Miscellaneous How about a rubato thread?

6441

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,846
Or is there one already. Next to BOTM/SOTM, "Tunes without Time": played rubato. You think BOTM is scary...

EDIT: I just realized I could start this and anyone who likes can add to it.

Here:

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I had to look that word up. Is it a complete abandonment of the metronome and the time signature? Is it something you just do when you noodle or improvise or do you play around with set pieces of music to bend them and shape them the way you want to? Is there no structure or pattern at all?
 
No i't not a complete abandonment of time. It's speeding up and slowing down for expressive purposes. It's Italian for "stolen" or "robbed". If you slow down, for example, you steal time from the next passage which therefore needs to be a bit faster to make up the difference.

The pianist Errol Garner was a master of playing strict tempo with his left hand and rubato with his right.

If the intention is to completely ignore time it will be marked "tempo ad libutum" rather than "rubato",
 
Thanks, @Dibbs, you beat me to the punch!
There is form. You play a song, but rubato, which for me means varying the time or beat.
The definition at Miriam Webster is not what I learned in relation to modern music. I do not agree with "against a rhythmically steady accompaniment". Rubato intros are common in jazz, with pianists like Bill Evans, but also very typical of Sonny Rollins.

Rubato | Definition of Rubato by Merriam-Webster.jpg


Here's a great accompanied rubato intro in Coltrane's Crescent. In my "education", this is rubato.

View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eOwW9j0YzgM
 
Further, I think there are some rubato versions of Danny Boy in the BOTM?

 
Beautiful, I never thought of it that way, but it just shows that music is music and you don't always think about what it is!
 
A discussion of "rubato" would not be complete without a reference to music played by larger ensembles. As a teacher and conductor I spent many years studying and interpreting pieces to teach rubato playing to my band students. One of the finest compositions written within the abilities of younger players is this work by James Ployhar entitled Balladair. Below is a recording by the famed Tokyo Wind Orchestra. Listen to how the rubato interpretation brings out the expressiveness of this beautiful composition.


 
If you want to hear how loose with time one of the greats was, get a copy of the Charlie Parker Omnibook, listen to a slowed down recording of Parker's Mood and KC Blues while reading the notation. Other tunes are likely the same but these two I had to learn note for note for school performance so I had to really study them.

He came back on time at meaningful points but look at the difficulty the transcriber had in notating. He never loses the groove and its not as noticeable at speed, but listening to what he is playing over the rhythm section. at 50% ...well......enjoy.
 
A lot of classical pieces are played rubato, the time follows the expression by the composer. I do not consider playing ahead and behind the time, which I work on daily, as rubato. My notion of rubato for the purpose of starting a post with rubato from members was withor without accompaniment, playing that would NOT stay in time with a metronome.

PS: It's been really, really hot here, and the rain gods have decided to try to make it cool off. Sitting here at the computer, I just realized that as I practice, if the power goes off, the sax will not!
 
Let's not worry about defining it, I could be mistaken, band leaders over the years have meant it to mean like the intro to Spiritual or Crescent. Those are directed by movement of the leader.

Here's a song I recorded in 1993 in California. The 46-second intro is played rubato with my guitar directing with big swoops of the neck! The drummer then brings the tempo. This was a rough mix, never really finished.

View: https://soundcloud.com/randulo2/engouement-infatuation



However, who cares: Post your stuff in the rubato room.If it can't be played with a metronome beat, it qualifies.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom