JayeNM
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 3,851
- Location
- New Mexico, US
Yep, their choice of singers definitely made some of those ones pretty hard.The trouble with the one about which was the most out of tune is that they’re all out of tune, although some are painful. I only got to the end of the second test before it locked up and couldn’t be bothered to start again, maybe another day. Though I doubt that I would match the magnificent scores above.
It's a tie! Play off! I was the opposite, out of tune got me and I think one wrong on the melodies.I got 123, I did well on the melody and tuning sections but the metronome bit let me down.
Got 113.And your score? 🙂
Ha ha! I got 105. Spent most of my time thinking about bad production and mixes, how the melodies were totally devoid of musicality, whether the out of tune vocal was skewed more by the out of tune piano or guitar and also how high the metronome was in relation to the track etc.Got 113.
I wish that the test had something to do with ability. Seems that it has little or noting to do with music knowledge or ability, but more recognition of melodies, accuracy of hearing rhythms and accuracy of hearing in tune. Lots of great players played out of tune most of the time, for example Coltrane.
The test says nothing about your ability to create a melody, your physical coordination that allows you to play well or fast, control of breath or embouchure, ability to recognize chords, harmonies, specific rhythms or even the vibe/feel of a piece of music. It's an academic quiz that someone will use to write a paper in trying to coordinate those other questions about age, experience, music schooling, etc. It certainly seems possible to get a great score and not be able to hum a tune or have ever played an instrument.
I don't think anyone should consider this test as something that reflects on your ability as a musician. It's certainly not a musical ability IQ, just how well do you hear accurately. Having very short snippets that come immediately after you answer a question doesn't let your brain have a lot of time to "reset". What's that testing?
IMHO I think some of the clever people here could dream up a much more relevant test...but that begs the question "are we here to compete or compliment each other and learn"?
Ha ha! I got 105. Spent most of my time thinking about bad production and mixes, how the melodies were totally devoid of musicality, whether the out of tune vocal was skewed more by the out of tune piano or guitar and also how high the metronome was in relation to the track etc.
I'm fine with a play off, as long as there's no penalty shoot out. We don't do well with those...It's a tie! Play off! I was the opposite, out of tune got me and I think one wrong on the melodies.
I was wondering how they did that...silly ol' codger, me I just thought they had the same singer do 2 takes....As a music producer I could pick the vocal melodies where they had used autotune to change the pitch...made it a lot easier.
