Saxophones neck to mouthpiece connection: tapering v straight considerations.

A digital caliper won't be any good for the job, it can't reach into the bore to the depths you would need to go.
You need a spring gauge and micrometer.
Then when you know the dimensions, what are you going to do. If your mouthpieces didn't fit before, measuring them won't make them fit.
All seems a pointless exerise.

John (a N.W. disciple ;})

Boy...you seems too sure of your statements...and no, you don't need to be too precise.
My digital caliper can reach enough to tell me this MP seems having a parallel bore and that MP is already tapering from the opening....so I might just chuck away the second MP and keep the other (got that?)....in fact that's exactly what I've already found out...a couple of MP (an old unmarked vintage and a Tonalin) weren't up to scratch - maybe these have been somehow "modified" by some previous owners.
 
but if you have a not too compressed cork even assuming that the shaft of the mouthpiece is conical (and I believe it hasn't started its life that way) the cork would accommodate for any " reasonable" difference in diameter
 
but if you have a not too compressed cork even assuming that the shaft of the mouthpiece is conical (and I believe it hasn't started its life that way) the cork would accommodate for any " reasonable" difference in diameter

The cork (or rather corks...as I'm dealing with more than one sax/neck)...is normally compressed and wouldn't be an issue in a normal setup.
My situation is a bit more complex as I'm testing 40 odd alto mouthpieces!! That's why in my case it would be better to find a more "accommodating" cork substitute...
Few of these MPs don't have a perfectly cylindrical bore (no idea why)....I myself have modified a Vandoren V16 small chamber because it wouldn't enter the neck deep enough (a recurring issue with this particular MP)...surely in my diy ways I'm not sure the bore section of that V16 is now cylindrical and I'm bound to think that some other MPs I have (especially those bought 2nd hand) are affected by similar diy modifications.
 
Boy...you seems too sure of your statements...and no, you don't need to be too precise.
My digital caliper can reach enough to tell me this MP seems having a parallel bore and that MP is already tapering from the opening....so I might just chuck away the second MP and keep the other (got that?)....in fact that's exactly what I've already found out...a couple of MP (an old unmarked vintage and a Tonalin) weren't up to scratch - maybe these have been somehow "modified" by some previous owners.

Sure of my statements, you bet! When it comes down to Metrology, that's playtime for me (nearly 50 years at it). As for only worrying about the first 15mm, which is the average usable distance of 6" calipers inside jaws (and not enough to determin very much), your opening post was concerned with the other end of the bore where you thought that any oversize would affect the sound!
Are you now telling us that you are selecting mouthpieces by the size of the bore, rather than the sound?
Just trying to clarify things >:)

John🙂;}
 
The cork (or rather corks...as I'm dealing with more than one sax/neck)...is normally compressed and wouldn't be an issue in a normal setup.
My situation is a bit more complex as I'm testing 40 odd alto mouthpieces!! That's why in my case it would be better to find a more "accommodating" cork substitute...
Few of these MPs don't have a perfectly cylindrical bore (no idea why)....I myself have modified a Vandoren V16 small chamber because it wouldn't enter the neck deep enough (a recurring issue with this particular MP)...surely in my diy ways I'm not sure the bore section of that V16 is now cylindrical and I'm bound to think that some other MPs I have (especially those bought 2nd hand) are affected by similar diy modifications.

My suggestion since you are trying different necks and so many mouthpieces is to sand the corks on the necks to be cylindrical and allow the mouthpiece with the smallest diameter shank to fit. Then for the larger shank mouthpieces wrap the corks with plumber's teflon tape up to the required diameter to form a snug fit, or use blue painter's masking tape. Again, if some of the mouthpiece shanks are in fact tapered, I think you will find it is to such a small degree as to be inconsequential in terms of fitting over a cylindrical shaped cork.
 
My suggestion since you are trying different necks and so many mouthpieces is to sand the corks on the necks to be cylindrical and allow the mouthpiece with the smallest diameter shank to fit. Then for the larger shank mouthpieces wrap the corks with plumber's teflon tape up to the required diameter to form a snug fit, or use blue painter's masking tape. Again, if some of the mouthpiece shanks are in fact tapered, I think you will find it is to such a small degree as to be inconsequential in terms of fitting over a cylindrical shaped cork.

I've been using the white hydraulic tape for a while by now...still, I'm fed up of having to take it out when switching back to a mouthpiece with a narrower bore (and then of course re-applying the tape when using other mouthpieces).
One can plan ahead and start using the narrow bore mpcs first and then the others but isn't very useful (not for me), and ideally one should be able to switch mouthpieces easily and without any glitches.
Surely there are materials more suitable than cork for these kind of testing?
 
If a mouthpiece has got a bore that's too wide (bleedin' Runyons for example) I just wrap a piece of paper round the cork. Works fine.

Of course the paper has to be handcrafted from virgin pulp with a dash of silk (emphasizes the 3rd harmonic) and totally acid free.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I've been using the white hydraulic tape for a while by now...still, I'm fed up of having to take it out when switching back to a mouthpiece with a narrower bore (and then of course re-applying the tape when using other mouthpieces).
One can plan ahead and start using the narrow bore mpcs first and then the others but isn't very useful (not for me), and ideally one should be able to switch mouthpieces easily and without any glitches.
Surely there are materials more suitable than cork for these kind of testing?

I feel your pain, but the fact is no one has come up with a material that works better than cork for saxophone necks.

There is another approach if you are willing to put in the time. That is to form a circle of black plastic electrician's tape about the size of the mouthpiece shank and insert one or more layers of that into the larger mouthpiece shanks. I have done this for customers who want two very different mouthpieces to work on the same neck cork.

The best way I have found is to wrap the tape sticky side out overlapping itself just a bit around a wooden dowel slightly smaller than the mouthpiece opening and insert the tape that way. When the tape grabs the inside of the mouthpiece you can pull the dowel loose and use it to press the tape firmly in place.
 
I feel your pain, but the fact is no one has come up with a material that works better than cork for saxophone necks.

There is another approach if you are willing to put in the time. That is to form a circle of black plastic electrician's tape about the size of the mouthpiece shank and insert one or more layers of that into the larger mouthpiece shanks. I have done this for customers who want two very different mouthpieces to work on the same neck cork.

The best way I have found is to wrap the tape sticky side out overlapping itself just a bit around a wooden dowel slightly smaller than the mouthpiece opening and insert the tape that way. When the tape grabs the inside of the mouthpiece you can pull the dowel loose and use it to press the tape firmly in place.

I did this trick already on a vintage Noblet - probably the mouthpiece with the largest bore of my arsenal...it was ok initially, but after a while the tape came out slightly from the opening and now is sticking out (about 2mm) = a bit messy.
A better and slicker solution is to use some laquer used to protect car engines - this form a very thin layer inside the mouthpiece and usually more applications are necessary (just protect the chamber with a tape)...very useful for minor adjustments and it works great on a couple of cheap metal mouthpiece but I'm a bit wary on using this laquer on ebonite - dunno, maybe I have to do a bit of research.
 
There is another approach if you are willing to put in the time. That is to form a circle of black plastic electrician's tape about the size of the mouthpiece shank and insert one or more layers of that into the larger mouthpiece shanks. I have done this for customers who want two very different mouthpieces to work on the same neck cork..

Beware, I think UK electrical tape may be not as sticky as US electrical tape.
 
Another option may be to use self adhesive copper strips inside the mouthpiece neck. Once in place they can be sanded to fit, and in need can be removed. They're intended for flute use, and I've only used them on flutes, so use them on ebonite at your own risk....

http://www.jlsmithco.com/New-Products/101068

It is great to find out about a new product. I'm thinking this could possibly also be used to reduce the diameter inside the end of saxophone necks in order to increase the taper and correct intonation problems.
 
It is great to find out about a new product. I'm thinking this could possibly also be used to reduce the diameter inside the end of saxophone necks in order to increase the taper and correct intonation problems.

here's another thought:

What do you think about smearing epoxy on the inside of a mouthpiece to reduce the diameter of the bore?
 
here's another thought:

What do you think about smearing epoxy on the inside of a mouthpiece to reduce the diameter of the bore?

My thoughts are anything that is not permanent and can be removed without damaging the material of the mouthpiece is fine. Some folks use layers of clear nail polish which comes off with nail polish remover. This is safe on metal and hard rubber mouthpieces. It is best to test a plastic mouthpiece first by applying a small drop of remover to an inconspicuous area and waiting a minute or so to see if the plastic turns tacky. There are so many different types plastics used that it is hard to generalize.

I personally don't know of any solvent that will remove cured epoxy. Scraping and heat are the methods I use.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,678
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom