female vocalist. She was asked to do a poppu jazzy gig a few weeks ago along with the top bass call in our area and one of the top drummers. The leader keyboard/songwriter/errrr?singer? graduated from Berklee a year ago. After the first rehearsal she asked my advice as the leader was telling her she wasn't singing it exactly as written. She had won the position in a competitive audition. I told her to tell him, if he needed it sung exactly as written, he should get a classically trained vocalist and gave a few names. They are absolutely fabulous at singing as written but he kept on with her. A total of 3 rehearsals for the concert.

At the gig, which I video'd, the bass player and drummer both had to focus entirely on the extremely complicated charts as did the vocalist. It sounded pretty good BUT, if he had given most of the bass parts as cord charts (other than those bits that tryuly needed written notes)and the drummer the feel other than those few buts where it would be necessary for all to play the dots the concert would have been much more freely expressive. We had a good laugh after as I told both I never seen them work/concentrate so hard. I have the jo of playing with the bass player in a project ( some guitar and some sax)

Being able to read well and play in a big band (orchestral) environment is a very different skill set from being able to play in a combo. IMO the most important skill is to be able to put almost all your focus on what others are playing and add something that contributes artistically to what is being played (which even includes multi bar rests at times LOL)

In the end you kinda have to decide where you want to go with music, Mastery is a challenging and time consuming enterprise and mastering more than one style is a very siginificant amount of time and effort.

FWlittleIW I started playing music professionally in 1965 and have on and off continued, though after the first few years didn't like being poor so went on to for me more lucrative endeavours. In 05 I retired and went back to music as my avocation.
 
Last edited:
In the end you kinda have to decide where you want to go with music, Mastery is a challenging and time consuming enterprise and mastering more than one style is a very siginificant amount of time and effort.
Agree. Forget Eddie Daniels - he's a freak.
 
I'll post in my 'musings' thread a Youtube link to the very mixed gig I did 18 months ago at Symphony Hall in Birmingham
Are you posting the gig as proof that you can cross genre? Exciting gig to be part of especially as an amateur player - but this isn’t crossing musical boundaries, it’s just adding an orchestra to pop music. Stylistically nothing is different.
Eddie Daniels and Benny Goodman both made very good concerto recordings. Much better than the ridiculous Menuhin collaboration with Grappelli or all the “jazz” recordings that have infiltrated light classical music radio stations like the jazz album by Emma Johnson (what an ego!) or the silliness in this field from John Harle.
The original point along these lines was made with regard to a high level, if you play for enjoyment then play anything and everything.
 
Hi Zugzwang, thanks. A couple of questions; when you undertook the audition did you have any grades at all or that you’d been playing a long time and was therefore able to assess yourself against a grade 5 syllabus before taking the audition? Also, the workload that you point out for both the workshop and the community band seems high. How many hours a week was/is that taking up?
Well, first I should say, I put the word audition in quotes, because neither were actual Play-on-your-own-and-be-judged situations - they let me come along, and as the workshop leader put it - "I'll tell you if you need a term or two more practice".
I've never studied for grades, and regrettably have only taken a handful of lessons (cost, and geography) I played - untaught - in my twenties before a 35 year gap, then a blinding light appeared in the sky and I came to my senses😉 . I rented a sax then joined the street band after three weeks and the workshop after 3 months (you can always mime..). I've now been back playing 3 years.
Re workload: you just have to choose your battles - there's never enough time (in the jazz workshop initially I used to sit out songs I hadn't worked on).
I reckon you have to study when you can't play, play more days than not, and put your groundwork practice ahead of individual songs (much easier to write than to say!)
If your heart says jazz, Jethro, then aim straight at that I would say : everyone gets to play the head, even if you don't solo.. (I've now given up on the street band - newer arrangements are too oompah, oompah for me)
This post is getting long, sorry. Do PM me if you want, I have a Masters in blagging your way into things...
Good luck.
 
That’s encouraging Zugzwang, I’ve only been at this for two and half years starting from a blank sheet effectively since my school musical experience was so long ago that it’s irrelevant. I’m still very much learning the instrument, sight reading etc. I can only aspire to be where Jazzaferri is currently. I’m really using the grade exams as checkboxes on my progress with the instrument and the limited techniques that the classical syllabus provides and to get to a stage where if I join a band they don’t show me the door ASAP. To learn jazz techniques, as I’m not a natural, I realise that a syllabus though not the only way may help. Also from previous posts trying to do stuff on my own may also be helpful, May take up your offer of blagging instruction at some time. Cheers
 
A lot of people are trivialising the differences between classical and non-classical. Nobody has yet mentioned that classical music is almost complete in all its directives upon how to play (apart from using vibrato which is down to the experience and choice of the player). Much jazz merely gives the notes to play with no other markings whatsoever. You are expected to fully know the language - which takes years! The 12 notes are the same, it's how you play them and where you place them in the beat. Horn section playing - tight horn section playing is amazing, and is every bit as detailed - even more-so - than classical orchestral section playing:

Use of vibrato - how big and where. Most section playing is straight tone;
Fall-offs - after how many beats do you start to fall and how long does it last and how far (pitch-wise) does it go;
Placement within the beat - on top of, behind or dripping off the back;
Longs and shorts - this is so important, and probably the #1 thing to make a classical player sound as much in a non-classical environment;
Articulation style/technique
Straight 8's or swing - even in swing tunes some phrases are played straight and are not always marked;
Blue notes - usually bent;
Scoops/doops/lip-slurs - whatever the language you want to use - over (personal) use in a horn section will get you a few looks;
Dynamics - same as classical but rarely marked in horn section parts. Also use of sfz crest etc;
Length of long notes - very often you'll pop sections consistently come off 4-beat notes on 4, instead of 1 of next bar. Let's it breathe a bit.

All this stuff is learned mainly by listening to loads of music and sitting amongst guys that know the language and are consistent. Any quaver (8th note) in jazz followed by a rest is clipped. All others are usually long (e.g. 4 quavers is dad-daa-daa-dit). In a shuffle, these four quavers are most likely to be daa-dit-daa-dit etc.

Solo playing is a lot less regimented of course.
 
Jazz exams in the UK are often adjudicated by classical examiners too, which renders them rather pointless. This doesn't happen in the Rock School syllabus.
I'm not sure how they are marked for accuracy anyway - are you allowed to fiddle around with the head or expected to deliver the tune as written (ridiculous)?
Again we come back to playing a bunch of notes, or playing notes musically and relevant to the genre.
 
Hi Jethro, I joined a community band and a jazz workshop both of which asked for Grade V, but just a way of giving people a guide to the level they want - they were happy to let me 'audition'.
The grading system in NL is different to that in the UK. I followed a curious grading system which was linked to 'playing in a band'. I got a 'level B' diploma (sight reading with 3 sharps or flats) that was just high enough to get me into the local band. There are also levels C, D, and E which I didn't pursue. I now regret this.

Just as an aside, I find these 'systems' in Europe very curious...and new to me, I was unaware of them prior to joining chat boards which were populated by folks from all over the globe.

For the most part, at the 'community band' level here in US (or, let me be more specific - in the places here I have lived: Northeast, Northwest, Desert West)...trying our for a community band does not 'require' any sort of certificate or such....usually, if a chair is open, you just ask to come in for a practice or in some cases an audition.

In some cases a director may send you some charts, prior, just to get an idea /feedback if you have the capabilities for the repertoire.

It either goes well...or not. That's about it.

(Perhaps 'community band' means a different thing elsewhere ?)

Obviously joining a college or conservatory or other educational-associated entity is different (although sometimes not - I know a number of players who have joined local college bands, having had no association with the college, simply by asking to come and sit in with the band and the director giving 'em the thumbs-up).

Without digressing the thread here, I also feel the characterization of a Classical path being a 'necessity' to truly 'learn' the instrument...is an arguable opinion, at best. It intimates that proper fundamentals can only be achieved via this particular genre, or following a program associated with a particular genre.
Yet, a well-structured syllabus by a teacher or program which may not focus on the classical genres of music (but which will of course teach proper fundamentals, etc); will certainly not leave the player 'handicapped' in some way....
 
Last edited:
I went back and reread your initial post Jethro - nothing is lost - everything you've ever learned is in there somewhere, so whatever you learned at school is still present, even if it doesn't seem currently available (and may be scarcely relevant). Secondly, stopping playing one way and playing a different way after a couple of years is never going back to the beginning - everything you've been doing is relevant to becoming a better player. There's no fast track to the top - even if you learn from everyone else's mistakes, you'll make your own unique ones. (not as pessimistic as it may sound.) Do whatever makes you smile (plus **&$£!*-ing Long tones and overtones)
 
A lot of people are trivialising the differences between classical and non-classical. Nobody has yet mentioned that classical music is almost complete in all its directives upon how to play (apart from using vibrato which is down to the experience and choice of the player). Much jazz merely gives the notes to play with no other markings whatsoever. You are expected to fully know the language - which takes years! The 12 notes are the same, it's how you play them and where you place them in the beat. Horn section playing - tight horn section playing is amazing, and is every bit as detailed - even more-so - than classical orchestral section playing:

Use of vibrato - how big and where. Most section playing is straight tone;
Fall-offs - after how many beats do you start to fall and how long does it last and how far (pitch-wise) does it go;
Placement within the beat - on top of, behind or dripping off the back;
Longs and shorts - this is so important, and probably the #1 thing to make a classical player sound as much in a non-classical environment;
Articulation style/technique
Straight 8's or swing - even in swing tunes some phrases are played straight and are not always marked;
Blue notes - usually bent;
Scoops/doops/lip-slurs - whatever the language you want to use - over (personal) use in a horn section will get you a few looks;
Dynamics - same as classical but rarely marked in horn section parts. Also use of sfz crest etc;
Length of long notes - very often you'll pop sections consistently come off 4-beat notes on 4, instead of 1 of next bar. Let's it breathe a bit.

All this stuff is learned mainly by listening to loads of music and sitting amongst guys that know the language and are consistent. Any quaver (8th note) in jazz followed by a rest is clipped. All others are usually long (e.g. 4 quavers is dad-daa-daa-dit). In a shuffle, these four quavers are most likely to be daa-dit-daa-dit etc.

Solo playing is a lot less regimented of course.
That description of classical music is only true if all you are exposed to is the main post-baroque 'classical' canon (and even then it is not entirely true - cadenzas in concertos can be improvised). Int he baroque era, players who had the leading line were expected to ornament and decorate and improvise. Organists have always been expected to improvise and it's a requirement for the ARCO and FRCO qualifications.
Given that most orchestral music is by definition for a large ensemble, improvisation gives way to the need for a coherent performance and the need to play what's written.
 
Are you posting the gig as proof that you can cross genre? Exciting gig to be part of especially as an amateur player - but this isn’t crossing musical boundaries, it’s just adding an orchestra to pop music. Stylistically nothing is different.
Eddie Daniels and Benny Goodman both made very good concerto recordings. Much better than the ridiculous Menuhin collaboration with Grappelli or all the “jazz” recordings that have infiltrated light classical music radio stations like the jazz album by Emma Johnson (what an ego!) or the silliness in this field from John Harle.
The original point along these lines was made with regard to a high level, if you play for enjoyment then play anything and everything.
I posted it as evidence that amateurs can sometimes play in quite amazing gigs. Stylistically, it was very different from our usual repertoire - seriously so. I don't usually have to play a repeated bass riff on my cello for 80 bars, switch to another for 80 bars, then repeat the first one, perhaps with minor modification for another. It was probably a bigger shock to the stage band to play with an orchestra under a conductor. And at least oe of the original singers was very evidently too use to the stage band covering his inability count.
 
That description of classical music is only true if all you are exposed to is the main post-baroque 'classical' canon (and even then it is not entirely true - cadenzas in concertos can be improvised). Int he baroque era, players who had the leading line were expected to ornament and decorate and improvise. Organists have always been expected to improvise and it's a requirement for the ARCO and FRCO qualifications.
Given that most orchestral music is by definition for a large ensemble, improvisation gives way to the need for a coherent performance and the need to play what's written.
Baroque players at the time i.e. Bach, not players of Baroque music now. Organists entirely different category. Horn section playing is not improvised either, and is certainly extremely coherent. My main point is that they play as a unit despite much of the style/direction not being written, unlike classical music.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,686
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom