Beginner Saxes New to saxophone-which type to go for?

One quick further point- it sounds like you’ve got a decent budget and would be able to get either a brand new Yamaha YAS 280 (alto) or nearly new YTS 280 (tenor) with that money- either of which would provide a great starting point in their respective keys.

I wouldn’t necessarily be seduced by the offer of a sax that comes with an Otto Link mouthpiece, especially at a 7 tip opening, because it may not suit you when you’re first starting (especially if you go for a tenor after playing clarinet). What suits one player doesn’t necessarily suit them all so I’d be much more inclined to go with a stand-alone sax or one with a beginner mouthpiece which you’re not really paying extra for, then get yourself somewhere you can test some mouthpieces (or order a few off Amazon and return the ones you don’t like). Otherwise you might end up finding it too hard/not intuitive and hating the experience when it’s nothing to do with the saxophone itself
 
Last edited:
As a beginner with one year under my belt I can honestly say that my alto is easier to play than any of my tenors. That there are also more learning resources available for alto and that you can pick up a quality used one for a lower cost than any quality tenor.
I currently have a 12-year-old student that is getting along fine with a tenor. If your alto is easier to play than your tenors, then your tenors may have some issues. Get the leaks out and focus on determining a good setup (mouthpiece/reed) that works best for you.

Resources: The fingerings are the same. There are more saxophone method books than one could read in a lifetime (I have a library of them). What more do you need?

Cost: Yes, tenors tend to cost more than an equivalent alto. Save money by purchasing the horn that you want to play.
 
You don't NEED a 62, not sure why that was suggested honestly....(?!?!)

It wasn't suggested. Another poster asked how much a YTS 62 goes for in the OP's local market. Presumably this was to compare/qualify the price for which the OP has been offered a YTS32, which is what he's thinking about.

A YTS2* series sax would, I am sure, be fine, although personally I'd go for YTS25 or later, as they have a high F#, which I just prefer, having played saxes with this key for decades. However, if the OP decides he wants to indulge himself with a better model, well, it's his money. He might not get much benefit in learning, as he might not appreciate the subtle differences, but if that's what he wants, it's his call.

There is a famous surgeon in the UK who also does a lot of TV appearances. Fairly late in life, he decided he wanted to learn to play the sax. He's a wealthy man, and decided to buy a YAS62 as his first sax, which is what he learnt on. A lot of people, particularly on another forum, seem to think that a learner has to 'earn their dues' on a student sax before progressing to anything better, but that's really just nonsense. A rank beginner might not get the benefit from a high end sax, but it won't hold them back, and if that's what they want to buy it's up to them.
 
A young saxophone student I would recommend a Yamaha 23, 25, 275, 280. I 23 is probably played more than a used 275 so I would go for a 275 if it was the same money.

An adult beginner that knows that he/she will never be a professional I would recommend saxes that nobody wants. A mint Conn Director "Shooting Star" (alto for 2000.00 s e k, tenor for 2800.00 s e k), An Armstrong tenor ("3000" model and Keilwerth New King influenced), for 4000.00 s e k. A used YTS 23 for 10000.00 s e k or a Conn Mexico tenor in mint condition for 2800.00 s e k?
 
Spotted this Conn-Selmer PTS-380 Premiere unlacquered at £700 which seems reasonable...

329233612_6175660975832072_3623277440544924955_n.webp


If @ricardolamos is still looking please advise and I'll PM a link. It's in the south of england.

NB. I have no connection with the small ad seller.
 
buying a better sax to start on is a good idea if you can afford it i think. it's unkind to make learners play poor instruments, it's hard enough anyway. but everybody seems fixated on yamaha here, and with respect to colin, they sound thin. as for which type i think it is safer to start on the alto - it needs less breath.
 
The larger the saxophone the more volume or throughput of air is needed.
On smaller saxophones there's more back pressure. This can cause some players to have problems with exhaling between breathing.
I find that the horn has little influence on tone. Less than mouthpiece and much less than reed.
I use vintage Selmer Soloists on my tenor and alto 25 Yamahas, with a D'addario (Rico) Reserve 3.
Thin is a word I've never heard describing anything about me.
The saxophone does as it's told imo.
 
Last edited:
I find that the horn has little influence on tone. Less than mouthpiece and much less than reed.
did you compare it to anything? and it's delightful, but i think there would be many players who would say that the type of saxophone has a great effect on the tone. i have a lot of saxophones here, unjustifiable quantities, and they all sound different, even different examples of the same hand-built horn sound different. i devote quantities of time fiddling about with reed/mouthpiece combinations in order to get them to sound the same; that is, as though i was playing them.
 
I own 9 altos at the minute. All student horns. I've blown a few I didn't own.
I more or less always sound like me. Sometimes more. Sometimes less.
On recordings I can't tell which one I'm playing. I would swear that I could at the time of recording but later on, no.
Some horns give more. Some need to be pushed. Some need to be restrained. Some will do things that others won't.
I'm not a very technical or demanding player. I knock out tunes solo and harmony in a band. No altissimo.

Once I've settled on a set up, I'll stick with it.
Till the usual reeds change. Then the hunt is back on.

I find more difference in reeds than horns sound wise. Maybe I've never had the subtle ears that some possess. Pardon?
 
Hi Guys
Many thanks for all your comments and recommendations.
Always a bit tricky when starting off to know what to choose as quality instruments are not cheap.
I guess if things don't work out you can always sell on without loosing much assuming you pay a reasonable price.

I have seen a Yamaha YTS32 in very good condition priced at £1200 with an Otto Link Super Tone master 7 plus a Hiscox case;does that sound the right sort of ball park cost wise?
Mates got one excellent nick purple logo, no hiscox case but original yam case also in excellent condition. Original receipt looked at by Dawkes when I had it and not played much since..Drop me a pm if you choose tenor and I will put it in the yardsale...Re your question get both and whichever stays on the wardrobe for the longest time isnt for you...seriously tho some songs are for alto it depends on your calling...Either way have a great journey...
 
Hi All
Previous experience with clarinet but new to the world of saxophones.
Just perusing instrument options and would like to get something of good quality on the used market.
Probably going to opt for a Yamaha but torn between an alto and tenor model.
Advice on pro's and con's of alto v tenor would be really appreciated.
regards
Richard
Nothing is set in stone, you can pick whichever suits you now but you can change your journey at anytime.
So if you pick tenor now and you could change to alto or soprano later or vice versa, no one type of sax is better than the other.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,602
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom