Tech/maintenance New Springs for a Martin Medalist Alto

new software that was made to run slower in older phones so people bought new ones
I understood it was because if the new software was run on older phones as was they'd fall over. Making them slower allowed it to work ... albeit more slowly.
yeah I was thinking offering £100 less,
A drop in the ocean. Import duty, VAT, handling charges ... lots of extra £s to take into account.
 
Ah yes, the old thing "ergonomics of older horns". Put in some time in the shed, learning how to play them the way they were designed, and those issues will disappear.

And the funny thing is, my very first sax was a Martin so I never learned that they were (supposedly) inferior. In fact, the Martin inline key layout and the pinky table still feel efficient to me.
 
I remember Richard Thomas a well known Dallas repair guy experimented a lot with octave pips. He made up a bunch of them: tall ones, short ones, ones that stuck into the bore a long way, ones that didn't go into the bore at all.

I watched him experimenting - they all sounded the same to me - and in the end he just put the original ones back in.

If I were asked the most likely reason why the ID of the tenon in question is small, I'd guess it's an adaptation to parts on hand. If you have a bunch of smaller sized receivers, then you make up a bunch of smaller size tenons. Or maybe the tenons were what was on hand. Or a manufacturing error. Or a bunch of necks cut too short and wanted to be salvaged - if you constrict the tenon, it'll play a bit flatter and still stay adequately in tune.

All the above sounds more likely than whatever convuluted reasoning Lance was coming up with.

In the absence of factory records, and you're not going to find them, it's all guesswork anyway.
 
I thought the point of playing a vintage horn was to play a vintage horn and enjoy owning it.

Butchering a survivor, to make it more modern, sort of misses the point imo, and removes one more survivor from the diminishing pool of originals.

It's only original once and modifications to personal specifications reduce its monetary value and saleability. imo.
I'm planning on keeping it long term, adding to my collection, so don't really care about its resale value. It was £400 with a £360 receipt for work done on it 1 year ago. There's about 5 or so medalists / Indiana's / Imperials on ebay atm all under 300 Dollars which is currently all they're worth. I'd like to get a committee III to compare, and work on, as a project, probably to sell though...

The Medalist has a great sound now that the neck is less restrictive; dark, husky, open and punchy depending on how it play, and in tune! It lacks the refinement you get from a yani or 82z etc. but I can live with that.

Playing a T992 (tenor) and 82z R soprano I want to minimize adapting as much as possible hence my questions about modifying. I think with a new set of springs and slightly raised action, plus leveling of a few tone holes...with some more practice, will be an even better horn...
 
I remember Richard Thomas a well known Dallas repair guy experimented a lot with octave pips. He made up a bunch of them: tall ones, short ones, ones that stuck into the bore a long way, ones that didn't go into the bore at all.

I watched him experimenting - they all sounded the same to me - and in the end he just put the original ones back in.

If I were asked the most likely reason why the ID of the tenon in question is small, I'd guess it's an adaptation to parts on hand. If you have a bunch of smaller sized receivers, then you make up a bunch of smaller size tenons. Or maybe the tenons were what was on hand. Or a manufacturing error. Or a bunch of necks cut too short and wanted to be salvaged - if you constrict the tenon, it'll play a bit flatter and still stay adequately in tune.

All the above sounds more likely than whatever convuluted reasoning Lance was coming up with.

In the absence of factory records, and you're not going to find them, it's all guesswork anyway.
I don't buy the octave pip shortening tbh. I guess if the bore is restricted already, they might make more of difference...but... all the saxes have protuding octave pips, including the legendary Mark 6, so I'm happy to leave that well alone...for now 😀
 
Not sure you were referring to me here (?)...I never said the Imperial and Medalist were synonymous.
I noted that (TheMartinStory site, specifically) claims they were produced/offered during the same period...this, I am gonna doubt a bit and there is info on that site which is great, and some which is inaccurate and has never been revised.

Medalists and Indianas are the same horn design, again. Imperial seems a dumbed-down Indiana...but the intent of that ? Not sure, but I think the hypothesis of 'to make the Imperial worse'...is debatable....

Comm III has a completely different body tube, bow, bell, and neck tube than an Indiana. So the Committees, all three versions, ARE different beasts from Indianas.

It has been said that Indianas are old Handcraft body specs. I will not contradict that as I never measured up a Handcraft and compared it to an Indiana. Might be so...but something changed (neck, at least ?) because an old Handcraft and an Indiana do not have the same tonalities....
My alto is a Medalist not an Imperial, I think that's where you got me confused, although I think probably sounds like an Imperial or has same neck hence the sound maybe someone swapped necks on it at some point?? I had an old 1920s Handcraft tenor for a while, lovely rich big sound (larger bore?) Nightmare to play, but great sound.
 
My alto is a Medalist not an Imperial, I think that's where you got me confused, although I think probably sounds like an Imperial or has same neck hence the sound maybe someone swapped necks on it at some point?? I had an old 1920s Handcraft tenor for a while, lovely rich big sound (larger bore?) Nightmare to play, but great sound.
Ah, thanks....my apologies. This would be new news to me if the Medalist and Indianas have same exterior tenon diameter (which I believe they do, if memory serves) but different wall thicknesses. That's be interesting...
 
Ah, thanks....my apologies. This would be new news to me if the Medalist and Indiana's have same exterior tenon diameter (which I believe they do, if memory serves) but different wall thicknesses. That's be interesting...
Would also be interesting if both Indiana's and Medalists have almost identical bore design and neck tapper to committee IIIs, just an overly restrictive neck tenon (I think this is what the thread I linked to was implying), which could have been intentional or simply tenon parts available in warehouse at time, which also seems a viable theory someone mentioned.

Certainly I know that a committee III neck is longer and won't work on a medalist / Indiana due to external clamp and length (committee III body is shorter in respect of this).

If bore dimensions and thicknesses are identical, aside from this, which case fitting a larger tenon should give you almost an identical Committee III sound. Tbh the sound is currently is as I would imagine a Committee 3 / The Martin to sound I don't have one, maybe will get a committee III and a spare medalist neck shortly then will know, I msged them if selling the martin alto elsewhere 🙂

The tenon thickness on the medalist seems like it must have been on the thicker side, as after removing metal its about standard now, compared to my yani neck (which is only a sample of 1!) both are between 0.6mm and 0.7mm wall thickness at tenon- I should have measured the medalist originally though! :doh:
 
I don’t know for sure, but as far as I have been able to tell, the “Medalist” was the name given to the Indiana Deluxe during the Richards RMC period, and the Imperial was the (cheapened) successor to the Indiana Standard during the Wurlitzer ownership in the 1970’s.

There was also a Martin Imperial model in the 1930’s. This was a top-line professional horn, and nothing to do with the later “Imperial”.
 
I don’t know for sure, but as far as I have been able to tell, the “Medalist” was the name given to the Indiana Deluxe during the Richards RMC period, and the Imperial was the (cheapened) successor to the Indiana Standard during the Wurlitzer ownership in the 1970’s.

There was also a Martin Imperial model in the 1930’s. This was a top-line professional horn, and nothing to do with the later “Imperial”.
Maybe they didn't had the right to call and sell a sax "Indiana"? The late "The Martin" saxes was called the "X model". Still very much the same saxes that reached the market around 1945. In past it was the same company that owned patents, the machine/tools that made the saxes, owned the buildings where the saxes were made ...... .
 
A large bore sax what is that? A sax with a big tube area? How to define a large bore sax? I asked a professor in acoustic to define a large bore sax. First we have to define the large bore sound. A way to do this is to have a player playing different saxes in the same way. Same licks, tones, same mouthpiece and reed Playing behind a curtain and have listeners to define with words their feelings. So far we just know that are saxes with larger bores and saxes with smaller bores. A way to decide the size of bore can be to mesure the I.D. of the neck tenon.
 
A large bore sax what is that? A sax with a big tube area? How to define a large bore sax? I asked a professor in acoustic to define a large bore sax. First we have to define the large bore sound. A way to do this is to have a player playing different saxes in the same way. Same licks, tones, same mouthpiece and reed Playing behind a curtain and have listeners to define with words their feelings. So far we just know that are saxes with larger bores and saxes with smaller bores. A way to decide the size of bore can be to mesure the I.D. of the neck tenon.
I think there are a number of points which determine the bore size, neck tenon size being just one of them. Someone will probably enlighten us.

I used to have a P Mauriat 66r, that was definitely a large bore sax, very loud, with little resistance - not enough resistance in my view - you just get one big spread sound without ability to move between subtone and full sound easily and have less focus. The air seems to escape too quickly. Its still a good sax though. However, the neck receiver is very standard size and seemed identical to my YTS 61 and 32. The Yamaha is probably the opposite end of the spectrum to the 66r sound wise, smaller more focused sound, but tends to be a bit on the bright / thin size on tenor, for me anyways.

From experience of playing quite a few I believe the Mark 6 has a perfect balance between focus, projection, resistance etc, the neck allegedly has a narrower tapper (smaller bore from mp end), yet some Mark6s have a massive tenon, you can't interchange them on other horns, some similar size to standard (massive variability in dimensions and sound over the years).

I personally find Yani (T992 bronze in particular) with a Mark 6 neck (I got one that happens to be a good one, although had to apply a little wet and dry to outside of tenon to fit) or ref 54 neck neck changes the yani (which feels like a larger bore instrument to me) from a more spread, lower resistance horn to slightly more resistance, focus and greater pitch control (switching to a T902 neck is somewhat similar but not as rich in my view). The Martin (tenor that I used to have) seems to just have all of this in spades right out the box, and darker / richer than any Mark 6 in my view but doesn't benefit from the newer action that most people prefer, I also found the note attack on The Martin less snappy than modern horns, a little too soft, but that can be a good thing. Horses for courses etc. In the end i sold it on as the yani felt better made horn in my hands and still had the sound I was after.

Now I got a Remy tenor also 😀 and that is also a cracking horn, which I actually play more, it's a lot lighter than the Yani, smaller neck receiver interestingly (neck modeled on an old SBA), and has its own sound, focus and richness that I also like...need to update my profile
 
Last edited:
Neck tenon ID is governed by the need to make the mechanical joint and should not be used as an indication of the general bore diameter of the horn. Furthermore, different manufacturers locate the neck joint higher or lower on the horn, so the conical shape of the horn will make a tenon larger or smaller accordingly.

The way to determine "bore size" (and there's not a single number, because it's a modified cone) is to take actual measurements up and down the tube. For by-guess-and-by-golly fooling round, it would probably be acceptable to measure the OD of the tube at different tone holes, then use something like a ball attachment on a micrometer to gauge the wall thickness and assume it's approximately constant. Then you've also got to determine the axial location of each place where you've measured, which isn't so easy with curved instruments. When you're done you have measurements that look like those on Marten Postma's website. I will point out that almost every time I've read mention of "oh, well, such and such a horn is large bore [or small bore, or parabolic bore whatever that means] and Postma's site has actual measurements, the word of mouth is contradicted by the ACTUAL MEASUREMENTS.

And that's why whenever someone starts ascribing characteristics of an instrument to its supposed "large" bore or "small" bore, I always respond "measurements, please" and amazingly enough there is almost never an answer.
 
Would also be interesting if both Indiana's and Medalists have almost identical bore design and neck tapper to committee IIIs, just an overly restrictive neck tenon (I think this is what the thread I linked to was implying), which could have been intentional or simply tenon parts available in warehouse at time, which also seems a viable theory someone mentioned.

Certainly I know that a committee III neck is longer and won't work on a medalist / Indiana due to external clamp and length (committee III body is shorter in respect of this).

If bore dimensions and thicknesses are identical, aside from this, which case fitting a larger tenon should give you almost an identical Committee III sound. Tbh the sound is currently is as I would imagine a Committee 3 / The Martin to sound I don't have one, maybe will get a committee III and a spare medalist neck shortly then will know, I msged them if selling the martin alto elsewhere 🙂

The tenon thickness on the medalist seems like it must have been on the thicker side, as after removing metal its about standard now, compared to my yani neck (which is only a sample of 1!) both are between 0.6mm and 0.7mm wall thickness at tenon- I should have measured the medalist originally though! :doh:
FWIW the body tube of a 3 and an Indana are not the same, I just measured them here, now (tenor)...I have junkers of both...testing 6 locations up and down the tube, there are variances between .5mm and 1mm......enough to indicate IMHO that these were intentional specs not just variances due to the fabrication techniques of the day...way I interpret it.

The 3 tube at top is .4mm larger, and at the centerline of stack D hole is .8mm larger.

Also, many tonehole diameters on tube are the same, but around 25% are different by between .5mm and 1.75mm.
 
Last edited:
FWIW the body tube of a 3 and an Indana are not the same, I just measured them here, now (tenor)...I have junkers of both...testing 6 locations up and down the tube, there are variances between .5mm and 1mm......enough to indicate IMHO that these were intentional specs not just variances due to the fabrication techniques of the day...way I interpret it.

The 3 tube at top is .4mm larger, and at the centerline of stack D hole is .8mm larger.

Also, many tonehole diameters on tube are the same, but around 25% are different by between .5mm and 1.75mm.
nice one! 1mm difference is actually quite a lot - so a com3 and Indiana / medalist are not the same bore / body design! Was this intentional, probably yes! At least on tenor 😀 If you get an alto, the neck receiver of the Medalist is 23.7mm. My Yani is about 24.5mm, less than 1mm difference, which is lot if you try to fit it. The issue with the medalist / Indiana neck is the large step inside the neck, well over 1mm, the actual OD neck tenon is only 23.5mm, so its very slightly undersized on the receiever end, possibly thicker metal on tenon?? Does the Tenor Indiana also have this step?
 
Last edited:
FWIW the body tube of a 3 and an Indana are not the same, I just measured them here, now (tenor)...I have junkers of both...testing 6 locations up and down the tube, there are variances between .5mm and 1mm......enough to indicate IMHO that these were intentional specs not just variances due to the fabrication techniques of the day...way I interpret it.

The 3 tube at top is .4mm larger, and at the centerline of stack D hole is .8mm larger.

Also, many tonehole diameters on tube are the same, but around 25% are different by between .5mm and 1.75mm.
now i think of it....it seems very plausible that Martin did intentionally restrict the bore size of the Indiana / Medalist compared with the larger Pro Level Com3. Not just the neck, but the whole horn. Obviously we're just basing this on a comparison of 2 horns.

Question is, why would you do this other when you have a perfectly proportioned designed bore on the pro-level horn, being manufactured at the same time? To make it easier for students? Unlikely, as the Com3 is hardly a relatively large bore compared with other horn, most likely so the cheaper student horns didn't compete with the pro level range. Make economic sense although its not proof, just "likely speculation". Pretty sure Yamaha do this on the YTS 275 vs 62 (I may be wrong though). It's not just features that are different, metal feels thinner in this case, leading to a thinner sound...
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,611
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom