David Roach
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 787
- Location
- London
I have to admit that I haven't given John's book any further attention recently. We moved house and I've been away every week playing etc etc. I'll try to get back to it in January.
I'd appreciate your viewI have to admit that I haven't given John's book any further attention recently. We moved house and I've been away every week playing etc etc. I'll try to get back to it in January.
Lucky you.I think I must have been.....
Jx
I recall that when John’s book first came out some of his concepts attracted a fair bit of controversy, Having seen his protege Jess Gillam perform at Hexham last Wednesday I reckon his methods do produce results. She was outstanding.
Actually, it's alto player Dave Pollack.It‘s probably Adam Larson himself playing in the clip. This said, Guenne sounds very good, too, judging from what he posts in the German forum.
The most interesting bit appears to be the section on using the glottal stop as an articulation technique
To which part?O. M. G. I haven't read through the other pages of this thread to find out if this fear has been a reality or if another end of a different stick was found after all. I've never been a fan of Harle. He's a classical guy that has dipped his toe into jazz when he really had no business in doing so other than down his local pub for fun. It either demonstrates a massive ego or massive ignorance, as his "jazz" playing is nothing more than a poor pastiche. There seems to be quite a British school of classical jazz-pastiche in the last twenty years or so.
As a non-famous person with no-one paying a fair amount of money to come and see you play presumably better than nearly everyone, you should play cross-genre. It's very enjoyable and a real challenge. Lots to be learned.
Perhaps we could have a festival of major stars swapping roles:
Dame Kiri Te Kanawa sings Bon Jovi
John Bon Jovi dances the Black Swan in Swan Lake
Darcey Bussell plays Art Tatum's Tea For Two
And John Harle - oh I think he does all of the above perfectly.
I have bought this book (which is very expensive at £48 and full of flashy, trivial and unnecessary artwork) and I have studied it in detail. My principal critique of it is that book 2 of the pair analyses critical issues like the implications of reed fan embouchure work for intonation in great detail, but only for alto and soprano instruments. It's obvious from Mr Harle's detailed analysis that tenor and baritone instruments require a different approach. So if you're essentially an alto or soprano player, it presents some valuable stuff and may possibly be worth paying £48 for. But if you're essentially a tenor or baritone player, book 2 is not particularly useful in my view because many of the points he makes are not transferable. He offers no explanation for their omission and to my mind, the work is a premature and incomplete publishing project by Faber, I think he/they badly need to revise it into a 2nd edition which gives equal attention to the particular challenges of playing tenor and baritone on a par with alto and soprano. Plus cut the unnecessary artwork and cut the price to no more than £30.And run it by John Surman!
In contrast, I have found Kim Walker's book 'Spirited Wind Playing' a very much more insightful and comprehensive work, albeit by a classical bassoonist, with many more transferable insights, and almost half the price! And I aspire to be essentially a jazz player. Hope this is helpful.