Playing the saxophone Jazz players and rock & roll players

The fundamental tenet of African American improvised music (of which rock and roll IS a subset) is to develop one's own personal sound.
Doesn’t really incorporate altered dominants et Al though does it.
If anything goes, then why do we designate styles?
 
Well, I'll leave the rest of this exercise to those who're interested; I reckon we all know how to look stuff up.

From Wikipedia a list of folks on whose albums Brecker played (I've taken out some like Frank Sinatra who'd never be called rock and roll....):

Steely Dan, Lou Reed, Donald Fagen, Dire Straits, Joni Mitchell, Eric Clapton, Billy Joel, John Lennon, Aerosmith, Dan Fogelberg, Kenny Loggins, Frank Zappa, Bruce Springsteen, Roger Daltrey, Parliament-Funkadelic, Cameo, Yoko Ono, Todd Rundgren, Chaka Khan, Orleans, Blue Öyster Cult, , Average White Band, Players Association, Everything but the Girl, Patti Austin, Art Garfunkel, Carly Simon, The Brothers Johnson, Karen Carpenter, and T-Square.
Yes I’ve heard loads of those. Sorry I didn’t mean reference sessions with rock bands. I meant some audio clips of him playing rock and roll.
 
Last edited:
Jazz (solos) is more demanding than rock sax (solos). No question about that. There is an intangible feeling when it comes to rock (& roll saxophone). A combo of the lines , tone of the player and setting.

Talking about "The Big Man" Clemons. A rock & roll saxophonist said:

" I have to admit that I was biased against him as teenager. I thought that Charlie Parker was where it was at so I dismissed Clarence's output as a player. That lasted until I tried to play in his style, then I quickly changed my mind. The tones he picks aren't anywhere near as difficult to play as "Countdown" by Coltrane, but the sound he gets and the energy is hard to reproduce".

Of course there are jazz players that can play rock (& roll). And there are rock saxophonists that can play jazz or classical.

I like jazz as well. But I don't play jazz because I'm not good enough. I wasn't an happy guy after a big band rehearsal. Coltrane and Parker, Brecker, Rollins .... were/are fantastic players. But I was raised with
CCR (John Fogerty), The Rolling Stones (Bobby Keys), Bruce Springsteen & East Street Band (Clarence Clemons) Otis Redding (Memphis Horns) ..... so it was natural for me to learn Blues, R&B, R&R, Soul, Country, Pop ... songs.

Most of what we today call Rock & Roll Saxophone came from the blues. And when the sax showed up at the rural Blues Joints the saxes were not played by well educated sax men that could play in all 12 keys. Today the rural blues joints are more or less gone?
 
Jazz (solos) is more demanding than rock sax (solos). No question about that. There is an intangible feeling when it comes to rock (& roll saxophone). A combo of the lines , tone of the player and setting.

Talking about "The Big Man" Clemons. A rock & roll saxophonist said:

" I have to admit that I was biased against him as teenager. I thought that Charlie Parker was where it was at so I dismissed Clarence's output as a player. That lasted until I tried to play in his style, then I quickly changed my mind. The tones he picks aren't anywhere near as difficult to play as "Countdown" by Coltrane, but the sound he gets and the energy is hard to reproduce".

Of course there are jazz players that can play rock (& roll). And there are rock saxophonists that can play jazz or classical.

I like jazz as well. But I don't play jazz because I'm not good enough. I wasn't an happy guy after a big band rehearsal. Coltrane and Parker, Brecker, Rollins .... were/are fantastic players. But I was raised with
CCR (John Fogerty), The Rolling Stones (Bobby Keys), Bruce Springsteen & East Street Band (Clarence Clemons) Otis Redding (Memphis Horns) ..... so it was natural for me to learn Blues, R&B, R&R, Soul, Country, Pop ... songs.

Most of what we today call Rock & Roll Saxophone came from the blues. And when the sax showed up at the rural Blues Joints the saxes were not played by well educated sax men that could play in all 12 keys. Today the rural blues joints are more or less gone?
I thought that the origins of saxes in rock n roll were jazz players….?
 
I think that's very hard to say, if you want to research it that would be great!
It’s just what a fairly learned friend used to say. Sounds plausible, especially if you look at the language used early on. But I’m sure you know a lot about it Pete.
 
But I’m sure you know a lot about it Pete.
Well not really. I think the problem comes when you try to define the origins of rock and roll, which is generally claimed to be around 1950 (claims being made for Bill Haley, Fats Domino and Elvis etc.)

But the "origins" are from at least a decade earlier with Jump Blues and Swing. So as those genres included both jazz and blues players as well as those who did both it's going to be a never ending argument probably 🙂

Bullmoose Jackson vs Illinois Jacquet I suppose.
 
Last edited:
Lovely (far too unsung) player. There’s also Tom Scott of course, whose arrangements for Dan are a real study. Don’t recall Ernie playing for Dan…

Ernie played on a couple of the Dan albums - part of the sax section on "My Old School" (along with Lanny Morgan, Bill Perkins and John Rotella) from the Countdown to Ecstasy album and I believe he's one of the duelling alto players along with Jerome Richardson on "Parker's Band" from the album Pretzel Logic...

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvziJUxrD6k


Greg S.
 
I thought that the origins of saxes in rock n roll were jazz players….?
Well, it's complicated.

There were a lot of threads in the creation of early rock and roll - and of course, not all early rock and roll was the same thing.

One thread is the old cliche that rock and roll was what happened when country and western met the blues. Certainly that's not a bad description of the Bill Haley/Elvis Presley track of early rock ("rockabilly") - except that Elvis was a Memphis guy and thoroughly steeped in all black popular music of the time, which included all the jump band or R&B type music of the time - think Louis Jordan and Big Jay McNeely. At the same time the black guys were taking that uptempo dance/RB type stuff and making it more and more rhythmic and wilder - think LIttle Richard, Fats Domino. And the blues guys were getting more and more of those shuffle and rhumba beats - Bo Diddley, anyone? Let's not forget the sweet tones of what we call "Doo-wop" - the street corner quartets - mostly black guys at first.

And all these people were listening to each other and being influenced. In the disreputable world of rock and roll/blues/RB/etc., there weren't the hermetic category divisions we see nowadays (even in statements like "Brecker wasn't playing rock and roll even with Aerosmith" - that's a hermetic division statement - sorry Pete). If you'd decided to leave the world of upright middle class morality and go hanging out amongst the boozers and druggies and ladies of the night with the musicianers (that's how your parents would have seen it), then white guys playing with black guys and black guys playing with white guys and all of them trying out different styles was the least of it.

Leaving aside the matters of racial discrimination that could be life-threatening, poverty, drug and alcohol abuse, theft of intellectual property, unspeakably bad working conditions, law-enforcement harrassment, and the generalized scorn of all "respectable" citizens, it was in some ways a golden period for popular music.
 
@Pete Thomas
I don’t see how anyone could argue that jazz/blues wasn’t the father of rock. Early rock is so obviously blues based. What else could it possibly have come from?
 
@Pete Thomas
I don’t see how anyone could argue that jazz/blues wasn’t the father of rock.
Indeed it's hard to argue with that (probably more blues than jazz if you think about the jazz that had evolved by the time rock & roll was deemed to be a genre. Although plenty of people do think there was a fair amount of country involved in rockabilly of course as you mentioned. So it could be argued there were several fathers.
 
I think you're describing Evanescence and didn't Queen do something similar.
Yes, but I’m not talking about just getting someone in to sing or play a certain part, moreover whether it is in a certain style or not. John Coltrane could have played on Buona Sera, but likely nobody would have called his contribution Rock n Roll.

Sam Butera on Kind Of Blue - probably not jazz.
 
Indeed it's hard to argue with that (probably more blues than jazz if you think about the jazz that had evolved by the time rock & roll was deemed to be a genre. Although plenty of people do think there was a fair amount of country involved in rockabilly of course as you mentioned. So it could be argued there were several fathers.
Well, if we say somewhere in the 1952-55 time period is when rock and roll started to be widely perceived as something unto itself, let's keep in mind that MOST "jazz" people were actually listening to in that time period was NOT Diz and Bird and Monk. MOST jazz people were listening to was Goodman, Basie, Ellington, and all the lesser bands like Les Brown, Elgart brothers, Dorseys (both singly and together depending on when their next scheduled fistfight was), etc. And for younger people the R&Bish performers like Louis Jordan would have been kind of in that "jazz" bucket sort of too. So while it's a far jump from Thelonious Monk or the Birth of the Cool to Little Richard or Elvis, it's not such a far jump from Louis Jordan or Basie's blues.

Again, we're busy chopping all these genres up and assigning very specific roles and performers to them, when that was not the way it actually was. A guy like Coltrane would walk the bar on Saturday night and then play the most austere challenging music on Sunday night. Ornette put in a lot of time in R&B bands. And so on.

And we haven't even touched on the influence of gospel music, which has a lot of similarities between black and white modes along with differences. You know, there's a couple recordings of the Million Dollar Quarter so called: Elvis, Carl Perkins, Johnny Cash, Jerry Lee Lewis, singing gospel songs with Elvis on piano (!!!) and they're beautifully done despite the obvious zero preparation or rehearsal and the crummy recording. These guys all had that whole style and genre right there in their heads accessible at a moment's notice because of who they were. That was a huge influence in their performance and for many of the Black performers of the time - Little Richard being maybe the best known.

A few final ones - how many people know that Doc Watson who's now an icon of country music was working in a rock and roll band when he was rediscovered? Earl Bostic who was a staple of early R&B was also a heavy influence on both Charlie Parker and John Coltrane for his outstanding technique including way up into the altissimo. Johnny Cash, Carl Perkins, Charley Pride, Marty Robbins, Conway Twitty were all people who ended up being filed by history in the "country" drawer but they all did a lot of rock and roll at one time. Show me how, for example, "Hey Porter" has to be country and "That's all Right" has to be rock. Never mind Elvis doing "Blue Moon of Kentucky" and then Bill Monroe changing HIS arrangement to include the fast 4/4 section a la Elvis.

I know this really doesn't have much of anything to do with writing note names over the words on a song, but it always chaps me when people start trying to chop up music into all these little categories and say "well, this is THIS so it can't be THAT."
 
Yes, but I’m not talking about just getting someone in to sing or play a certain part, moreover whether it is in a certain style or not. John Coltrane could have played on Buona Sera, but likely nobody would have called his contribution Rock n Roll.

Sam Butera on Kind Of Blue - probably not jazz.
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZWH-WiHVOE


Coltrane was employed by this singer a couple years before this recording was made. Do you really think he was unable to fulfill her requirements for a tenor sax player to walk the bar?
 
but it always chaps me when people start trying to chop up music into all these little categories and say "well, this is THIS so it can't be THAT."
Exactly - there is so much crossover between music styles as well as so much versatility in what people play. I hate getting labelled, which used to happen to me a lot as a session player once I'd got a little bit of recognition.
 
View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZWH-WiHVOE


Coltrane was employed by this singer a couple years before this recording was made. Do you really think he was unable to fulfill her requirements for a tenor sax player to walk the bar?
Of course he could! If I'm not mistaken Coltrane started out playing R & B didn't he? At least he was in Earl Bostic's band. A pity we don't have any recordings of those very early days- or do we?
 
Or this one. Is this blues, rock and rolll, or jazz? Roy Eldridge could have played that trumpet solo in 1938. Put Jerry Lee Lewis on the piano and you'd call it rock and roll. Give them all white faces, put cowboy hats on 'em and southern accents and put a steel player in there and it'd be Western Swing. Give the electric guitar player a long solo and you'd be calling it blues.

Seeeeeee????

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dcbHok0GhTQ
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,072
Messages
578,567
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom