Playing the saxophone How much does your performance quality vary

Pete Thomas

Admin
Cafe Moderator
Messages
23,617
Location
London
Level
Retired professional
By this I mean does your perceived quality vary, ie what you think about your playing either while actually playing or when reviewing afterwards e.g from a recording?

Something I noticed when I used to do more playing and have a go almost every day at recording something, maybe even something very simple like a sort of blues or modal ballady thing that requires very little in the way of brain or ears to negotiate round difficult changes.

First take often seems good but patchy.

Next few takes over several days I often found more and more patchy. I was thinking I could cobble something together from all the takes, but that is rather annoying, if Iwanted to nail this nicely.

But then after days/weeks bingo! something happens four choruses popped out as nicely as anything thank you very much.

Now the interesting thing for me is why? Obviously if your livelihood is depending on this, you need to be able to tap into that quality you know you are capable of whenever you need to.

I'm sure some people do this spiritually, or with knowledge of self psychology, or possible mind altering substances (let's not go there for the sake of this discussion unless it's legal) or could it just be that I play better on Thursdays?

For live work this is crucial I suppose, you have to be able to give your best at all times, but when recording you sometimes have the luxury of attempting over and over to reach for perfection.

Obviously warming up and practising can be important, but I find that sometimes that doesn't actually help.

I just wondered if people have come up with methods to help with this.
 
Last edited:
This is interesting to me as I have been venturing out to jams in the past couple of months; I haven’t played in public for several years. What we work on in the practice room, the little intricate details of how to get around the changes, these are not the things I notice when I’m playing for other people.

Where I fail is in the intention behind the music, not the actual notes. Or rather, I do struggle to play the notes I am aiming for, but that doesn’t really matter. What matters most is whether I play with substantive statements; the actual notes don’t matter nearly as much as whether I can play them with authority. Of course, the actual notes do matter too, but they are of lesser importance than how you play them.

The old song goes “It ain’t what-cha do, it’s the way how-cha do it”. Problem is I don’t really know how to practice this. Other than just getting out there and sitting in with someone and stepping on my own nether parts again…

I think the answer is time. You work on something, a new lick or tune, and the first few days it doesn’t click, then suddenly it does. I think if you pay attention to something intensely, even for a short while, your subconcious brain gets a message that this is important, and sorts it out while you sleep or have dinner or something. This process takes a few days. Then suddenly things start to work.
 
It depends very much on what I’m trying to do. If it’s the standard sort of stuff - blues, jazz, rock, etc. - then I don’t think it varies much at all. Lately, though, I’ve been doing a lot of free improvisation and I think there’s rather more variation in quality. It’s only my impression. No one else has commented.
 
I can relate to all of the above. For me it's usually recording the first take that either makes it, or it's a struggle to have a better take after that. Fortunately I have thousands of original templates to play with in all genres, so can just go to the next and maybe at some future date try that same one. I'm playing improvisations 100% of the time, so getting the feel, hearing changes and melodic possibilities without technical analysis is what works for me. There is no practice other than hearing the music and having the attitude of wishing to be "inside" it. If the goal was to dominate it as a soloist or demonstrate technical prowess (that I don't possess) it would take a lot more work.

From my perspective there is little/no ego as I'm always coming to the music as an adjunct rather than the main act. The concentration is on making what's already there enhanced, being inside. If I'm physically OK and clear headed, there is no concentration as whatever I hear that may fit comes out of the horn. It flows through rather than having any impediments. If the ego pops up it usually stops/dies. Trying to play beyond my ability or "show off" kills the flow.

If players are not in sync with their instrument to where the music they hear flows through, then they need to keep playing to the point where it happens for them. IMHO if the player is forever concentrating on the dots and trying to analyze and translate or just plug in well practiced riffs and arpeggios, it will take a lot longer to get there. Hearing and reacting without analysis or "translation" gives the opportunity to be playing with your own distinctive voice.

The goal for me is easy to define, however it doesn't always materialize. Playing known tunes comes easy, but doesn't appeal as the melody already exists and the goal (for sax players) seems mostly about demonstrating technical ability. That doesn't appeal to me or the vast majority of potential listeners.
 
I haven't yet recorded myself nor played to an audience so can't really comment so I hope nobody minds a beginner's perspective.

I wonder if periodic rests from playing/practicing and concentrating on something else can actually benefit progress? Allows time for it all to sink in as it were, for the brain to sort it out at a subconscious level without additional input.

I remember when I practiced jujutsu the process was similar, learn a pattern in chunks slowly, don't try and learn it all at once, and take a break from it and do other patterns for a while. Come back to it and find some how it has improved.
 
Good music is full of small suprises and suprises are very difficult to catch in theory. Try to keep the suprises small as music is the goal. Concentrate on listening and think as litlle as possible. Do not judge directly as it requires thinking.
 
I haven't yet recorded myself nor played to an audience so can't really comment so I hope nobody minds a beginner's perspective.

I wonder if periodic rests from playing/practicing and concentrating on something else can actually benefit progress? Allows time for it all to sink in as it were, for the brain to sort it out at a subconscious level without additional input.

I remember when I practiced jujutsu the process was similar, learn a pattern in chunks slowly, don't try and learn it all at once, and take a break from it and do other patterns for a while. Come back to it and find some how it has improved.
That's an interesting point, I've also found sometimes if you walk away from something for a bit, even if it's a couple of weeks or more, whatever, you can oddly, find definite improvement, maybe it's all psychological but it's certainly a noticeable 'thing'
 
If I get recorded I always tend to make a cock-up somewhere, despite being able to play the thing fine in 'real life' 😡
Years ago, 1st black belt test. Practice run I rocked! Knew my partner, I didn't think about it, it just flowed. Formal test with a new partner in front of Sensei, the Grandmaster and all the honchos an hour later and I sucked, was tense, made mistakes and performed badly. I passed but it was poor showing of what I could do. Stage fright, judgment phobia, ego?
 
Good music is full of small suprises and suprises are very difficult to catch in theory. Try to keep the suprises small as music is the goal. Concentrate on listening and think as litlle as possible. Do not judge directly as it requires thinking.
I disagree. Your musical “antenna “ should be on 100%. This requires thought, concentration.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,060
Messages
578,354
Members
8,128
Latest member
Roger Atlas
Back
Top Bottom