Playing the saxophone Instrumentals by ear

Now could be a good time to start 🙂
Why @Pete Thomas 🙂 ..I'm only six years into my playing...set your goals higher for me means you achieve more...

I do realise it appears that I am after a quick fix with regards to completing a few tunes: but it's really not the case..I need to get out and play the care homes so do need 10 songs but I realise improv and the ability to fill in the gaps is the next challenge on my pathway. I will continue with the practice.

A lot of the set list are easier tunes, True love ways, I don't know why I love you, Sweet Caroline, enjoy yourself and a few more.... I can play the main bodies its been good practice for key sigs, scales, transposition, stamina, etc...It also has brought me into contact with the benefits of understanding the circle of fiths..

I will never be able to make my living from music and have a job and commitments outside my sax life but I still play as much as I can, 3 hours Tues, Thurs, Fri, 5 hours Sat and Sunday, and an hour Mon and Weds...Theres a helluva lot to learn and thanks to the guys on here's patience I'm doing ok... just need help with three tunes to move on....

Ive never understood the importance of modes, arpeggio's and the complexities of improv as highlighted by @lydian who has really helped with his little quizes on intervals...until I saw this

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hXiUyP1vqiM


Again so much gratitude for the advice and website you have built...@Mizmar, @jazzdoh , @Dr G, @Veggie Dave @Jimmymack @thomsax @Ivan @turf3 are a few ( apologies I've missed many ) who have helped me along my way....

Again I am not trying to cheat my way through but playing by ear is a skill that could take decades to learn...I am in process but want to move onto playing in front of people and learning the new skills this entails: it seems futile to continue playin alone...( sooooo tempted).. If I had the music for the outros and instrumentals I have I would be able to get through but.....The relevance of the above video is that it shows me that learning the key isn't enough....flatten the fith or make some changes it becomes something different. For me this means that most notes can (could) be present in most tunes..There are so many variations it will take a lifetime of committment to learn....a challenge that i will rise to eventually I just can't yet...but I have to get out and play some open mics, care homes and these 3 tunes are blocking me which is why I need help..........
 
Why does it have to be just like the record? Who's going to complain if it's not? You'll not be flung into jail by the tune police.
Do the instrumentals and outro within your capabilities; the more you do it, the better you'll get. Makes sense to me, anyway. If I were you, I'd concentrate on enjoying what I can do, not beating myself up for what I can't.
 
Why does it have to be just like the record? Who's going to complain if it's not? You'll not be flung into jail by the tune police.
Do the instrumentals and outro within your capabilities; the more you do it, the better you'll get. Makes sense to me, anyway. If I were you, I'd concentrate on enjoying what I can do, not beating myself up for what I can't.
Hey @stitch I agree with you in general but I'd like it to sound as good as it can..I'll take it to my teacher too..
 
Eddie, on these 3 tunes your stuck with write down the chords to the parts of the tune you need to fill then write down the notes that are contained in the chords then with an app like iReal pro find these tunes and loop the backing track so that it only plays the chords that you need to fill and then noodle around with the notes that you have written down until you get something acceptable, also if you are doing this with a mate and he/she is a better player let them sort out the outro until you get better prepared.
As Stitch as said it doesn't have to be like the record.
 
Eddie, on these 3 tunes your stuck with write down the chords to the parts of the tune you need to fill then write down the notes that are contained in the chords then with an app like iReal pro find these tunes and loop the backing track so that it only plays the chords that you need to fill and then noodle around with the notes that you have written down until you get something acceptable, also if you are doing this with a mate and he/she is a better player let them sort out the outro until you get better prepared.
As Stitch as said it doesn't have to be like the record.
Trouble is I can't get those chords I have the notes from the key sig though, trouble is its a guitar I think I could leave the flute but would like to noodle over the other bits...
 
Trouble is I can't get those chords I have the notes from the key sig though, trouble is its a guitar I think I could leave the flute but would like to noodle over the other bits...
Load the songs into iReal pro, put in the key signature the app will show you the chords, make sure you put the transposing to your instrument ie Bb if its tenor and you will have the chords in front of you.
You can even set it so that it shows you what notes to play.
 
Last edited:
P

Load the songs into iReal pro, put in the key signature the app will show you the chords, make sure you put the transposing to your instrument ie Bb if its tenor and you will have the chords in front of you.
You can even set it so that it shows you what notes to play.
Will band in a box do the same...or can you get i real pro for windows on the phones to small for me..
 
Trouble is I can't get those chords I have the notes from the key sig though, trouble is its a guitar I think I could leave the flute but would like to noodle over the other bits...
You don't have to do the chord thing. I'm not even sure it's a good idea for those songs. All you need is the pentatonic scale. Play the tune with variation and a few pentatonic noodlings. Lots of stuff uses no more than that... Pluss the players musical sense, of course.
 
Well ... yes.
The guitarist is using the same notes s/he played throughout the song; you do the same on sax.
Thanks good thing is its given me a bit of structure..Last silly question..if you dont mind( sorry @lydian n) Key is A chords are mainly d ang which gives me six notes of the key..there is no F# in those 2 chords..
 
Thanks good thing is its given me a bit of structure..Last silly question..if you dont mind( sorry @lydian n) Key is A chords are mainly d ang which gives me six notes of the key..there is no F# in those 2 chords..
That's not how it works. You don't just make a big list of all the notes in all the chords in the whole tune. You play what fits each chord at the time. If it changes from G to D7, then you play notes that fit D7, not G. When it changes back to G, you play notes that fit G. You can do alterations, enclosures, tri-tone subs, leading tones, chromatic/diatonic approaches, etc. Anything goes, as long as it sounds good. Limiting yourself to the 3 notes in the chord is going to sound pretty boring.

Having said that, there is no possible way you are going to be able to approach this using theory. So you just have to follow your ears. I recommend sticking pretty close to the melody, and embellish/change in whatever ways sound good to you.
 
In a nutshell
TBF I asked a question a long time ago about playing chords on a sax because it made no sence..its all learning and i guess Jambalaya is the catalyst that takes me into improv..I know it wont come from theory but its still foundations. If i can find a process that works i.e. for me its a complex piece fast but only 3 chords so I have to slow it down..who knew theres an app..bingo. Its just time and finding patterns but it stops me playing. I thought someone who was good at playing by ear could do it for me for a price..on reflection I dont think that would give me a feel for it..Guess its time to start a new part of my journey..
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,618
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom