Teaching Music teachers

even more amazing that teachers can assess people using such a ridiculous test.



the bottom line is that it didn't really matter to have a population that was all musically, trained, as compared with all being literate
- so music teaching was often non-existent, or just consisted of singing in the hall, or something rather divisive - where only a chosen few got the chance to shine, often by some arbitrary test. You'd be surprised how common these sort of stories are.

It's a bit like the tale of "they said I wasn't musical so they always gave me the triangle to play"
 
the bottom line is that it didn't really matter to have a population that was all musically, trained, as compared with all being literate
- so music teaching was often non-existent, or just consisted of singing in the hall, or something rather divisive - where only a chosen few got the chance to shine, often by some arbitrary test. You'd be surprised how common these sort of stories are.

It's a bit like the tale of "they said I wasn't musical so they always gave me the triangle to play"

I got my early musical stuff from the choir in St Werburgh's in the 60s. Super choirmaster.... Hated the music stuff at prmary school. Out came one of the big green books, teacher sat at the piano and we had to sing to it.
 
I had no "early musical stuff". Decisively put into the category of "no musical talent" ... took me decades to decide to prove/disprove that for myself. Jury still out on how much musical talent, but there's enough to give me great pleasure anyway.
 
I was very lucky as a child. My parents recognised the fact that I had some sort of talent. It wasn't a great talent, but, from a very early age I could play the last post (to a fashion) on the watering can and several random notes from a hose pipe!
My mother had a connection to a chain of music stores in Hull and managed to get me a trumpet. I played it for a short while, getting bored with it and getting frustrated with the music teachers because I just couldn't figure out the theory side of things.
I could, however, sing and as luck would have it, our next door neighbour was a retired opera singer. She realised that I was never going to be able to read music so she taught me to listen, very intently, to the tune. I think this is where my ability to play by ear comes from.
 
Interesting thread.
My experience of music teachers is that the 2 i have been under both a long time ago were very different.
The first one which was when i started was ex military band but his primary instrument was piano but played all the woodwinds in the army,he knew nothing about equipment and still asks me even today if any of his woodwind students want to upgrade,but he is an excellent teacher especially if you want to do grades,but knew little about jazz which was the path i wanted to take,i was with him for my first 7/8 years,we are still friends even though its been 12 years since lessons.
The second was a professional saxophone player and jazz teacher at university,what he didn't know about jazz wasn't worth knowing and he knew everything about equipment,different approach but just as effective,so maybe its better having teachers that are different and offer a varied programs.
I also like saxnik's approach to teaching.

Brian
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,681
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom