Playing the saxophone Jazz players and rock & roll players

Well, if we say somewhere in the 1952-55 time period is when rock and roll started to be widely perceived as something unto itself, let's keep in mind that MOST "jazz" people were actually listening to in that time period was NOT Diz and Bird and Monk. MOST jazz people were listening to was Goodman, Basie, Ellington, and all the lesser bands like Les Brown, Elgart brothers, Dorseys (both singly and together depending on when their next scheduled fistfight was), etc. And for younger people the R&Bish performers like Louis Jordan would have been kind of in that "jazz" bucket sort of too. So while it's a far jump from Thelonious Monk or the Birth of the Cool to Little Richard or Elvis, it's not such a far jump from Louis Jordan or Basie's blues.

Again, we're busy chopping all these genres up and assigning very specific roles and performers to them, when that was not the way it actually was. A guy like Coltrane would walk the bar on Saturday night and then play the most austere challenging music on Sunday night. Ornette put in a lot of time in R&B bands. And so on.

And we haven't even touched on the influence of gospel music, which has a lot of similarities between black and white modes along with differences. You know, there's a couple recordings of the Million Dollar Quarter so called: Elvis, Carl Perkins, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis, singing gospel songs with Elvis on piano (!!!) and they're beautifully done despite the obvious zero preparation or rehearsal and the crummy recording. These guys all had that whole style and genre right there in their heads accessible at a moment's notice because of who they were. That was a huge influence in their performance and for many of the Black performers of the time - Little Richard being maybe the best known.

A few final ones - how many people know that Doc Watson who's now an icon of country music was working in a rock and roll band when he was rediscovered? Earl Bostic who was a staple of early R&B was also a heavy influence on both Charlie Parker and John Coltrane for his outstanding technique including way up into the altissimo. Johnny Cash, Carl Perkins, Charley Pride, Marty Robbins, Conway Twitty were all people who ended up being filed by history in the "country" drawer but they all did a lot of rock and roll at one time. Show me how, for example, "Hey Porter" has to be country and "That's all Right" has to be rock. Never mind Elvis doing "Blue Moon of Kentucky" and then Bill Monroe changing HIS arrangement to include the fast 4/4 section a la Elvis.

I know this really doesn't have much of anything to do with writing note names over the words on a song, but it always chaps me when people start trying to chop up music into all these little categories and say "well, this is THIS so it can't be THAT."
They’re great examples. Pete and I (sorry to speak for you Pete, but I think we’re coming from the same place) aren’t pigeon-holing stuff, it’s just we don’t believe that anyone playing on a song or in a particular band automatically qualifies it as stylistically compatible.
Take your example of Brecker (he’s a colossus btw) - in Joni’s band he played much the same as he did in Jacko’s band and his own band, and at times the music was quite rock n roll. Some people undoubtedly loathed what he did over Joni’s stuff in the late 70’s and much preferred Tom Scott, with his far more out and out bluesy playing on her stuff a few years before.
I love it.
Tom Scott on Jump Jive and Wail isn’t that much of a, well, jump and certainly someone like Plas Johnson; but Mike on a rock n roll song doesn’t make it rock n roll..
 
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZWH-WiHVOE


Coltrane was employed by this singer a couple years before this recording was made. Do you really think he was unable to fulfill her requirements for a tenor sax player to walk the bar?
No you score big time here - perfect. But Brecker never changed his style (though he was quite a master at using altered dominants where nobody else could get away with it)
 
No you score big time here - perfect. But Brecker never changed his style (though he was quite a master at using altered dominants where nobody else could get away with it)
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZWH-WiHVOE


Coltrane was employed by this singer a couple years before this recording was made. Do you really think he was unable to fulfill her requirements for a tenor sax player to walk the bar?
Actually this is a perfect example against your earlier point about Brecker. I’d never pick this as being Coltrane, because he sounds like Sam Butera and is a world away from the Jazzer that he became: ie he’s playing rock n roll :confused2:
 
Actually this is a perfect example against your earlier point about Brecker. I’d never pick this as being Coltrane, because he sounds like Sam Butera and is a world away from the Jazzer that he became: ie he’s playing rock n roll :confused2:
the actual recording I posted does not have Trane. But do you think big Maybelle hired Trane because he COULDN'T do what she wanted?

I can't find any links to recordings of Trane in the R&B context. They're probably out there somewhere.

But I'm always going to take issue with the image of the jazz player as unable to do anything except weird stuff no one likes that meanders on forever and you can't dance to it. Yes, there are a few like that. But rockers have taken this thing to an absurd place where they've defined jazz as the plink-and-squeak crowd and if you say "Well, how about Fats Waller? Art Blakey? Horace Silver?" their heads explode.
 
OK, let's run that pop fly out. Here's an example of how Michael Brecker played on a rock and roll session, solo starts at 1:47:

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y6C_nyZLQR8


Really ought to listen to these things before popping off about what someone can and cannot do.
Mmm, doesn’t sound anything like Brecker and it was 1975. I’m gonna stand by what I said before. He never compromised to any degree like that again.
 
But I'm always going to take issue with the image of the jazz player as unable to do anything except weird stuff no one likes that meanders on forever and you can't dance to it. Yes, there are a few like that. But rockers have taken this thing to an absurd place where they've defined jazz as the plink-and-squeak crowd and if you say "Well, how about Fats Waller? Art Blakey? Horace Silver?" their heads explode.
Well keep hold of yer breeches there boy, I count myself as a jazzer.
 
But I'm always going to take issue with the image of the jazz player as unable to do anything except weird stuff no one likes that meanders on forever and you can't dance to it.
I think we are all in agreement over that aren't we?

Nobody here said otherwise. Of course some jazz is like that and some people are not very open minded.
 
But do you think big Maybelle hired Trane because he COULDN'T do what she wanted?

I can't find any links to recordings of Trane in the R&B context. They're probably out there somewhere.
I know that Coltrane played with Earl Bostic - but I'd never call him rock and roll, however I do have an album called Bostic Rocks. He was an amazing jazz and swing and R & B musician all round very versatile.

I wasn't aware Coltrane was ever hired by Big Maybelle and if he did play with her is there any evidence it was as soloist anyway? I somehow doubt it but I'm always happy to eat my hat.

I'll leave you with this though as the epitome of great rock and roll or R&B saxophone solo:

View: https://youtu.be/BWvSN95akdI?si=wrDAJYEv-1FWAa4J&t=49
 
I've been waiting for someone to mention the New Orleans alto player, Capt. John Handy, whom Bostic copied. Small band swing into R&B into rock 'n' roll, with gospel thrown in, and all played in a New Orleans Revival context…
 
I thought that the origins of saxes in rock n roll were jazz players….?
Yes, many of the R&B honkers had a background in big band jazz. Eddie Shaw (Muddy Waters, Howlin' Wolf ...) A.C. Reed (Earl Hooker) and J.T Brown (Elmore James) had different backgrounds. The music was "jazzified" before it became "rockified". Jazz was/is a wide concept. Recordings aimed to radio and jukeboxes changed the sax players. It was expensive to record and the players that were the recording companies the first call were effective. The big band saxophonist could read music and was used to play solos.
 
Yes, many of the R&B honkers had a background in big band jazz. Eddie Shaw (Muddy Waters, Howlin' Wolf ...) A.C. Reed (Earl Hooker) and J.T Brown (Elmore James) had different backgrounds. The music was "jazzified" before it became "rockified". Jazz was/is a wide concept. Recordings aimed to radio and jukeboxes changed the sax players. It was expensive to record and the players that were the recording companies the first call were effective. The big band saxophonist could read music and was used to play solos.
@Pete Thomas this is along the lines of what a mate used to say to me
 
I know that Coltrane played with Earl Bostic - but I'd never call him rock and roll, however I do have an album called Bostic Rocks. He was an amazing jazz and swing and R & B musician all round very versatile.

I wasn't aware Coltrane was ever hired by Big Maybelle and if he did play with her is there any evidence it was as soloist anyway? I somehow doubt it but I'm always happy to eat my hat.

I'll leave you with this though as the epitome of great rock and roll or R&B saxophone solo:

View: https://youtu.be/BWvSN95akdI?si=wrDAJYEv-1FWAa4J&t=49
I've read multiple biographies of Coltrane and I'm pretty confident about the Big Maybelle link.

I suppose she COULD have hired him as just a horn section member - but surely all the horn section guys also soloed. I think this would have been in the late 40s time frame; Coltrane was absolutely a bebopper in those days; so if he came across with that stuff he'd have been shown the door.

The famous "walking the bar" story comes from the lowest time in Trane's life which it seems was around 1954, so later than the Big Maybelle and King Kolax experience; but again, does anyone here really think Trane would have played sheets of sound while walking the bar in a dive bar in the red light district? Why, those CUSTOMERS would have handed his arsch to him, they wouldn't have waited for the bandleader.
 
Last edited:
@Pete Thomas this is along the lines of what a mate used to say to me
I think if you wanted to be a professional saxophonist in the late 30s through the late 40s you were playing in "jazz" contexts, and the most common of those was the small to large group playing for dancing. As that music became increasingly rhythmic (and from about 1950 or so, increasingly electrified), saxophone solos and horn parts became more simplified and emotional, leading to the playing styles of guys like Big Jay McNeely. Let's keep in mind that black bands playing for dancing pre-R&B would probably have been largely indistinguishable to US from the later R&B aggregations. Basie had a bluesy and swinging band, but it's always been my impression that he presented a seriously cleaned-up version of what would have been playing in a juke joint outside KC in say 1936.

I still think that the evolution of what small and medium groups playing for dancers in nightclubs were playing was far less dramatic and far more incremental than it's presented to us now. Nowadays the music is presented to us as "this is rock and roll, and that's jazz, and that's R&B" but I doubt very much that these distinctions were nearly as important to the dancers and the musicians of the time as they are to us, now, sitting in our suburban homes and typing on our computers some 70-80 years after the fact. And don't assume that someone playing in Big Maybelle's band wasn't listening to, and working with, what Diz and Bird were doing; nor that someone who played the most esoteric "modern jazz" for peanuts on Sunday nights didn't make his daily bread playing convincing raunchy "honker and bar walker" music on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday nights.

Listen to Pee Wee Russell with Marshall Brown on "Ask Me Now", playing Monk tunes - listen to Sonny Rollins and Coleman Hawkins on "Sonny meets Hawk" - listen to John Klemmer playing free jazz and then a few years later doing a completely convincing job on the smoothest of smooth "jazz". The musicians themselves I think constrain themselves a lot less than the analysts do. I know I"m not putting forth a lot of examples of rock and roll crossing with straightahead jazz, because I simply don't have the familiarity with the rock and roll sax as I do with jazz, but I'd submit that the stylistic difference of Klemmer's free work and his smooth-jazz work is at least as great as the difference between, say, Clarence Clemons and Sonny Rollins. We know Sonny made a couple rock recordings that were very convincing; I'd bet Clarence could have played very effectively in the same context as someone like Zoot Sims or Al Cohn. Put Clarence Clemons on the Basie bandstand next to Eddie Lockjaw Davis and I think you'd say, "two bluesy bootin' tenor guys, Davis plays a little more elaborate stuff and Clemons focuses more on the blues" and I think if you brought Davis to the stage with Springsteen, you'd say "man what a pair of great tenor players, Clarence the total gutbucket guy and Eddie more the sharp-dressesd man."
 
One last one for today: let's not forget that when Elvis first hit, very many listeners thought he was a black guy, in fact he caught a lot of grief from country musicians for "playing that [African American] stuff". I believe it was Hank Snow that actually reduced Elvis to tears, he was so angry and hateful about it. So initially it was perceived not that Elvis was doing something wildly different and new, rather that he was doing what Black musicians had been doing for a long time, and the difference was that he was a white guy.
 
Rollins work with "Stones" didn't impressed me. More spectacular than good.

Michael Brecker, Randy Brecker and David Sanburn played on Springsteen's "Tenth Avenue Freeze Out". They had some difficulties to get it right. Little Steven came to rescue the session. After that Van Zandt became a permanent member of the E Street Band. I don't know if the jazz guys work with The Boss again?
 
I don't know if Steve Douglas, Jim Horn, Bobby Keys, Plas Johnson Lee Allen had a genuine jazz background? Maybe Plas Johnson and his piano playing brother Ray, played jazz as "Johnson Brothers"?
 
I don't know if Steve Douglas, Jim Horn, Bobby Keys, Plas Johnson Lee Allen had a genuine jazz background? Maybe Plas Johnson and his piano playing brother Ray, played jazz as "Johnson Brothers"?
Mate of mine had Jim Horn on a record of his in the ‘90’s - seemed to think that he wasn’t a particularly fluent reader..

Plas Johnson was The Pink Panther, and played a lovely jazz solo. Well, I’ve heard him use some extended language so he’s a jazzer and a rock n roller in my eyes (?).

And Pete knows Lee Allen.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom