Tech/maintenance Issue with D and Octave Key on Alto

John S

New Member
Messages
2
Location
Managua, Nicaragua
Hi everyone,
One of my students bought a very cheap alto. It works really well in most respects but for some reason when she plays the D on the staff I hear an A a 5th above. I have tried it myself and the same thing happens, though not always. There is no problem with the low D or with the Eb above the problem D, but there is a problem if I finger low C and hit the octave key (I also hear a G a 5th above). I notice that when I press the octave key and I have the G fingered, the octave key moves a little, I know it shouldn't. Maybe the problem is with the octave mechanism. Has anyone else experienced something like this?
Thanks in advance for your help.
 
On some saxophones the design of the octave mechanism allows the extension that opens the neck octave to move slightly when the thumb key is pressed. This is ok so long as there is some space between the extension and the ring on the neck---usually 1.5 - 2mm. Sometimes pressing the octave key extra hard will open the neck key slightly encouraging an overtone to sound. The way to test this is to finger G and hit the thumb key hard several times and see of the neck octave opens or jumps. Let us know if it does and I can talk you through the way to adjust for that.

As for the overtone or harmonic sounding instead of the fundamental, it can often be caused by an incorrect "voicing" inside the oral cavity. Its like when you whistle a low note then a high note. The tongue raises on the high pitch and goes back down on the lower pitch. Try singing "AHH" and playing the D with warm air keeping the same shape and tongue position inside the mouth.
 
^I'm sure that will help.

But also, any of these or a combination of them may be the solution:

- open the low C (sometimes even if you have other problems, this will do it). On many saxophones, the place most players will like the way the D voices and plays (both low and middle) will be with the low C open as much as the lugs or cage for it will allow, short of clanking. Sometimes, you want to alter the cage or guard to allow the C to open more than they will allow it to, without altering it, because the horn will not play as well as it's capable of playing without a gigantic low C venting.

- you may have octave leaks or leaks at pads that act like octave leaks for that note.

- you may have other problems with the octaves, for example the neck key may be hitting the body octave linkage, in which case the low D most likely voice poorly.

If you have someone nearby who understands venting, I would just take it to that person. The PRC factories do a very poor job of setting up venting, generally. They do a great job of seating pads, generally, but very poor venting. There are other things they consistently do poorly, but you can be sure if no reputable repairperson serviced it, and it came from China, you have some venting issues.
 
Thanks to everyone who wrote back with your helpful suggestions. We finally got a leaklight I had ordered last year, it turned out to be the F# pad not closing completely when the D key was pressed. I was able to fix it and it's working fine now.
Just for your information, the F# pad is the one just above the F, and should close completely when either the F or E keys are pressed. The D key can also close the F#, but it doesn't have to. Some techs like myself prefer to regulate the D to F# closing lightly for a variety of reasons. It does not affect the playing of the instrument unless the F# is played:

X X X | O O X like is is on the flute.
 
Techs will already likely have noted this.... Responding on it because others will hit this thread in the future, and if they are keeping what they take away from it that would not be for the best.

The low D does not need to close the F#, for any "normal" (meaning non-altissimo/alternate/multi-phonic, etc.) voicings. That's because any time low or middle D or anything lower is being played with a "normal" fingering, F is closing the F# pad. I can *help* if middle D is set-up to close F# perfectly without the other keys above them being closed, in terms of getting a stronger/firmer seal at F# -- especially given the amount of work F# is doing via connecting to the Bis and G# as well -- but when everything is right the only reason D would need to close the F# (again, for any "normal" fingering) is in the case where that is necessary for some kind of alternate fingering, where either F and/or E are not being pressed closed while D is, and where the need is for the D to close the F# completely. Important: there are cases where players may specifically want the D *not* to close the F# completely, or to even leave it rather open, for example for alternate voicings, altissimo tweaks, or multiphonic voicings.

E of course also needs to close the F#, the same way F does, because of the -2- F# right hand (middle finger only) fingering.

That's worth mentioning to save techs headaches due to misunderstandings with clients that the belief that the D has to close the F# may cause.

When I work on a new client's horn, if the D is not closing the F#, I'm not going to change it without asking them first if they prefer it not to close that key for some reason, or unless they specifically ask me to make it close the F#. It does not actually need to do that, and in some cases -- actually the more advanced the player is, the less likely I am to "correct" a leak there, withotu being asked, because if it's already like that they probably have found a way to use that leak in some way -- it makes more sense not to do it.
 
My deafult is not to set the D so that it closes the F# (or, as I prefer to call it, the auxiliary F).
What I do is set the D up so that when it's fully closed - and the aux.F is held down by the F key - there's around a few thou's gap between the regulation buffer on the foot of the D key and the regulation bar that runs along the rear of the main stack. Or, simply put, a piece of paper can slide freely between the buffer and the bar.

This is to take into account the flexibility inherent in the keywork - along with any wear and tear. Without this latitude you're almost certainly going to run into the issue of the D key being 'held off' by the regulation bar when closing all the keys on the lower stack.
Even with a perfectly tight action, key flex is going to have to be a consideration on almost all horns. Some older horns alleviate the issue with a different design of bar...and some don't even bother to extend the bar down to the low D - so it's clearly something that manufacturers have been aware of for quite some time.

If you solved a problem by making the D close the Aux.F then you haven't solved the problem (especially on a budget horn) - you've just disguised it, and quite likely introduced another. However, a 'gorilla grip' can overcome this - though finding the right solution would make for a better feel and response.
 
I found this discussion reassuring. I struggled to get the D adjustment on the adjustment bar right and decided to give up - and wind out that adjuster - when I realised I couldn't really see the use of it anyway (for me).
 
I worked in the repair shop of a busy music store for 7 years starting out as an apprentice. One of my main responsibilities during that entire time was to do "play conditions" on mostly alto saxophone rental returns played by elementary and junior high students and get them ready to go back to do battle in the "trenches". A recurring issue that I found was the D key getting pulled up bending the foot of the key upwards so the back bar from the F# prevented the D from closing rendering the notes below E unplayable. Regulating the D to not completely close the F# in some instances, provided enough "lost motion" to prevent this problem.
 
I don't know if I'm unusual in the fact that I use R3 to trill G F# and B Bb. I find it easier. I've started fingering F# Rh3 and fluttering 2 for a sort of wah wah effect. I like my R3 well regulated.

Why would the Rh regulation bar include R3 if it's not needed?
 
I don't know if I'm unusual in the fact that I use R3 to trill G F# and B Bb. I find it easier. I've started fingering F# Rh3 and fluttering 2 for a sort of wah wah effect. I like my R3 well regulated.

Why would the Rh regulation bar include R3 if it's not needed?

IMO, although (and I don't expect Steve to necessarily agree, but I doubt in practice our practices much disagree) D should not play a role in closing F#, BUT, if it *looks and feels* like the D is closing "perfectly" (quotes because it is apt to be an appearance, not a reality) in unison with E/F/F#/G#, there could be a contributing role that the linkage at D (where it is not missing by design) *could* play in getting full and complete seating, which could be an aid to the speech of notes lower down the horn, especially for example B, or C#. Your D should not *have* to do that -- i.e. if it does, something else is amiss -- but it is possible for it to sort of play an assisting role in a harmless way, or in a way that may help to "take up slack" any time it either exists or comes up (due, say, for example, to a change in humidity/environment, which changes how pads are seating either micro- or more macro-scopically).

It should not be needed to "program in" something like that on your D, but where/if one does, a D whose linkage setting with the F# is closer to exactly simultaneous could play an assisting role when/if the seating of F# from F or E is inexact (for whatever reason). If it does *need* to do that, as Steve suggests, something else is wrong, but where something else is wrong, and if there is no reason to leave D out of the F# equation, it would be harmless for D to help close F# (say with added finger pressure when playing finickier bell tones). I'm speaking practically, here, not in the abstract, when I say "it would be harmless." I think over time I have probably "programmed in" the D to close the F# on horns for kids and people that I think take poor care of their saxophone, without really thinking about it, or thinking about it and then forgetting about it. It is a conscious kind of decision that is then forgettable afterward.

On some horns B tends to be more picky about perfect seating, and on some others Bb. C# voicing issues will be venting related, more commonly than B or Bb (where it voices worse than B or Bb. And venting plays a role on B/C#, quite often. But even in these cases usually if you're having trouble playing bell or bow tones there is probably somewhere else on the horn (for example your mouthpiece or reed or tenon) where normal/corrective/always-a-plus attention would be a better place for applied attention, and where the effect on low note voicings would be greater.

"Fixing" a leaking F# from the D, as Steve suggests, is not "fixing" but missing the fix. That's not a criticism of anybody to say that, it's just a fact.
 
By the way, Steve: I wracked my brains to think of horns that don't connect at the D to the F#. I can see it in my mind, I'm operating the low D so I can adjust the foot and venting, and going, to myself, Oh, isn't this nice that there isn't a linkage here....

I literally just went through at catalog of horns that might be that, and couldn't think of one. The first candidates were:

- SA80 alto (I'm working on one now, it has a weird C# linkage, that made me run that back to myself). Not one.

- New King, Toneking, Superba I, SX-90R tenors. Not one among them.

- My own lines (Taiwan, PRC, not one among them)

I think Conn New Wonder (both Chu and earlier, and if so probably 10Ms, too) tenors may be an example -- I'll have to go and check in a second -- but those of course connect to the F# via the D to E linkage.

Wonder if you have other examples either off the top of your head or after some brain wracking.

I thought D&J might be one, but if Keilwerths aren't, then D&Js probably aren't either.

Definitely, as I visualize examples, I'm seeing a Conn Chu tenor keyfoot in my mind's eye.
 
I couldn't find any images in my collection either - but I have a feeling I've seen it more on vintage baritones, and the odd tenor. Will have to make a point of taking a piccy next time I come across it.

As for the rear bar - a very common example of a square section bar is that found on the Buescher 400.

shwwimg_buescher400_alto_keybar.webp
 
Still haven't been in the shop since last email, but will be shortly. Will try to remember to take a look at the Conns hanging around. I can't think of any others that don't have linkage bar connecting to the D. Very specifically, I see the particular shape of the key foot, and it's even silverplated in my mind's eye. I bet you visualize it (that specific keyfoot shape and the unique spacing back there on Conns) immediately as well, when you recall that topic.

A funny/ridiculous part for me is that I was connecting the visualized memory to Keilwerth stacks, because I just worked on a custom Conn where I replaced that key/stack with Keilwerth years ago -- despite that the visual memory is really specifically, clearly, of a Conn keyfoot (so specific that it's silverplated, which must mean it's a memory of the one I customized for myself even a longer time ago -- 20 years ago). That's why I was convinced initially to check every Keilwerth ever for that feature (or lack of a feature), i.e. I replace the stack that has that feature with Keilwerth stacks that don't have it, yet instead associate it with the Keilwerths. Humorous...strange...inexplicable (or maybe I just don't want to know what the explantion likely is). :doh:
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom