Tech/maintenance Indiana shined up moved from Bare brass temptation

@Hoosierken the differences in Martin models is best observed side by side. Here’s the first 2”.
View attachment 22549
View attachment 22548
You didn't list the models that I can see so I will guess. The second one back looks a lot like my Handcraft, The octave mech on the neck of the next one back looks like my Indiana. The farthest back also looks like a Handcraft to me. That's a pretty impressive group there. What I would really like to know is if The Martin from the mid 40s through the 50s plays better than an Indiana of the same years. You have a lot of Martins, what do you think?
 
You didn't list the models that I can see so I will guess. The second one back looks a lot like my Handcraft, The octave mech on the neck of the next one back looks like my Indiana. The farthest back also looks like a Handcraft to me. That's a pretty impressive group there. What I would really like to know is if The Martin from the mid 40s through the 50s plays better than an Indiana of the same years. You have a lot of Martins, what do you think?
1677718506291.webp

Left to right
28 goldplated HC, 38 Comm1, 62 Indiana, 27 HC, 31 Typewriter.
I also have a 31 troubadour just acquired.
1677719190176.webp

A 40 Comm II
1677720225187.webp

lastly a 25 C Melody HC.
1677720534254.webp

Each has its own unique sound and feel characteristics but really close. The Indiana is no shotty alto. It holds its own quite well. I just did a full overhaul on it. Actually I was quite surprised how close it plays to the two 20s Handcrafts.
 
View attachment 22550
Left to right
28 goldplated HC, 38 Comm1, 62 Indiana, 27 HC, 31 Typewriter.
I also have a 31 troubadour just acquired.
View attachment 22552
A 40 Comm II View attachment 22553
lastly a 25 C Melody HC.View attachment 22554
Each has its own unique sound and feel characteristics but really close. The Indiana is no shotty alto. It holds its own quite well. I just did a full overhaul on it. Actually I was quite surprised how close it plays to the two 20s Handcrafts.
I just love the engraving on the Committee II. I also love the engraving on the deluxe Indiana's. From what I understand those were done by hand. Could you imagine doing that day in and day out?
 
I bought the Deluxe from Shop Goodwill and they didn't wrap it so I had damage in shipping. I had to replace the octave mech and resolder a post. I thought that I had straightened this G key but while trying to get my key heights lower I broke it. I ordered another from Texas Horn Trader on Ebay. I put the G key from my other Indiana on and checked it with a tuner. I am a beginner but it put more notes naturally in tune for me having the G lower. I had even put a thick piece of cork on this and it did not lower it enough. I guess I should have replaced it with the octave mech.
20230301_213104.jpg
 
What advantages does The Martin have over a The Indiana.
We are drifting from bare brass .......

A Committee sax (Handcraft Committee, Handcraft Committee II, Martin Centennial and "The Martin ..... , Magna as well) is a more modern construction. And better built/QC as well. I think a fine set-up Committee sax has an even scale/intonation. Freeblowing? ... Is a sax freeblowing or is it the player that is freeblowing or a combo between player, sax, mouthpiece, reed .... . A Committee sax was designed to meet the new demand of what a sax should sound like. So was the SBA, MkVI, King Super 20, Buescher 400 ..... . The growing music industry wanted "louder" (more volume and a distinct voice) instruments. Indiana, Handcrafts, Committees are all fine instruments made by Martin, RMC, Wurlitzer are all fine instruments. And Martin kept the soft soldered on tone holes construction on all their saxes. How could they sell a student sax with such labour intensive construction. Indiana is one of best student saxes that ever been made. So hold on to your saxes.

Two videos to compare an Indiana" (1960) to a "The Martin Tenor" (Magna) (1959, not 1929). Same player, ..... 1300.00 or 3200.00 US.

View: https://youtu.be/xpZ3_LZblT4


View: https://youtu.be/c3OzVBW9X_g
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,610
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom