Saxophone beginners Just had my first proper sax lesson

DaveT

Member
Messages
147
Location
UK
Making god-awful sqauwks for the first 5 minutes was a bit embarrassing but with some prompting about what I was doing wrong it came together.

The weight of the soprano on my right thumb had become a problem so I was using a strap.
I thought it wasn't long enough, but no, it was too long.
Shorten it an inch or so and things improved.

I was placing my left thumb on the wrong bit of the thumb rest too!
Get that right and the octaves came easily.

Pleased to say the tuning and intonation was good.
I use the Tune A Day for Tenor and we managed to play one of the simple duets which was fun.

I sang bass in a choir and often play bass guitar so the Treble Clef has been an alien thing to me for many years! A bit of catching up to do there...

I was told to go away and practice and come back in a couple of weeks and we'll see what needs working on next.
Quite pleased with it all.
Getting comfy with the weight and feel of the soprano using the strap means there is no need to hunt out a good curvie or saxello. Bad thing it kills the GAS!
 
Yes, I think most players would suggest that for a beginning sax player...Soprano would NOT be the recommended choice...proper embouchure and such is quite different from the other saxes and a bit more challenging IMHO.

Usually people start Alto or Tenor then move to Soprano after a bit of sax time under their belt.

But best of luck to you, OP, I applaud you for getting face-to-face lessons....nothing beats that.
 
I don't get on at all well with alto.
Not interested in tenor. Bought my ex a new Selmer tenor in 1988 to replace the old East German sax she had, she was thrilled! Nice, but not for me.
As a bass player I reckon I could get on well with a baritone, but big and expensive.
Beefheart could make a god-awful racket on a soprano and so I can I! Getting there in bringing it properly under control.
Learning an old Selmer that is nice and easy to play.
GAS wants a Rampone & Cazzani but happily no-one holds them in stock, and if I can't try it I'm not buying it.
And of problem then. For awhile.
 
R&C? Read the reviews.
Baritone.
Mine plays great. Coming up for a year of ownership it has zero issues and it's own fan following.
Black Friday is coming. PayPal pay in 3. :rolleyes:
 
How does a beginner judge an instrument they don't yet know how to play? As a sax player I'd be completely hopeless trying a bunch of guitars and choosing a good one. I'd try to find a player friend to help me.

Ideally, that would be my choice/advice too. But I personally doubt this always works for everyone. Probably for everyone who's a member of this forum 🙂 .

Thankfully, there are some widely recommended (e.g. Yamaha) models that beginners/novices can have confidence in that they will be:
- a good model to learn on
- a good model on which to develop their skills and perform on
- will retain their value, should they decide to re-sell

My personal tips on buying a sax as a beginner (novice) are:
- get a rough idea (via internet) on the general price ranges of saxes (I'd never realized that saxes were so expensive!)
- get a a rough idea (via internet - and especially via our sister site TTS) of the different 'reliable' brands/models
- try to get advice from someone you (via via) know
- if you're considering lessons, try and get a (potential) tutor to advise you and preferably accompany you when buying your 1st sax/mpc/reeds etc.
- if you have no personal 'sax' contacts, then visit a 'reputable' sax/instrument dealer; these have a reputation to maintain and won't - without discussion - 'palm you off' with a cheapo sax that you might find difficult te learn on or soon discover its limitations/re-sell value
- don't (yet) buy a 'sax bargain' from e-bay or other on-line marketplaces
- don't (yet) buy a 2nd hand sax from a market/shop and expect it to be playable (without any prior restoration/maintenance)

IMHO, the very worst thing that beginning/novice saxophonists can encounter is that - while they're learning to play sax, they're also struggling to play a 'not fit for purpose' sax. In other words, if the sax is - or has been reliably checked out as being OK, then beginners/novices can be confident that any 'challenges' are their own and not due to any imperfections on their saxes.
 
Back in the day I had one shop that sold organs and a single make of tenor and alto. That was the only choice.
I fell in love when I saw my first baritone in the window of Rushworths Liverpool.
Went home and talked my Dad into guaranteeing the finance. Weltklang.
Still got both btw.
How times have changed.
 
I had a Lade cheap Chinese soprano.
Having decided this was fun I managed to have a go on a better soprano. Ahhh!
Then I was able to try 9 different used sopranos made by Jupiter, Mauriat, Yamaha, Selmer and a couple I can't remember.
The Selmer Model 22 made in 1925 was the best of them. Easy to play, the keys that were very close in to the body by modern standards had been raised by carefully shaped wooden pieces glued on. The modern saxes had the keys too high for my liking. It felt good and sounded good.
Now I know it and me have decent intonation too.

I found the Mauriat to be 2nd best and would have bought that if the Selmer wasn't there.

I heard a Rampone & Cazzani alto at the studio where I work. The player was good, the tone was wonderful and it was loud! What's that then? R&C came the reply.

I had enough of poor quality instruments trying to play guitar 40 years ago. I'm an old man now and don't have time for it. Good equipment or else!
I would of course do a direct comparison between Mauriat, Theo Wanne, Yamaha, Yanagisawa and R&C - maybe even Selmer too, but no shops have them in stock. 'Order Only'. What use is that? I'm not spending £2k to £4k on something I haven't tried first.

I played fretless bass guitar because I could make it myself, made the neck, the body, the pickup (used my Meccano set to make the coil winder), the bridge, the amp, the speaker cab.
Naturally I ended up as an Electronics Engineer! Then CEng and Eur.Ing. now retired.
 
How does a beginner judge an instrument they don't yet know how to play? As a sax player I'd be completely hopeless trying a bunch of guitars and choosing a good one. I'd try to find a player friend to help me.

What attracts you to R&C?

Lydian, happily the horrible cheap guitars we had to use don't exist anymore.
But you would still be able to tell why a Gibson Les Paul is better then a cheap copy.

I like Ducatis and Italian wine, a handmade sax by R&C might be nice. Being hand made by craftsmen you probably need to try 6 of them because they will all be slightly different and one will sing for you.
 
I’m sure R&C are fine horns, but all saxes are hand made, some more carefully than others.

Sounds like you may have enough experience to judge after all, but most beginners don’t. Many cheap copies look and play quite well these days. Only an expert could truly judge.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,602
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom