Saxophone beginners Learning Clarinet

funkyrag

Member
Messages
33
Location
USA
Hi, I'm a sax player (have played alto and tenor) wanting to learn clarinet, is it doable? Any advice for me? Also, what's an Albert system clarinet? Thanks.
 
It's certainly doable. Quite frustrating at times. A lot of practice helps. I found it difficult to get even a reasonable tone in the high notes. The clarinet is certainly not as forgiving as, for example, the tenor saxophone. It shouldn't be hard to get info on the Albert system, but it probably is not what you want to do.
 
Also, what's an Albert system clarinet? Thanks.
It’s a very old fingering system that I think most saxophone players would find very awkward compared with Boehm system that is now the norm.

It’s probably also worth determining if the instrument is high pitch, in which case it won’t play in tune with modern instruments.
 
Lifelong sax player here who learned clarinet late in life. I learned from the beginning band book that came with it. 3 months later I was playing it in my community concert band, a big band and a Dixieland band. So it is possible.

I found the throat tones the most challenging by far, so I drilled those and chalemeau a lot. I also sightread thousands of exercises and tunes, everything I could get my hands on. Repetition is the name of the game, as it is with any instrument.

I wouldn’t bother with anything weird like Albert system. Just get a normal clarinet. Mine was fifty bucks from a middle schooler Cindy who apparently loved Jeff very much according to all the scribbles in her band book. Hopefully things work out for them. Best of luck to you too.
 
This is a list I made of the differences in the fundamentals of tone production of each instrument I used when teaching students who started on clarinet to switch to saxophone.

Forming the Embouchure
Clarinet - "EE" muscles pull out, "OO" muscles push in forming a tug-o-war that ends in a tie.

Saxophone - "EE" muscles pull out, "OO" muscles push in forming a tug-o-war where the "OO's" win but the "EE" muscles keep pulling.

Clarinet - the bottom lip is stretched thin to minimize the amount of lip touching the reed resulting in a flat chin.

Saxophone - the bottom lip is fuller providing more of a cushion to the reed resulting in a chin that is "rounded" but not bunched.

Mouthpiece
Clarinet - the mouthpiece is tilted down at about a 45° angle.

Saxophone - the mouthpiece enters straight into the mouth or tilted downward very slightly.

Clarinet - (due to the angle of the mouthpiece) the top teeth are closer to the tip of the mouthpiece.

Saxophone - the top teeth are placed to position the bottom lip approximately where the mouthpiece and reed separate.

Air stream
Clarinet - generally speaking uses faster, colder air.

Saxophone - generally speaking uses slower warmer air.

Mouthpiece pitch
Clarinet - plays near the top of the mouthpiece pitch (lipping up closes off the reed).
 
This is a list I made of the differences in the fundamentals of tone production of each instrument I used when teaching students who started on clarinet to switch to saxophone.

Forming the Embouchure
Clarinet - "EE" muscles pull out, "OO" muscles push in forming a tug-o-war that ends in a tie.

Saxophone - "EE" muscles pull out, "OO" muscles push in forming a tug-o-war where the "OO's" win but the "EE" muscles keep pulling.

Clarinet - the bottom lip is stretched thin to minimize the amount of lip touching the reed resulting in a flat chin.

Saxophone - the bottom lip is fuller providing more of a cushion to the reed resulting in a chin that is "rounded" but not bunched.

Mouthpiece
Clarinet - the mouthpiece is tilted down at about a 45° angle.

Saxophone - the mouthpiece enters straight into the mouth or tilted downward very slightly.

Clarinet - (due to the angle of the mouthpiece) the top teeth are closer to the tip of the mouthpiece.

Saxophone - the top teeth are placed to position the bottom lip approximately where the mouthpiece and reed separate.

Air stream
Clarinet - generally speaking uses faster, colder air.

Saxophone - generally speaking uses slower warmer air.

Mouthpiece pitch
Clarinet - plays near the top of the mouthpiece pitch (lipping up closes off the reed).
These are all excellent pointers that you should absolutely heed.

During your early career with the clarinet it will reward you with egregious squeaks should something not be absolutely perfect with fingering and or embouchure, you’ll probably find this much more pronounced as you ascend from the throat tones to the fuller length tones with register key. This is in realty just practice practice practice, if you can in front of a mirror (or teacher even better if you can get one) to see what’s slightly off.

Throat tones (A/#,G#) require a lot of voicing work to get full and consistent, but mind there are many useful fingerings to being a fuller tone and help with intonations.

Voicing the very top notes is a lot easier to pick up on clarinet, I have a young student who has blasted his was up the range and can hit them consistently with ease (the tone still needs a lot of work but he’s improving all the time).

It’s good fun though and a much less
Steep learning curve than the flute for eg. You’ll always be able to get a nice tune out of it with a sax background.
 
I started on clarinet as a kid.
I basically agree with the conventional wisdom that it's the easier route to take if you want to play both eventually. Get some lessons with a good teacher to avoid bad habits developing early on.
 
The great thing about clarinet is the range.
The frustrating thing, for me, is the register key.
Engage it and you're up a 12th. Moving from clarinet to saxophone feels much easier.
I started on recorder, added clarinet. Moving to saxophone felt like coming home. The similarities help. A bit like playing guitar and banjo. Same but different.

The Albert system has simpler keywork. Sometimes called the Simple system. Many of the alternative fingerings and trill keys are absent.
Many New Orleans Jazz players use them very successfully.
Some passages and runs are easier to negotiate if you have the alternative fingerings of the boehm system available.
Having said that there's less to fudge.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,662
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom