Introduction Mouthpieces

OK, I'm mostly talking in terms of kids here, but if I recommend a mouthpiece in my experience what happens is:

1) Nothing, to begin with. Many parents as Kev says are reluctant to part with more readies unless they have to.
2) After a lot of pestering, mouthpiece shopping becomes likely, but what actually happens is a lot of internet-based procrastination.
3) Frustrated by choice, student/parent go to the local music shop (usually a branch of MusicRoom or similar, most people don't have a woodwind specialist nearby and won't travel unless they've been given a direct instruction!) and find that the choice is limited to Yamaha 4C/Selmer S80, because 'thats what everyone recommends'.

Also, I have to say I disagree with Brian's quote - sorry Tom. I recommend working with what you have up to a point. Obviously if you use some of the stock mouthpieces that come with cheap horns they are frankly disastrous since they've been injection moulded and put straight into the case with no QA process. This is because the makers know they'll be thrown away 90% of the time.
The same is not true of the Yamaha pieces, I find their QA to be excellent, and the mouthpieces very consistent.
I've said elsewhere in the Caff that if you learn to drive in a diesel Fiesta you can probably migrate to a Mercedes without much trouble, but the other way around is not so easy. I think that developing embouchure flexibility is more important than starting out with everything perfect. I think a beginner could easily squeak on a 'perfect' setup, but it will be so much easier to play on the 'perfect' setup if you can already play on an imperfect one.

More important than that is encouraging students/parents to get into the process. The learning to play is always going to be hard but the starting to learn should be as easy as possible. Parents will usually go for the simple, cheap option.

Having said that, I take your point on the Runyon 22. I'll have to have a go on one at some point so that I can recommend them too.

Nick
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Its just that the majority of folks who have played a Runyon 22 rate it way above a Yamaha - and it is about the same price. Helpfully it has quite wide rails and reduces squeaking in this way. Interestingly I recently bought a Buffet Crampon A400 Alto sax, which came with a Runyon 22. Feel free to give it a blow if you are interested. It has no writing on it but seems to be about a 5 tip opening.

I'd never aim my comments at kids - different ball game from my perspective, though my 10yo daughter has thrived on a larger mouthpiece on her trumpet than the 7C - plays a 3C which is larger the lower the number just to confuse matters. I have also just manage to buy a Morgan Protone Tenor 0.090" so will give that a go, see what Brian's work is like.
Hope you're having a good day!
 
As you say - the Yamaha is a high quality mouthpiece. Hence the comment found on Amazon.com on Jan 8, 2012:

"This review is from: Yamaha Alto Sax Mouthpiece 4C (Electronics)

Purchased this mouthpiece for my daughters alto sax to replace the cheap one that came with her sax. With the positive reviews I had hoped for a decent sounding sax. The mouthpice is completely unusable. She is not able to play any notes. Took the mouthpiece to her music teacher to make sure she was not creating the problem. Music teacher not able to get the mouthpiece to produce any notes."

And to think I started off believing you, as well..........................................:shocked:;}
 
"...The mouthpice is completely unusable. She is not able to play any notes. Took the mouthpiece to her music teacher to make sure she was not creating the problem. Music teacher not able to get the mouthpiece to produce any notes."

If that's truly the case they need to replace a clearly shoddy mouthpiece or shoddy teacher...! If a teacher can't get a mouthpiece to "play any notes" then it ought to be visibly broken, not just badly made. I have never encountered anything like this from a branded mouthpiece of any description!

Nick

P.S. Did the buyer buy through Amazon or eBay..?! :w00t:
 
Hi Nick!

Sorry - bit of a wind up on my part. The quote was actually from Amazon.Com - customer reviews section. I've never experienced that even with all sorts of stock mouthpieces - soprano with BW Curvie, and Rampone straight amongst others.

On the theme of Beginner mouthpieces I have ordered a Bari Esprit II and a Clark Fobes Debut to trialand will give you feedback. The Bari is actually only £14 inc shipping so I'm curious. The Fobes is £36, similar to the Yamaha and Runyon 22 in price.
Kind regards
Tom
 
Hi Tom, took delivery of my TJ Raw today, great but surprise surprise, hit the high palm key notes
with ease but lower register low c, d, with difficulty.

Were as on my old Artemis the reverse. The raw has a narrower bell could this be the reason?

Re the Runyan 22 managed to get one from Sax UK with difficulty, a six lay. The assistant was very helpful and explained that Messrs Runyan mouthpieces are quite hard to come by hence me going for a six which is all they had.

Should receive it by Saturday will let you know how I find it.

Thanks again to you and all the Guys and Gals who have offered their advice. Regds. N.





.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
As the OP seems happy with the responses and the thread is still running, I'd like to ask a question. I'm beginning to play alto (clarinet is my normal instrument) and I'm interested in mouthpieces without having a real need to change yet. In finding a mpc that I was happy with for the clarinet, I settled on a Yamaha hard rubber mpc. Do Yamaha make a hard mpc for alto? I haven't been able to find one.

I realise that my logic, if it worked on the clarinet then it might work on an alto sax, has no reason to be sound but then again, we are talking about mouthpieces. Does anyone know of a Yamaha hard rubber mpc for alto?
 
As the OP seems happy with the responses and the thread is still running, I'd like to ask a question. I'm beginning to play alto (clarinet is my normal instrument) and I'm interested in mouthpieces without having a real need to change yet. In finding a mpc that I was happy with for the clarinet, I settled on a Yamaha hard rubber mpc. Do Yamaha make a hard mpc for alto? I haven't been able to find one.

I realise that my logic, if it worked on the clarinet then it might work on an alto sax, has no reason to be sound but then again, we are talking about mouthpieces. Does anyone know of a Yamaha hard rubber mpc for alto?

Yes Tony they do,its their custom mouthpiece they supply with their custom series saxophones,it might be hard to find but some shops might have one or sometimes you see them on Ebay.

Brian
 
Thanks for this information. My apologies for not finding it myself but I seem to have got into the habit of searching the US sites and not those in the UK. I live in Brisbane and, as anyone over here will tell you, there's never any joy searching the local sites.
 
Update on Runyon 22 alto mouthpieces:

East Coast Wind have "loads but no 7's" - they are due in in a couple of weeks. They cost £30 with £3 shipping. They can be found here
Deadimage removed
Hi Tom , My Runyon 22, 6 lay, arrived early. I can only say nice mouthpiece great quality finish for the price. Really pleased, thanks for the recommendation. Using a Rico 4 with it. I have got over the initial glitch on the lower register on my new TJ Raw. Interesting little point on this instrument when I'm practising chromatics the key action is so smooth my speed has improved dramatically. Regds N
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,686
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom