I was thinking more about this
@eb424
Cane and polypro are very different materials, so rules for one don't necessarily govern the other
The underlying assumption in this thread is that both cane and polypro bend to accommodate mouthpiece table imperfections, and once bent they don't resume their previous shape, so they don't play well on other mouthpieces
However, I don't think cane bends, it absorbs moisture and swells under the ligature and into any unevennesses in the mouthpiece table. The rule of not moving cane reeds from mouthpiece to mouthpiece suggests that there is some permanent, irreversible change in the cane shape. So once swelling has occured, some or all of it remains
Polypropylene doesn't absorb water and so doesn't deform in that way. Nevertheless there is an assumption in this thread that Légères do deform on the mouthpiece table and that they deform permanently. I doubt that I or anyone else tightens the lig sufficiently to reshape the body of a Légère, because they are so robust, however...
If you really, really overtighten the lig over a Légère reed, you
might squish the reed out of true on an uneven mouthpiece table. But then if you're in the habit of applying that much lig pressure, your poor abused Légère will yield and squish into the next mouthpiece anyway