Beginner impro Major tunes vs minor

eb424

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,216
Location
london
[ADMIN: moved from Cry me a River transposition thread ]
How can they? The major song has a major 3rd. If you play a major 3rd in a minor song it will sound very different.
Hi @Pete Thomas could you expand and take it too another thread if needed...I'm stuck thinking the same as @thomsax that if the notes are the same but in a different order the song would sound the same...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Solution
Yes Em and G maj have the same key signature (one sharp - F#). But that's not the only thing that makes the tonality major or minor. There's no way to tell by looking only at the key signature whether a song is major or minor. You have to also look at the tonality, what note/chord does the melody/harmony resolve to? That tells you the tonality (major vs. minor).

Somebody selling sheet music should know the tonality of each tune, but if they only use the key signature as a guide, they may indeed mistake Em for G major. You have to be able to look at the notes of the tune to confirm you're buying the right key or not. If you still can't tell, play it on your horn and listen. Does it sound minor or does it sound major?

Nobody on earth is...
A major key is defined by the fact that the 3rd degree is major, so the interval between the tonic and 3rd is two whole tones.

On the other hand a minor key has a minor 3rd as the interval between the tonic and 3rd which is a whole tone and half tone.

One (albeit stereotypical) attribute of a minor key is it sounds sad. It is a smaller interval so sounds different.

So if you took a sad minor song such as Cry Me a River and changed the 3rd to be major, then it might sound a lot happier. Probably not quite so appropriate to the lyrics. Unless you want to be ironic.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes Em and G maj have the same key signature (one sharp - F#). But that's not the only thing that makes the tonality major or minor. There's no way to tell by looking only at the key signature whether a song is major or minor. You have to also look at the tonality, what note/chord does the melody/harmony resolve to? That tells you the tonality (major vs. minor).

Somebody selling sheet music should know the tonality of each tune, but if they only use the key signature as a guide, they may indeed mistake Em for G major. You have to be able to look at the notes of the tune to confirm you're buying the right key or not. If you still can't tell, play it on your horn and listen. Does it sound minor or does it sound major?

Nobody on earth is going to rewrite minor tunes in major and sell them. So when a publisher sells a minor chart and claims it's a major key, it's up to you to work out the actual tonality. In this particular case, if you see a chart of Cry Me A River with one sharp, the tune is in Em, regardless of what the publisher says.

Long story short the key signature of Em is the same as the key signature of G major. But the tonality of Em is NOT the same as G major.

If this doesn't make the difference between major and minor obvious, I don't what will:
View: https://youtu.be/2BkEorFwJGg

View: https://youtu.be/IHsjFdsd5lA

View: https://youtu.be/W2r41V27sEk

View: https://youtu.be/wSpsFJZ2riQ
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Solution
So if I listen to a melody/song and write down the what I hear, note by note, is wrong? I shouldn't play what I heard? I have done this a lot over the years. An A is an A, B is a B ..... the keys, major or minor share the same notes. If I read and play the transscribed notes, I'm not talking about music theory in general or arranging a minor song or improvising over minor chords.... . Just to play what I hear or as it's written on the paper. G major or G minor, both have one sharp.
Major and minor DON'T share the same notes! G major has one sharp. G minor has two flats!

I know you meant to say that E minor and G major share the same notes (one sharp). But surely you understand the difference between tonality and key signature. Do the clips above sound the same as the original songs?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes Em and G maj have the same key signature (one sharp - F#). But that's not the only thing that makes the tonality major or minor. There's no way to tell by looking only at the key signature whether a song is major or minor. You have to also look at the tonality, what note/chord does the melody/harmony resolve to? That tells you the tonality (major vs. minor).

Somebody selling sheet music should know the tonality of each tune, but if they only use the key signature as a guide, they may indeed mistake Em for G major. You have to be able to look at the notes of the tune to confirm you're buying the right key or not. If you still can't tell, play it on your horn and listen. Does it sound minor or does it sound major?

Nobody on earth is going to rewrite minor tunes in major and sell them. So when a publisher sells a minor chart and claims it's a major key, it's up to you to work out the actual tonality. In this particular case, if you see a chart of Cry Me A River with one sharp, the tune is in Em, regardless of what the publisher says.

Long story short the key signature of Em is the same as the key signature of G major. But the tonality of Em is NOT the same as G major.

If this doesn't make the difference between major and minor obvious, I don't what will:
View: https://youtu.be/2BkEorFwJGg

View: https://youtu.be/IHsjFdsd5lA

View: https://youtu.be/W2r41V27sEk

View: https://youtu.be/wSpsFJZ2riQ
Aint they horrible..
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I agree with all the above.

Maybe I've missed something but I've not seen the term 'relative minor" (or relative major) in this thread so far. Yes, they both share the same notes and key signature. Because of this - apart from having a different tonality (major/minor) - they are also (audibly) strongly related. So a simple 4 chord sequence on a guitar might be Root (major), relative minor, 4, 5. For example C, Am, F, G.

Another example is the song "Halleluja" in which alternating C (root) and Am (rel, minor) plays a prominent part. With just 1 exception (G->E7), the song is based on Root (C), Am (rel. minor), F(4) and G(5).

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i4h91YXLGsU
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
.
So when a publisher sells a minor chart and claims it's a major key
Small observation. In the OP that ignited this thread, both the sheet music and karaoke sites are clear the material is minor. Neither claim anything is major. That the conversation segued into this topic just proves we live in a glitchy simulation.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Think it was said em has the same notes as g major that was all... i.e. f#.. BTW tonality..???
Usually it doesn't. It has the same key signature as its relative major, but very very often has a raised 7th (or 6th). The exception would be if it is a natural (aeolian) mode, but in regard to "standards" (as we are) and giving clear and precise info for people not overly familiar with music theory, no need to complicate things by going into modal territory.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0
The thing with the term "minor" is that it is used to describe several different types of chords/scales/note collections, whereas "major" pretty much just means one thing.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@thomsax, I agree that notes are absolute in terms of their frequency. In modern western music, an A is 440 Hz (or some integer multiple of that). But in terms of functional harmony, an A could be the major 3rd of an F chord or the minor 3rd of an F#m chord or the sharp 11 of an Eb chord. So the function each note serves is not absolute. It changes according to the notes around it (above, below, before and after).

Let's say for example, you learn Mary Had A Little Lamb in the key of C major (for your tenor) by ear - E D C D E E E ..., etc. In terms of scale degrees that's 3 2 1 2 3 3 3 ... Yes, an E is an E is an E. But if you say you just played that tune in Am because Am and C share the same key signature, that's where things go wrong. Home base for Am is A, not C as it is in the original tune. So play a C chord then the first few notes of the tune, then play an Am chord and the first few notes of the tune. It's a totally different tune in the second case even though the melody notes are the same. The tensions and tonality are completely different. To truly play the tune in Am, the notes would be C B A B C C C, etc.

The fact that an major key and it's relative minor share the same key signature is not in dispute. What's in dispute is claiming that major and minor tonalities are equivalent. By extension, you could also claim that all seven modes of the major scale are functionally equivalent because they all have the same notes. They are most certainly not.

In a rock context, imagine you have your friends over to play a rock song based on an E blues. You wouldn't tell the bass and guitar to play a blues in Dbm would you? It's the same notes after all. No, that would be crazy.
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom