Saxophones I hesitate between Saxello by R&C and buescher tipped bell soprano

Just stumbled over this thread from last summer. Thanks @Hankenstine for the reference to the tipped bell you so kindly flagged up.

I thought I’d address some of the assumptions since I have the tipped bell Buescher in question in the video.

An original TT tip bell is a collectors item. Probably not the best player!!! My LP-122 have modern pads with reflectors, the original Snap-On-Pads system removed, and is in my and the sellers opinion better (playability).

In actual fact it’s probably the best sounding (player) of my vintage sopranos. Is it better than the best player from a representative sample of regular TT sops? Probably not, but it’s a very fine horn up there with the best of them.

It’s got a big resonant, moderately focused sound on its original snap-in resos. I see no advantage in grinding out the spuds to use large modern boosters. The sound is so big as it is. Plus the original resos (also factory gold plated FYI) hold the middle of the pad slightly recessed compared to the part of the pad that seals on the tone hole, which is very nice. The idea that a TT is better off without them just isn’t right. A useful premise if selling a horn without snap on pads, but simply not born out in reality. (I’ve had TTs without the snap ins as well, since sold). I guess they get a bad rep when repairers slap modern pads with boosters over the spuds (or what’s left of them) and that ruins the action and feel of the horn.
 
Just stumbled over this thread from last summer. Thanks @Hankenstine for the reference to the tipped bell you so kindly flagged up.

I thought I’d address some of the assumptions since I have the tipped bell Buescher in question in the video.



In actual fact it’s probably the best sounding (player) of my vintage sopranos. Is it better than the best player from a representative sample of regular TT sops? Probably not, but it’s a very fine horn up there with the best of them.

It’s got a big resonant, moderately focused sound on its original snap-in resos. I see no advantage in grinding out the spuds to use large modern boosters. The sound is so big as it is. Plus the original resos (also factory gold plated FYI) hold the middle of the pad slightly recessed compared to the part of the pad that seals on the tone hole, which is very nice. The idea that a TT is better off without them just isn’t right. A useful premise if selling a horn without snap on pads, but simply not born out in reality. (I’ve had TTs without the snap ins as well, since sold). I guess they get a bad rep when repairers slap modern pads with boosters over the spuds (or what’s left of them) and that ruins the action and feel of the horn.
I bought buescher tipped bell, and now, i have one King saxello, one tipped bell by buescher and one perfect curved by couturier
 
Just stumbled over this thread from last summer. Thanks @Hankenstine for the reference to the tipped bell you so kindly flagged up.

I thought I’d address some of the assumptions since I have the tipped bell Buescher in question in the video.



In actual fact it’s probably the best sounding (player) of my vintage sopranos. Is it better than the best player from a representative sample of regular TT sops? Probably not, but it’s a very fine horn up there with the best of them.

It’s got a big resonant, moderately focused sound on its original snap-in resos. I see no advantage in grinding out the spuds to use large modern boosters. The sound is so big as it is. Plus the original resos (also factory gold plated FYI) hold the middle of the pad slightly recessed compared to the part of the pad that seals on the tone hole, which is very nice. The idea that a TT is better off without them just isn’t right. A useful premise if selling a horn without snap on pads, but simply not born out in reality. (I’ve had TTs without the snap ins as well, since sold). I guess they get a bad rep when repairers slap modern pads with boosters over the spuds (or what’s left of them) and that ruins the action and feel of the horn.
I've owned and played Buescher sopranos w or wo Buescher "Snap - On - Pad" system.

Buescher's "Snap-On- Pad" is snap in instead of glued in. So no glue, shellac ..... . I have seen "Snap-On -Pads" (with spuds and bottons ) that are glued in. Why? Maybe I got it all wrong but wasn't Buescher "Snap-On-Pad" a kind of self leveling system? A pad for Buescher Snap - On, use to have a stiff metal back and a big center hole. The Buescher Snap-On-Pads was working well as long as the "bottons" didn't fall out. Happened to me several times.

I bought my straight Buescher LP-122 (1928) with modern pads with nylon resonators/reflectors installed. N.B. not oversized resonators/reflectors. I think the key action is better? The height of a snap-on pad and a modern standard pad is the same; c 4,00 mm. Or maybe it can be that the sax tech in NJ did an overall good job on the soprano?
 
I think the Snap ons were trying to be a lot of things. Among the first resonators to come to market, to stop pads from becoming billowy, and ease of switching. I think the latter presupposed no shellac but pads were soft in those days so much more forgiving in seating.

To achieve the snappy feel we now expect we tend to use thin firm pads. I don't think self levelling was ever a claim per se. One needs far less shellac than if floating a pad in with the snap ons, but they work really well with a thin layer of shellac, and as I say, I really like the shape of the pad they give and extent to which the resonator is held recessed compared to the rest of the pad. If your snap ons were falling off I guess that some of the flanges on the underside of the snap on button may have been weakened through repeated removal and reinstall. They should snap on and hold very securely.

To be clear, I'm not suggesting that modern pads are a bad option at all. I have had 2 TT sopranos with that set up and they were fine. What I was rebutting was the suggestion that snap ons aren't as good. Property installed with modern pads (I buy quality pads and use a hole punch) they make for a really nice pad profile and a lovely feel.
 
I have a Kohlert modell 1927 soprano as well. A screw and a washer is holding the pad. Thick pads on this sax and no glue or shellac. I used a small amount of clear silicone "glue" (more a sealing) to prevent moisture/dirt to "crawl" down in the keycup. The pad is not fixed as it is with hot glue or shellack.

Back in the 1920's, 30's .... saxophone manufacture had diffent pad system. "Snap-On-Pad, Conn Res-O-Pads ...... even Martin jump on the pad train with "perfect pad". Martin made the best saxes when it came to even tone holes due to the Haynes method (soft soldered toneholes)!

If all the pads were good why didn't they continued making saxes with the great pads?
 
You seem to think I’m advocating snap ons in preference to modern pads. I’m not. I’m simply saying that the idea that modern pads are better than a good functioning snap on system, or that snaps ons play suboptimally, is wrong.

Why did Buescher discontinue making saxes with snap ons? They didn’t as I understand it. My understanding (could be wrong) is that their pad system ceased around the time they were picked up by Selmer.

I can certainly see how it’s way simpler and cheaper to use 3rd party standardised pads as a manufacturer or assembler, and also for repairers who might have their own pad brand preferences.

Is it a good idea to have proprietary pad arrangements? I wouldn’t think so. Back then they were innovating and also trying to differentiate. But is the snap on a bad system that compromises playability? No.
 
You seem to think I’m advocating snap ons in preference to modern pads. I’m not. I’m simply saying that the idea that modern pads are better than a good functioning snap on system, or that snaps ons play suboptimally, is wrong.
The C soprano had Snap-On-Pads and they were fine. On the other Buescher soprano the Snap-On's began to fall out and and what to do if you can't buy or find a missing Snap-On botton?
Why did Buescher discontinue making saxes with snap ons? They didn’t as I understand it. My understanding (could be wrong) is that their pad system ceased around the time they were picked up by Selmer.
To be frank, I don't know when Buescher company gave up the Snap-On-Pads. I know two players who are on Buescher 400 tenor and they have modern pads on thier horns. Maybe they had some problems with bottons that fall out?
I can certainly see how it’s way simpler and cheaper to use 3rd party standardised pads as a manufacturer or assembler, and also for repairers who might have their own pad brand preferences.
If your sax is a work tool for you and pays the bills I can't see why a player should spend more money on keeping the old system? If a tech can't find new bottons then the player have wait, and problably pay more compared to install a standard pad. There is a difference between a sax owner and a proffesional sax player.
Is it a good idea to have proprietary pad arrangements? I wouldn’t think so. Back then they were innovating and also trying to differentiate. But is the snap on a bad system that compromises playability? No.
Nothing wrong with the Snap-Ons if they are working correct. I have Ferree's Snap-On-Pads in my pad box. A guy ask me if I could help him with the pads on his Buescher alto. It was not the pad that was the problem it was the missing bottons.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,063
Messages
578,426
Members
8,129
Latest member
Bartman
Back
Top Bottom