Mouthpieces Mouthpiece for a Bass Saxophone?

Your friend and mine Michael Somerset got a Vandoren bass mouthpiece from us a few years ago- i notice these haven't come up in this chat yet...
I thought I had mentioned Vandoren. I tried it twice (different horns, different times) and it was pretty terrible compared to my Selmer. I returned both. Felt like a bari mouthpiece to me and lacked that big, deep sound a bass should have. If your friend likes his, I’d encourage him to try a Selmer to see what he’s been missing.

For the record, I’ve played a lot of bass the past couple of years, weekly rehearsals and at least one gig per month on average. So I’ve put in a lot of time on the mouthpieces I’ve tried.
 
Last edited:
I watched a Youtube video on these basses by a chap called Jared de Leon, and he makes a bass m/p which he plays on the video. Has anyone heard of or encountered these? He sells 'em at $160 dollars, which is about £140 - a LOT cheaper than a Selmer or Vandoren - although the Customs and Excise will no doubt firk more money out of a British purchaser in taxes. Adrian Rollini used a baritone m/p but I believe he had alterations made to the crook to improve the intonation. Unfortunately, I've mislaid the article in which he details what he did. Link to the de Leon m/p: Bass saxophone mouthpiece — JDWoodwinds | Custom clarinet accessories
Yes I have.
I was very disappointed with it and sent it back.
 
Update on bass mouthpieces.

I tried a Pillinger 6* bass mouthpiece. It's quite a bit more open than my Selmer. So to get the same response, I had to go down a bit in reed strength. At that point the sound is darker (duller) but not necessarily fuller as I had hoped. I think the facing is actually quite a bit too short to get the best bass sound. Plus the more open facing takes quite a bit more air. So I still rank Selmer significantly better in terms of tone and ease of playing, at least on my short wrap horn. But the Pillinger does have a nice, dark tone and excellent intonation, just too dark for my taste. It would probably make an ideal classical mouthpiece.
I want to add that Ed Pillinger was great to deal with, and that this piece would probably work great for someone after a more classical sound. It's a fantastic value for a handmade piece of such quality.
 
Now, this is how I would like to play the bass saxophone. What a lovely warm sound.

View: https://youtu.be/_mf6RIdH2JQ


I wonder what mouthpiece he is playing (even though I know that it's Scott who makes the difference).

Rhys

I emailed Scott a year or so back to ask what setup he used on bass. He plays a vintage Woodwind Co mouthpiece. I'm not sure what size though.

Screenshot_20230124_155956_YouTube.webp
 
I've been on the bass saxophone mouthpiece merry-go-round for the last 6-12 months or so. I've mainly been looking for vintage pickle barrel type mouthpieces. Started out with the original Conn 'eagle' bass mouthpiece that came with my horn and have ended up with a bunch of pieces including a Holton, a couple of Riffault pieces (R3 & R4), also a couple of vintage Woodwind Co mouthpieces (B6* and B4*). Here's the haul plus a 'Pennsylvania' piece that a friend just lent me to try. Can you guess which mouthpiece plays/sounds best? Yes, it's the the one which doesn't belong to me 🙁

20230308_151408.jpg
 
I’m interested in the Riffault pieces which I guess were baritone pieces. Do you know if they were modified in terms of the bore, the facing and maybe the chamber ?

And how did they play for you ?

Rhys

The Riffault pieces appear original and unmodified. They have a more focused sound and perhaps slightly more volume than the other pieces probably due to the flat side walls and slightly smaller chamber.
 
Mouthpiece update.

While I was initially impressed with the Thomann piece, I'm changing my tune after more time with it and a couple of different reeds. While intonation and tone are ok, it's just too closed. Low end is pretty thin, and even with harder reeds it's too easy to overblow when I need more volume.

I'm keeping an eye out for a "Pennsylvania" like Hank's or a Woodwind Co. In the mean time, I've gone back to my Selmer and put the Thomann away.

Now to find the perfect reed...
 
I ended up getting a Lebayle Rosie 7* and I'm very pleased with it!

You just beat me to it Damflask. 😉 I was just going to mention the Rosie.

I got a Rosie bass saxophone MP to play-test from Brian Landrus--the official distributor of the brand. My original plan was to review the piece only. In the end I liked the piece so much, I ended up keeping it.

I haven't finished writing my review yet since I've too tied up with a lot of other things. However, I can unequivocally state that with the Jinbao-made bass saxophones, like the Thomann mentioned by the OP, these Rosie pieces work flawlessly.

Their tone is beautiful, and the control they allow you over this rather awkward best, is amazing.

I use it as well on my own JK-made bass, but it requires a lot more air than my other bass sax pieces.

If you play a short wrap, the Rosie is a snap to play. If you own a long-wrap horn, it might take you longer to develop the necessary air support to get the full potential out of the piece.

For reeds, the Rosie really does best with bass saxophone reeds. I use a Harry Hartmann Fiberreed bass reed, but I do know players who use baritone Hartmann reeds. If you are a cane reed user, the Rico bass sax/contrabass clarinet reeds are perfect, and are the ones that Brian himself uses in his work.

5-bass-mps-top-blur.jpg


From left to right: Rosie bass; Vandoren bass; Geo Bundy bass/bari; Riffault bass; Runyon bari blank that was customized specifically for bass as per instructions by non other than Santy Runyon himself.

rosie-bottom.jpg
 
Last edited:
I’m interested in the Riffault pieces which I guess were baritone pieces. Do you know if they were modified in terms of the bore, the facing and maybe the chamber ?

And how did they play for you ?

Rhys

My Couf came with a Riffault bass piece. In the post above it is the MP 2nd from the right in the row of MP. Here is the bottom view of the same MP. (Riffault again 2nd from the right.)

5-bass-mps-bottom.jpg

From left to right: Rosie bass; Vandoren bass; Geo Bundy bass/bari; Riffault bass; Runyon bari blank that was customized specifically for bass as per instructions by non other than Santy Runyon himself.
 
Last edited:
I got a Rosie bass saxophone MP to play-test from Brian Landrus--the official distributor of the brand. My original plan was to review the piece only. In the end I liked the piece so much, I ended up keeping it.
Never tried that but it sounds interesting. Having now sold my bass ( to @john_dikeman here ) I am of course very much regretting it as it was such a good bass.

I would have like to try one of those but the Pillnger still really knocked the socks off any other I tried. Closest was Harry Gold's Toots Mondello but less versatile.
 
Last edited:
Never tried that but it sounds interesting. Having now sold my bass ( to @john_dikeman here ) I am of course very much regretting it as it was such a good bass.

I would have like to try one of those but the Pillnger still really knocked the socks off any other I tried. Closest was Harry Gold's Toots Mondello but less versatile.
Man I'm loving that bass! Been playing it a lot in a bunch of different settings.

So I'm still new to the bass but I'll share what I've been trying out at the moment.

Pete gave me an exact copy of Harry's Toots Mondello piece Ed Pillinger made for him. Very interesting, I must say I don't quite have a handle on it. I feel like I can see a bit where Harry's sound came from though. Harry had the most tuba like sound of any bass saxophonist that I know of. Not sure if others agree...?

I'd love to get one of Pillinger's regular bass mpcs at some point. I borrowed one for a bit and it was really a beautiful mouthpiece. Probably one of the best bets for a bass piece, especially for the price.

Right now I've got two prototype pieces from Phil Engelman of PhilTone which are excellent. I'm not sure if he's going to offer these as a standard mouthpieces but if he did, that'd be my clear suggestion for a medium/ largish chamber piece that plays great and dark, not as extreme as one of the old school "dill pickle" pieces, but still dark, and the chamber isn't so extreme as to cause tuning problems on some basses (such as the Jinbao). They also have some real projection without being too bright. I'm not sure but I think Pillinger's piece is a bigger chamber. This is probably closer to Selmer C* territory. And personally, I much prefer this over the C* I had for a while.

My all around favourite is a slightly modified Woodwind & Co. It has a big, dark, woody sound, with enough projection for most settings. I think if I really need to project, or just have a slightly more centred sound that could cut more and responds a bit faster, I'd go with one of the Phil Tone pieces.

I also recently got a custom Caravan in a .110 opening. That's really nice but very dark. I find the Woodwind more woody and projecting more, while the Caravan is just dark dark dark. Which is also cool. From what I've tried that's the extreme in that direction. I had to add a bit of epoxy to the chamber to get it to tune on the Buescher, it was just too big of a chamber and without that I would push it all the way until the shank was hitting the neck brace and couldn't go in any further, and it was still a bit flat. Nonetheless, a very nice piece I play a lot as well.
Incidentally, I found that decreasing the chamber size at the far end of the chamber, as close to where the neck would enter the piece as possible, didn't really change the sound.
 
Rosie on the far left. It's very slim, I'm using a soprano ligature at present.

I use a Rovner lig. that Brian was good enough to send along for the review.
Ps. Where did you get the Mouthpiece cap?
I have lots of extra Rovner caps in my studio. Rovner is generally the only lig. I use.
Never tried that but it sounds interesting. Having now sold my bass ( to @john_dikeman here ) I am of course very much regretting it as it was such a good bass.

I would have like to try one of those but the Pillnger still really knocked the socks off any other I tried. Closest was Harry Gold's Toots Mondello but less versatile.

You sold your bass? Oh dear. That is sad, although it sounds like @john_dikeman is giving it a good home. 😎

Yes, the Rosie MP is very interesting. I am currently using it on a Jinbao-made Selmer copy that belongs to the leader of a saxophone band I play in. It is simply brilliant for the short-wrap horns.

My favourite sax shop is in Bellingham, WA, and they have a fantastic player there who did his PhD in performance on an Orsi contra. Since Marcel has lots of air to spare,😉 I took the Rosie with me the last time I went down to the shop, and he had no problems playing it on his Buescher True Tone bass.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,071
Messages
578,541
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom