Studies Music book

My biggest problem with A Tune a Day (old version) is that I get the impression it was written by a clarinet player whothought of the sax as a big clarinet. It's good to have some familiar tunes written out, but I'd take what he says about embouchure and technique with a large grain of salt.
 
I recommend "The Jazz Method for Saxophone" by John O'Neill. This book starts from assuming no prior musical experience, and takes you up to around grade 5 using jazz examples.

Tenor version:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/0946535205

Alto version:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/1902455002

The only difference between the alto and tenor editions is that the CD backings are in a different key. The CD is available separately.
 
I tend to think that having a solid footing playing "straight" stuff will serve anyone, playing any kind of music, well. Too many amateur jazz players I've met, although they might improvise very well, are often really bad readers. This can be a very annoying deficiency when you're trying to work out charts in a band situation.

It seems that you fail to recognise the parallel visual pattern recognition problems that led to children suffering dyslexia being called thick. Language was spoken long before homo sapiens learnt to notate it, rather badly at times and similarly there was music before homo sapiens learnt to notate it, also rather badly.

The good sight reader who is a bad improviser is akin to giving Shakespeare to most eight year olds, who will read out the pentameters with rhythm but no understanding, however it is possible to get dyslexics to remember the speeches and deliver them in a meaningful way. Possibly the difference between the lawyer, who has to write very accurate language that cannot be misunderstood and only Glass and Hoffnung have achieved that amongst the composers and the actor, whose metier is emotive expression?

There are a number of members who find reading difficult yet are superb musicians and it is accepted there was no intention to imply reduced musicality. Pax vobiscum.
 
I recommend "The Jazz Method for Saxophone" by John O'Neill. This book starts from assuming no prior musical experience, and takes you up to around grade 5 using jazz examples.

IMV this also is a very good book. The author expects you to be committed to learning, and some of the lessons are far from walkovers. But if you finish this book, you'll be well on the way towards becoming a useful player.
 
Old Git, I don't disagree with you (I think) but all I was suggesting - as far as whether A Tune A Day is a good book - is that it is a good book for the first weeks / months of a sax playing career, but that no beginner should hastily abandon playing straight stuff just to get cracking with jazz, or whatever.

There was no jazz method book for sax back when I started , and I guess I would have loved it if there were, but being made to read and interpret classical pieces (alongside any jazzy stuff that my teacher gave me) was a good discipline, I think. Not least because classical demands a precision that in the jazz world you would only really find in big band charts.

Otherwise, the two idioms make vastly different demands on the player, but experience of one helps the other, surely.
 
Bari,
I am an O'Neil fan but have seen a notorious Melodeon book that clearly stated, that it will take five years for you to finish this book. Not very encouraging for beginners. O'Neil just seems to say, get on with this at your rate, a good way to help learners, which we all are.

I am in absolute awe of those who played in the live TV and Radio bands where it was, one run through and then live. Real master musicians and most capable of a good solo too. All worth a seat in any genre.

Bit more of a grouch than usual at the moment, as involved in a legal battle with the council and the crunch is due in autumn. Play what you like, with and without dots, be judged by the standards you wish but enjoy.
 
I am an O'Neil fan as well but if you play alto there are a couple of very good books by Ollie Weston called Exploring Jazz saxophone and Improvising Blues saxophone and they are both very well written and enjoyable to play along with.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,588
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom