Saxophone beginners Mouthpiece: does this seem right?

I believe you should not add too much importance to different tip sizes without also taking the length of the curve into account. I’d can be misleading or even meaningless to compare tip size across different brands, but of course many people do so.

The more important factor to compare is resistance which can be a combination of all the different measurements including tip, facing curve and chamber.
 
Thank you, folks, for your help and contributions.

I'm being led by my teacher who knows why he recommended I try another piece; I don't. He didn't actually say to me that I should try a wider tip opening and I am sure all the different factors of mouthpiece construction and characteristics and reed strengths would have played a part in him suggesting it to me.

It was me who attached meaning to the size because I saw it was marked "7*" and as a very early beginner, it was the only thing I had any idea about. I'm not sure how I will get on with this piece until next week but I suppose the important thing for me at the moment is to stick to the plan and learn as I go.
 
I think the main thing to take away from this is that there is no such thing as 'one size fits all' in the most literal sense when it comes to reeds and mouthpieces.

You're fortunate to have a teacher who can observe you face to face to give you guidance, and also lend you the mouthpiece. I hope this helps build your confidence and get more comfortable playing the instrument.
 
You're fortunate to have a teacher who can observe you face to face to give you guidance, and also lend you the mouthpiece. I hope this helps build your confidence and get more comfortable playing the instrument.
Very true. He pays a lot of attention to what I'm doing and corrects my mistakes as I go. It's whag I need and I'm pleased to have found him
 
I am sure all the different factors of mouthpiece construction and characteristics and reed strengths would have played a part in him suggesting it to me.
Maybe, maybe not. I find that a hug majority of players just go by the number. I wouldn't be surprised if my observations above would probably be construed as being pedantic by most players.

And that is probably fine in most cases, where there is relevancy in comparing the tip opening, it's just that I think it shouldn't be assumed to be relevant 100% of theme as hard rule.
 
Maybe, maybe not. I find that a hug majority of players just go by the number. I wouldn't be surprised if my observations above would probably be construed as being pedantic by most players.

And that is probably fine in most cases, where there is relevancy in comparing the tip opening, it's just that I think it shouldn't be assumed to be relevant 100% of theme as hard rule.
Well you're a highly experienced player and, I believe, a mouthpiece designer whereas what I know about mouthpieces would fit on the back of a postage stamp so I'm sure your right, Pete.

I've only had 3 physical lessons so far and the whole mouthpiece thing is beyond me. I will just see how I find this one and settle on one or the other
 
Well you're a highly experienced player and, I believe, a mouthpiece designer whereas what I know about mouthpieces would fit on the back of a postage stamp so I'm sure your right, Pete.

I've only had 3 physical lessons so far and the whole mouthpiece thing is beyond me. I will just see how I find this one and settle on one or the other
If you and your teacher are happy, that's all that matters. Just be mindful of intonation which can be an issue with beginning players and open mouthpieces. Your teacher may be overlooking your intonation at this early stage, but you should start learning to recognize whether your are in tune or not and trying to control it.
 
See Turf3’s post again - the 1 1/2 reed is too soft for the 4C because the 4C has a shorter lay and small tip. The soft reed will perform better on the 7*. Better yet will be a mouthpiece that lets you use a 2 1/2 - perhaps a 6 - 6*, as 1 1/2 reeds tend not to be stable for very long.
That’s exactly what I did, started with my OL HR6 with 1 1/2, gradually increasing reed size over the years. Now using Legere 2.25 which is probably similar to 2.5 cane. I love my sound and don’t feel the need to change MP yet as I don’t need too much power/sound.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,703
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom