Tech/maintenance How to fix sticky pads - stop them sticking

Solution
I use 1000 grit wet-or-dry sandpaper cut into a strip slightly wider than the tone hole. I wet the paper side with Naptha (lighter fluid) and pull it out from under the pad several times with light pressure with the paper side up. This cleans the surface of the pad and also the top of the tonehole. If this doesn't work, I remove the key, clean the pad again and rub a generous amount of fine teflon powder into the pores of the pad and brush/blow away the excess. If the pad sticks again after that process, it gets replaced.
My guess is that the "white areas" are where the leather dye or "pigment" as you call it has been rubbed off. This happens when pads are cleaned aggressively. It has no effect upon the pad's performance. In my experience naptha does not act as a solvent for waterproofing and render it sticky. This is why techs use it as a pad cleaner.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@jbtsax - so John, given the seat deepness, the state of the pads, the symptoms, how confident would you be that the Doctor's Pad Cleaner followed by the PTFE powder (this precise one: PTFE Powder 1/2 oz.) would cure the problem? I think it has to be worth a go, especially as I'm in the States soon and can get this particular powder posted to me there (Smiths have confirmed OK). No response from Doctor's but I'm sure it will be OK.

Did you have to try many cleaners and powders to find the right ones?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
@jbtsax - so John, given the seat deepness, the state of the pads, the symptoms, how confident would you be that the Doctor's Pad Cleaner followed by the PTFE powder (this precise one: PTFE Powder 1/2 oz.) would cure the problem? I think it has to be worth a go, especially as I'm in the States soon and can get this particular powder posted to me there (Smiths have confirmed OK). No response from Doctor's but I'm sure it will be OK.

Did you have to try many cleaners and powders to find the right ones?

I have used naptha, Dr's Pad Cleaner, and teflon powder for pads for a long, long time. Before that I tried Yamaha Powder paper and Charlie G's Gig Dust (no longer available). Both were at best a temporary fix. Cleaning the tops of the toneholes with 1000 grit wet or dry paper is also something I have used for a long time.

Teflon powder is used primarily by piano techs to reduce friction in felt hammers and other parts that rub against one another. It is all the same to the best of my knowledge. The piano tuner in the music store I used to work at turned me on to it years ago.

There is one more variable that may come into play and that is the "burrs" around the edges of the toneholes that have been leveled by filing. I have found some from the factory with burrs and some as a result of techs who don't know better. This is one more thing that can "grip" the surface of the pad---especially when there are seats.

Whether any of my techniques will work on your pads remains to be seen. You will have to try them to find out. 🙂
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I can strip it down completely if necessary, to clean the pads, but is there anything DIY that can be done to smooth the tone holes while I'm at it? I have 800, 1200 & 1500 emery paper but unless this is applied uniformly am I in danger of taking off more metal than I need from one side of a tone hole rim?

I can recall lapping cylinder head valves in to the head to seat them. I suppose ideally I'd have a soft circular backing to my paper so that the rim sinks into it whilst I turn it about a spindle centred on the tone hole. I reality I'd probably just use 1500 grade round around the rim between forefinger and thumb. No doubt the techs have a more engineered approach? Perhaps removing just the top stack and applying all these fixes will show if it's going to work, before stripping any more cups off? But what "safe" DIY method exists?
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I have a dremel, and a bit which looks like the one you're using for chamfering, but in the video (1:38) it's an "abrasive rubber piece on the end..."
Is it rubber, or a solid bit?

For which part of the job are you recommending the sanding sticks in the link?

Thanks for your input John. If you're in Fl in October I'll buy you a beer! :cheers:
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
I have a dremel, and a bit which looks like the one you're using for chamfering, but in the video (1:38) it's an "abrasive rubber piece on the end..."
Is it rubber, or a solid bit?

For which part of the job are you recommending the sanding sticks in the link?

Thanks for your input John. If you're in Fl in October I'll buy you a beer! :cheers:
It is a rubber bit that is a very fine abrasive. The sanding sticks are also a way to remove burrs on the edges of toneholes.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Back from the States. Bought some teflon powder back with me from Smiths, and ordered some Doctor's cleaner but the doctor was on holiday too so couldn't get it to me in time.

Anyhow, I'd dropped the Selmer (& Keilwerth) into Paul Carrington before my trip. He tried to convince me not to re-pad it at first as the pads looked so new, but after trying all kinds of remedies while I waited he couldn't stop the stickiness and said he'd replace the worst ones. "No, just do them all and be done with it!"

Collected it the other day and all seems well with the all new Pisoni pads. Time will tell, but there's no reason to think the sticky pads will return as I've never had this problem on any of my other (numerous) horns.

£260 all in, which seems a good deal, but the Selmer was otherwise in excellent nick so not too much other work I guess.

Keilwerth also had a general service, few pads replaced, bell was a little twisted out of true. Fettled and sorted for £68.

As usual with Paul, a wholly satisfactory experience and he always says if something's not quite right to bring it back. I haven't ever had to so far.
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
After watching the video about deburring the edge I remembered one about doing it with some scrunched up aluminium foil rolled into a small ball and rubbed round the edge, I wonder what the pro's think of that one, I gave it a try once and wasn't too sure about the results, I suppose it might depend how bad the burrs are to start with.
Hope your sax behaves itself now you've had it sorted and you can enjoy it fully, I'm assuming your joking about the £250 purchase,if not I don't know how you find them
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
my selmer pads often stuck too.. changed to roo pads now.. love them. cant say i have yet got full opinion as to whether they stick at all. give me a few more years with them .
hope you solve your problem I tend to agree with above that maybe its time for a strip down to clean the horn and pads properly and maybe if you need to just replace the worst pads if cleaning doesnt solve it.
ofcourse I good service and the tech will maybe let you know if your horn needs some tlc to free ticght mechanisms and/or adjust spring tensions to make things right. some times I have found springs far to hard becuase they need to work against sticking mechanism so you have to solve the basic problems and hopefully the spring can do its job properly and often you can lighten them a little too to make horn action smoother... .. job solved.!
good luck
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Yes £250 for a repad - thats really a fantastic deal - The pads would be at least £75. I couldn't do it for that.

The £250 I mentioned was in relation to what was quoted as his purchase price for the horn AMAZING!!! then it's £260 for a full repad, like you agree a real bargain.
A Selmer SA 80 in great condition for that kind of money must be the bargain of the year
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Campho-phenique is the best solution to sticky pads that do not respond to cleaning with lighter fluid (a la Stephen Howard). I must credit my friend Jim, saxophonist in Wichita Falls, KS, USA, for sharing this useful tip a few years ago.

Look for Campho-Phenique Pain Relieving Antiseptic Liquid - not the ointment or gel formulation, and use a cotton bud to spread thinly on the sticky pads' surface contacting the tone holes. And it can also come handy for its original use, as treatment for cold sores, skin burns, etc..:confused:
 
Vote:
Upvote 0
Campho-phenique is the best solution to sticky pads that do not respond to cleaning with lighter fluid (a la Stephen Howard). I must credit my friend Jim, saxophonist in Wichita Falls, KS, USA, for sharing this useful tip a few years ago.

Pop off-topic geography lesson. Wichita Falls is in Texas, Wichita is the one in Kansas. The latter is the home of Wichita Band Instrument Co., which has one of the best repair/restoration outfits in the States.

Also, back on topic, a strip of the synthetic leather marketed as "Ultra Seude," drawn beneath a closed pad, does a great job of both drying pads and cleaning up sticky pads. This tip is from the repair technician for the US Army Field Band (on YouTube).
 
Last edited:
Vote:
Upvote 0

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,650
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom