Playing the saxophone How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of key

Dear all,

I did a quick post on Slonimsky's pattern 626 "Incorporating the Sound of Nicolas Slonimsky’s Pattern no. 626 in Jazz Improvisation" and thought it might be helpful to some of you to bring some dissonances into improvisations.

Peace & Respect,

JK

Hey man I just looked through it - absolutely love this stuff! Great how you can play the examples also to hear how they actually sound. It's like you have a juxtaposition two patterns (modulating minor triad pattern with whole tone) but also have a vertical composite (chords) as well - guess that opens up a whole load of possibilities with other scales and patterns too...🙂
 
Vertical thinking might also help some of us to move in/out of the supporting harmonic syntax. Some of equal-divisions of two-octave thingy in Slonimsky's book are also very fun to try. Was a bit rush toward the end of the post as my pals were dragging me to movie theater...(hence no sound clips at the end), sorry about that.
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

...I was thinking about sequence in Baroque music (maybe it's time for some Glenn Gould?;})

But he was 20th century 🙂))

Seriously, I don't think anyone's done a better Goldberg Variations... Pity he and Bernstein didn't get on, probably led to GG's demise.
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Glenn Gould's first recording of Goldberg Variations has been my lullaby for sleepless nights for years🙂
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Looks interesting, will take a proper look later, thanks!

I think that should be 'motifs', not 'motives'. I don't normally comment on typos, but this one is misleading.
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Kev,

Many thx for pointing that out! Now, I am bear-hugging other related terms such as "figure" or "pattern" to avoid the issue you kindly mentioned. Working on my little thesis few years back though, I did have a fun meeting with my advisers just to discuss "motive" vs "motif" preference (since the term would eventually be used frequently in the thesis...and it's easier to pick one term and stick with it like a cute Koalo bear hugging a Eucalyptus tree🙂. Browsing through various papers from Annual Reviews of Jazz Studies, related diss., and books...it seemed that both terms have been used frequently in U.S. music literature. We ended up choosing "motive" mainly because that Charlie Parker scholar Thomas Owens used "motive" in his dissertation (since I was adapting Owens' motive categorization). But, apparently, the use of "motive" in music is less accepted internationally than we thought.:crying: I did receive several emails commenting on the issue.

Kind regards,

JK
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

To contribute to this discussion, I have put some ideas & examples in this post, such as using synthetic scales, superimposition, sliding in/out with pentatonic scale...etc. They are more like generalized ramblings though. But, hopefully, it will generate more ideas and thoughts from forum members.

Peace,

JK
[Apologies - I seem to have got my wires crossed - I'll check more carefully in future before posting!]
Interesting. Personally, I see dissonance as something which adds colour or tension, which has to be released (the whole reason behind suspensions for example). It can be overdone, since if it's the 'norm' there is no consonance to contrast with! Probably why I'm not a fan of serialism etc... However, it certainly has its place - it's working out what you like.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Hi,Tobes read your post,fraid completely out my depth,you and JK Chang lost me,but admire your knowledge,me i just want to blow and hope folk know what i am playing!!?? I am going too stick to my play along books!Regards Dave.
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Kev,

Many thx for pointing that out! Now, I am bear-hugging other related terms such as "figure" or "pattern" to avoid the issue you kindly mentioned. Working on my little thesis few years back though, I did have a fun meeting with my advisers just to discuss "motive" vs "motif" preference (since the term would eventually be used frequently in the thesis...and it's easier to pick one term and stick with it like a cute Koalo bear hugging a Eucalyptus tree🙂. Browsing through various papers from Annual Reviews of Jazz Studies, related diss., and books...it seemed that both terms have been used frequently in U.S. music literature. We ended up choosing "motive" mainly because that Charlie Parker scholar Thomas Owens used "motive" in his dissertation (since I was adapting Owens' motive categorization). But, apparently, the use of "motive" in music is less accepted internationally than we thought.:crying: I did receive several emails commenting on the issue.

Kind regards,

JK

Motive - reason for doing something, driving force, causing movement
Motif - pattern/picture often recurs (especially in music)

Often mispelt & confused, sadly

But not to worry.
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Hi,Tobes read your post,fraid completely out my depth,you and JK Chang lost me,but admire your knowledge,me i just want to blow and hope folk know what i am playing!!?? I am going too stick to my play along books!Regards Dave.
Great to be able to knock out a great solo without reverting to tricks all the time! For me the theory helps me break away into new avenues and sound scapes that I probably wouldn't discover so easliy all by myself 🙂
 
Re: How do I create more dissonance in sax improvisations - e.g. playing in + out of

Kev or is it kV,
Living in Germany, shouldn't you use "leitmotif" or is that too restrictive?

We don't want to confuse things.... especially when my favourite online English/German dictionary gives:
"leitmotif also leitmotiv [mus][art]..." for the German "das Leitmotiv".

standardised spellings would stop a lot of this nonsense... But can you conceive of any significant acceptance in the UK, let alone the U.S. for any standardisation in the language?
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,075
Messages
578,650
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom