Tone or Sound Just when I thought I'd found my reed

I'm in no rush to step up to harder reeds, I don't have reed vanity. Got home this evening and popped a new 2S filed reed on, a lesser played 2M, and the V16.

Getting completely different experience again, so driving me round the bend.

Tired reed, me being sloppy with embouchure :headscratch: just going to get on and play the sodding thing.
 
I've finally, after years of messing around with different brands and strengths, settled on Vandoren ZZ alto reeds. For me they have a nice balance between dark and bright and seem to be quite consistent from reed to reed.
My soprano setup is less fussy and as long as a reed isn't too soft then I'm usually happy with the sound. My favourites are Marca, Hemke and Vandoren blue box.
The big mistake I made in the early years was the endless search for some holy grail mouthpiece that would make me sound like Paul Desmond without ever having to do any practice. When you find a mouthpiece you like, stick with it and find a reed that's a good match.
 
As a returning player, I've been practicing an hour a day, alongside my regular lessons.

I thought I'd found my perfect set up, Jazz Select 6M mouthpiece, with Jazz Select 2S, and more recently 2M reeds.

I wasn't happy with the sound, sometimes a bit muffled, and spitty.

I rummaged around and found a V16 1 1/2 reed from a sample pack I purchased months ago.

I remember thinking it was a bit hard, but gave it a go today. It sounds to my ear that the articulation is sharper and sound brighter, coupled with a little more resistance.

Are V16's harder, more resistant than Jazz Selects?

Hard to make a judgment off the 1 V16 reed I have, and don't want to go buying more if I'm simply imagining it.
In my experience Vandoren reeds run hard, your 1.5 may be more like a 2.0 or 2.25.
 
May as well throw in an opinion that's not been completely covered: Synthetics! Doesn't matter what brand of cane you buy. It's a natural product that isn't consistent. The larger the reed (Tenor, Baritone) the more potential for anomalies. Higher pitch saxes (sopranino, soprano) have smaller reeds, so less potential for anomalies. Alto is in between. When you buy a box of cane reeds most experienced players on alto or lower pitch horns find only a few per box that are truly good. The others you can "work" to try and make good, with mixed success. No matter what, the life of any cane reed is limited.
I recommend that any learner/student only use synthetics. There are lots of brands of synthetics available and players will recommend different ones (same as with cane) depending on their experience and perceived preferences. The major difference between cane and synthetics are consistency and longevity. A good synthetic can last more than a year. That means that the student/player can concentrate on every other aspect of playing using that consistency and not wondering if the (cane) reed has gone beyond it use by date or whether a new reed is playing well or you're just having a flabby lip day. With cane you're always in a flux between variations and a new reed becoming an old reed.

Learning sax isn't like playing piano or other consistent tone instruments. With a sax you make the tone. Having all the variability inherent with cane and also having to get used to new reeds which deteriorate = not developing the consistency of tone production and retarding your development.

Those who advocate being a purist and only using cane are (IMHO) not thinking of the student's best interests, but instead prolonging the student's development based on "tradition". There is no need to hobble yourself with "tradition" when the logical alternatives are now available. To be fair/honest, it not like good synthetics have been around forever, the really good ones are a recent phenomena. Once you've developed your embouchure and have a somewhat consistent tone, then that's a good time to experiment and see if there are other cane or synthetics that give you more of the tone you're after.

Use the search function to check other posts and you'll find lots of information regarding brands of good synthetics.
 
Last edited:
I'm in no rush to step up to harder reeds, I don't have reed vanity. Got home this evening and popped a new 2S filed reed on, a lesser played 2M, and the V16.

Getting completely different experience again, so driving me round the bend.

Tired reed, me being sloppy with embouchure :headscratch: just going to get on and play the sodding thing.
Try Legere synthetic reeds ..each one of it's type exactly the same.
 
I've given legere reeds a go (1.75 & 2.0) whilst they work, and seem consistent from my small sample, I do prefer to play cane.

Been concentrating on long tones. Getting a little bit frustrated, I gave it a good blowing, that seemed to clear things up.

Hmmmm, breath support? Not so much blowing harder, but firmer if that makes sense seems to help.
 
Hmmmm, breath support
More Huuuuaaa, breath support!

But yes. Because the reeds, mp and sax can be flakey, people fuss over them ... But, seems to me, they shouldn't be pandered to so much. Good solid breath will show them who's boss.

Not just breath; complete focus or intent. Ear, fingers,embouchure, voice etc.
 
Last edited:
More Huuuuaaa, breath support!

But yes. Because the reeds, mp and sax can be flakey, people fuss over them ... But, seems to me, they shouldn't be pandered to so much. Good solid breath will show them who's boss.

Keeping up with my long tones seems to be helping.

Tried some of the softer reeds I had but the higher notes lost their punch. So stuck with the 2M's and making an effort to rotate them, and driving the neighbourhood mental with long tones.

The result some of the practice pieces in my workbook are sounding much more consistent.

Below low D is improving too.
 
Keeping up with my long tones seems to be helping.

Tried some of the softer reeds I had but the higher notes lost their punch. So stuck with the 2M's and making an effort to rotate them, and driving the neighbourhood mental with long tones.

The result some of the practice pieces in my workbook are sounding much more consistent.

Below low D is improving too.
Carnegie Hall beckons!!
 
Had my first lesson in just under a month now my teacher is back.

I mentioned my sound issues, a quick play and I'm given few pointers on my embouchure & posture. I just need to concentrate on those so it becomes second nature, rather than just blowing the thing.

My poor timing and rythm was pointed out, which far outweighed the improvement in sound!

I've shortage of things to work on until my lesson.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,077
Messages
578,684
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom