Playing the saxophone Improvising by Ear

I hope it’s OK for me to chip in hear. I am very much a Sax beginner ( been about 6 months now). But ever since I started playing my fave Jazz tunes , i have felt the need to improvise. It has also really helped me find my way around the instrument connecting my fingers to my brain and instinctively I am already creating some quite melodic lines harmonic lines. I am sure it is very basic but at least I am playing ‘what I feel’ and increasingly what I hear in my head goes straight to my fingers and out of the sax.
As I said, I am sure it is very probably very basic improvisation & I am also learning all of the music theory ,( different scales, arps etc) to both broaden my musical vocabulary & also to help me understand what I am doing myself by ear from a technical musical perspective.
When I hear my fave Jazz greats who realistically are so far ahead of me, and I hear lines that go off in an unexpected direction I am keen to know what musical ‘technical’ choices & knowledge of scales etc informed them to go down that road.
I am not a complete musical novice. I know a some of the musical theory but need to apply it to the Sax. I do play keyboard & have done in bands over the years , but my biggest and longest tool has been from a little boy my understanding of harmony. I have always specialised in harmonies, even called up in school to add harmonies to any song from my head & I’ve added layers of backing vocals on recordings & always been more interested in the harmony of any tune rather than the melody. So I think this is what drives me to improvise & search for interesting lines to play along the the track etc. So my practise consists of the formal musical theory stuff, technique etc and studying some etudes & usually finishes with playing just for pleasure tunes I wanna play with some free improvising by ear , and occasionally throwing in maybe some the musical vocabulary that I have learned i so far if I can to see where that takes me & then build on that by ear.

Sounds like you're on a good musical trajectory. It's good to listen to all of the possibilities others have examined, even better not to go down any rabbit holes in the process and just build your mental library while developing your head to hands "sync" so that you can play what you hear in your head. Too many get totally sidetracked into imitating (usually poorly) their favorite(s). Always keep yourself in the equation, even while studying others. The world likes originals and pays little attention to "tribute players".

Aiming at melodic rather than technical improvisation is also a good idea. By all means develop your chops, but don't make that the subject. You can go to a thousand open mike jazz jam sessions and see/hear one player after another trying desperately to impress with absolutely nothing to say but a bunch of cut and paste riffs and arpeggios. The job is entertainment, it's about giving emotions and stories, not boring technical displays.

Play what you love, yet be aware that the world doesn't care much about 70+ year old songs that everybody knew then, but nobody knows now (standards). The arts move on...except for the tribute players who seem happy to frequent those "jams" with little/no audience.

Follow your heart and head, and if playing for others is important, then keep in mind that it's about entertaining them.
 
If you have some dislike of 'golden oldies' what have proper words what people can sing-a-long-to then you could go really cutting edge avant-garde improvising to a DJ who performs what passes for music in clubs and on beaches.
Though from what I've seen on youtube this is usually done wearing a miniskirt, heels and plenty of lippy.
Not a good look for an old white man.
 
Improvising is nice if you can make a decent rhythm in your head play on the sax without any other instruments. Other then that you need to know scales at least o’chap
Thanks , yes I agree. I know the scales etc. of course. As I said, I’m not a complete novice, have played keyboards in bands for years (from rock & pop to reggae & ska) , a bit of harmonica & even studied a little jazz piano in my mid 20’s. And I am a song writer since my teens. 🙂
 
@Vin_Sax fascinating because many of us are recommended spending a little time on a keyboard to get to grips with harmony and theory, where it's easier than an intrinsically melodic instrument like the sax.
I'm nobodies expert in this, but when I started down that road I noticed that "Jazz Keyboard Harmony" by Phil DeGreg was often recommend... It's quite a lot for a novice but you, on the other hand, might find some useful stuff there.
 
Last edited:
@Vin_Sax fascinating because many of us are recommended spending a little time on a keyboard to get to grips with harmony and theory, where it's easier than an intrinsically melodic instrument like the sax.
I'm nobodies expert in this, but when I started down that road I noticed that "Jazz Keyboard Harmony" by Phil DeGreg was often recommend... It's quite a lot for a novice but you, on the other hand, might find some useful stuff there.
Thanks mate. I’ll check it out for sure
 
I don't think of the saxophone as a one note instrument. I like to think of strumming the saxophone.

When strumming a guitar the notes come out one at a time. Granted the notes follow each other very quickly and there's more resonance to carry the harmony, but I find it easier to think this way on saxophone.

Scales are fine but sometimes it comes out a little meandering.
Learning arpeggios/chords so that you can recognise them, understand how they connect with each other and having them under your fingers, can connect up a meandering noodle into something meaningful.

If you've got basic harmony sorted, extending the given harmony can make things interesting.

Not playing one note at a time will improve your improv no end.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,679
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom