saxnik
Member
- Messages
- 354
- Location
- Poole, Dorset, United Kingdom
OK, I'm mostly talking in terms of kids here, but if I recommend a mouthpiece in my experience what happens is:
1) Nothing, to begin with. Many parents as Kev says are reluctant to part with more readies unless they have to.
2) After a lot of pestering, mouthpiece shopping becomes likely, but what actually happens is a lot of internet-based procrastination.
3) Frustrated by choice, student/parent go to the local music shop (usually a branch of MusicRoom or similar, most people don't have a woodwind specialist nearby and won't travel unless they've been given a direct instruction!) and find that the choice is limited to Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80, because 'thats what everyone recommends'.
Also, I have to say I disagree with Brian's quote - sorry Tom. I recommend working with what you have up to a point. Obviously if you use some of the stock mouthpieces that come with cheap horns they are frankly disastrous since they've been injection moulded and put straight into the case with no QA process. This is because the makers know they'll be thrown away 90% of the time.
The same is not true of the Yamaha pieces, I find their QA to be excellent, and the mouthpieces very consistent.
I've said elsewhere in the Caff that if you learn to drive in a diesel Fiesta you can probably migrate to a Mercedes without much trouble, but the other way around is not so easy. I think that developing embouchure flexibility is more important than starting out with everything perfect. I think a beginner could easily squeak on a 'perfect' setup, but it will be so much easier to play on the 'perfect' setup if you can already play on an imperfect one.
More important than that is encouraging students/parents to get into the process. The learning to play is always going to be hard but the starting to learn should be as easy as possible. Parents will usually go for the simple, cheap option.
Having said that, I take your point on the Runyon 22. I'll have to have a go on one at some point so that I can recommend them too.
Nick
1) Nothing, to begin with. Many parents as Kev says are reluctant to part with more readies unless they have to.
2) After a lot of pestering, mouthpiece shopping becomes likely, but what actually happens is a lot of internet-based procrastination.
3) Frustrated by choice, student/parent go to the local music shop (usually a branch of MusicRoom or similar, most people don't have a woodwind specialist nearby and won't travel unless they've been given a direct instruction!) and find that the choice is limited to Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80, because 'thats what everyone recommends'.
Also, I have to say I disagree with Brian's quote - sorry Tom. I recommend working with what you have up to a point. Obviously if you use some of the stock mouthpieces that come with cheap horns they are frankly disastrous since they've been injection moulded and put straight into the case with no QA process. This is because the makers know they'll be thrown away 90% of the time.
The same is not true of the Yamaha pieces, I find their QA to be excellent, and the mouthpieces very consistent.
I've said elsewhere in the Caff that if you learn to drive in a diesel Fiesta you can probably migrate to a Mercedes without much trouble, but the other way around is not so easy. I think that developing embouchure flexibility is more important than starting out with everything perfect. I think a beginner could easily squeak on a 'perfect' setup, but it will be so much easier to play on the 'perfect' setup if you can already play on an imperfect one.
More important than that is encouraging students/parents to get into the process. The learning to play is always going to be hard but the starting to learn should be as easy as possible. Parents will usually go for the simple, cheap option.
Having said that, I take your point on the Runyon 22. I'll have to have a go on one at some point so that I can recommend them too.
Nick
Last edited by a moderator:

