Tech/maintenance New Springs for a Martin Medalist Alto

I think the last USA patent on a sax tube/bore was "The Martin" (1947) "polyconical bore" (I don't know if Eagle -Powell?). The bigger bell (flair) gave The Martin saxes a more contemporary sound. Martin made saxes were what we call thick wall saxes. I don't think it has anything to do with the tone/sound more that the thick soldered-on tone holes that need more metal to work well. When I compare a "The Martin" to a HC Comm II/HC I can see that the bell is a little bit thinner but the flair on a The Martin is much bigger.. The tone a Comm II/HC (Committee) is bigger and that was an answer the the music industry that wanted more and bigger sound. The music was designed to fit the juke boxes and the radio. The DJ's on the radio stations were important. Red Prysock's song "Hand Clapping'" was played on jukes boxes and radio stations all over America and also played on warm-up at basketball games. So it made a huge impact on the younger (post WWII) generation.

Martin necks are good due to the thick wall construction. They stays round. Martin Committee necks are often large at the tip. I have tenor mouthpices that I can't use on a Martin Committee. So a tenor mpc is not always a tenor mouthpiece.

Lots of thoughts and rumours about Martin Committee saxes. I can't say what' true or not. I just know that they are fine saxes.
 
Last edited:
now i think of it....it seems very plausible that Martin did intentionally restrict the bore size of the Indiana / Medalist compared with the larger Pro Level Com3. Not just the neck, but the whole horn. Obviously we're just basing this on a comparison of 2 horns.

Question is, why would you do this other when you have a perfectly proportioned designed bore on the pro-level horn, being manufactured at the same time? To make it easier for students? Unlikely, as the Com3 is hardly a relatively large bore compared with other horn, most likely so the cheaper student horns didn't compete with the pro level range. Make economic sense although its not proof, just "likely speculation". Pretty sure Yamaha do this on the YTS 275 vs 62 (I may be wrong though). It's not just features that are different, metal feels thinner in this case, leading to a thinner sound...
I don't necessarily agree with that assertion. It has been said the Indiana came/evolved from the (pre-Committee) Handcrafts....while the Comm 3 was an evolution from the Comm 2.

I once had a Comm 2, a Centennial, and a Comm 3 in the shop all at once, measured all of them. The Centennial, chronologically in the middle, in fact did have specs both of the 2 and the 3. It wasn't a full 3 in tube/neck design, but it wasn't a 2 either.

I tend not to believe the company intentionally made their second line offerings to be inferior or wanting compared to their top shelfers. I think the Indianas came from one pedigree, and the 3 came from another. I think that as Martin had the tooling for the old Handcrafts already, it made budgetary sense for them to keep that design for their second-shelf model(s).
IOW, the manufacturing infrastructure and tooling was 'already there' at the factory.
The Committees, therefore, got the R&D, while the Indianas were deemed (correctly) quite good and popular enough to just keep producing using the older specs;mayb adding small tweaks from time to time over the years.
That's about all, IMHO.

I do think most mfr's added bells and whistles to their top offering while leaving their second shelfers a bit more spare/simpler in the furniture (keywork mechanics, guards, touches, etc) dept.

That one finds a model 'inferior' or superior to another, when talking Martins, becomes a bit subjective.

The 3 is their Grail, but for me...when you go down a checklist of attributes....I actually prefer the 1, 2, and Indianas to the Comm 3.
 
Last edited:
The post WWII Indiana are based on the Handcraft Special saxes. Take a look at the tone holes to make sure if a Martin Is a Committee model. The Committee have tone holes that are without beveled tone holes rims. And I think they are a little bit lower as well? Just one sax that shared the Committee tube and that's the rare Reynold Contempora model. The great Sorkin, Dick Stable and other fine Martin stencil saxes are not based on the Committee tube.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom