Playing the saxophone Hit The Road Jack

I think the music theory needed for BiaB is beyond you at the moment.
Buy a theory book. Start at page one. Or...

the piano thing.

Meanwhile.

Eminor is the relative minor of Gmajor. They use the same key signature because they share the same notes. Em runs from E to E. G runs from G to G.
Using these same notes the interval from 1 to 3 is smaller in Em than it is in G. It's minor.
All major keys have a relative minor. Same notes. Different starting point.
There is much more to minor keys but that'll do for now.
It's very easy to see and hear on a keyboard. So...

go do the piano thing...
 
I followed your link to the K.V. and saw this:

So why not just try different keys until you get what you want. Use your ears and your horn a little bit until the key you choose matches what you play off your score. As we've suggested many times, if it's written too high or too low, just play it down or up an octave. Better yet, switch to iReal or BIAB so you can change the key at will and not be stuck with an MP3 that can't be changed. You could even learn the tune in multiple keys which is a great exercise for your musical development.

There's no publisher on earth who would change this tune (or any minor tune for that matter) to a major key. So you don't have to worry about that.

As always, a little theory or piano, which you continue to resist with all your might, would make your process of finding and learning tunes SOOOOO much easier. In fact, all of the tunes I've ever seen you post about are very simple melodies which would be very easy to pick out by ear and either memorize or write down yourself. So there's really no need to buy charts for most of this stuff. Try this, pick any random note on your horn, and play "Happy Birthday" by ear. Now pick another random note and play it from there. Repeat until you've tried all 12 notes of the chromatic scale. This is how you build your ears and stop relying on charts for simple tunes.
Thanks @lydian I started the thread re BIAB so mght go that way.. I agree as usual with what you say re playing by ear but i am not quite there yet. Im not resisting the piano but would like some agenda otherwise it will be the same as the sax lessons..30 down and nothing valuable learnt.. I thought playing from scores would give me some structure theory wise...
 
You're mixing up written music with music theory. You'll get no theory from playing dots.
Not trying to sound defensive and hear what you say about listening. I do feel tho at times my content is misconstrued Its probably the way I phrase things. What i meant was as scores are based on theory problems that arise lead back to theory.
 
I followed your link to the K.V. and saw this:

So why not just try different keys until you get what you want. Use your ears and your horn a little bit until the key you choose matches what you play off your score. As we've suggested many times, if it's written too high or too low, just play it down or up an octave. Better yet, switch to iReal or BIAB so you can change the key at will and not be stuck with an MP3 that can't be changed. You could even learn the tune in multiple keys which is a great exercise for your musical development.

There's no publisher on earth who would change this tune (or any minor tune for that matter) to a major key. So you don't have to worry about that.

As always, a little theory or piano, which you continue to resist with all your might, would make your process of finding and learning tunes SOOOOO much easier. In fact, all of the tunes I've ever seen you post about are very simple melodies which would be very easy to pick out by ear and either memorize or write down yourself. So there's really no need to buy charts for most of this stuff. Try this, pick any random note on your horn, and play "Happy Birthday" by ear. Now pick another random note and play it from there. Repeat until you've tried all 12 notes of the chromatic scale. This is how you build your ears and stop relying on charts for simple tunes.
The problem is with the definition of simple, what is simple for someone with your experience in music isn't simple for me...I would find installing gas boiler simple and whilst it looks so the theoretical laws underpinnining it are complex unless known. The key sig is the main issue the song has been bastardised as in Ab with 7bs it must be quite difficult to play. As @thomsax said I can transpose it up to Bbm but would then have to play an octave higher. For me playing in the same register would be quite hard as it starts all low Eb, Db, Bb Bb then the next bar starts with a low Bb all played at 82 minims BPM which I assume is 164 crotchets...



There is no easy transposition so I would have to do it of the chart and I didn't want to commit all that time if the finished song an octave higher wouldn't sound right against the K.V in the key of Ab.. I am definately going to try the happy birthday tip tho so thanks for that....Eddie
 
here is a resource I found that may be useful to someone in my position reading this thread


it could go on the list
 
I also do not understand how playing scores can help with music theory.
Hi, I will use the gas boiler analogy again putting a boiler on the wall and piping up is easy...The rules and laws that underpin it are quite complex, gas rating, pipe sizing, electrics, co2 co ratios, etc...if music theory underpins scores key sigs, major or minor scale, used notes re key sigs, accidentals that break theory..You can do anything in life without knowing theory driving without the highway code is possible, but unsafe, fit a boiler, possible but unsafe, electrics possible but unsafe...theory in my mind drives safe (not in the case of music) practice, scores are the tool that enable you to practice and theory drives the writting of scores..Without theory how would you differentiate between a bass cleff and treble cleff ( not relevant to sax), transpose, move up an octave, understand notation, accidentals...playing from a score brings you into contact with these things which then have to be related to theory....
 
I cannot find that thread, please link so I can merge this one which has now gone off the rails
sorry which thread @Pete Thomas ....it's kind of all relevant to hit the road jack...these are just issues that the darn thing has bought up....
I cannot find that thread, please link so I can merge this one which has now gone off the rails
sorry just sussed out BIAB vs I pro real player...don't think it was started...going to transpose Hit the Road Jack into Bb and use K.V. so this thread has ended anyway, I think....
 
Hi, I will use the gas boiler analogy again putting a boiler on the wall and piping up is easy...The rules and laws that underpin it are quite complex, gas rating, pipe sizing, electrics, co2 co ratios, etc...if music theory underpins scores key sigs, major or minor scale, used notes re key sigs, accidentals that break theory..You can do anything in life without knowing theory driving without the highway code is possible, but unsafe, fit a boiler, possible but unsafe, electrics possible but unsafe...theory in my mind drives safe (not in the case of music) practice, scores are the tool that enable you to practice and theory drives the writting of scores..Without theory how would you differentiate between a bass cleff and treble cleff ( not relevant to sax), transpose, move up an octave, understand notation, accidentals...playing from a score brings you into contact with these things which then have to be related to theory....
I shall leave it there @Pete Thomas, otherwise the thread will go off the rails. In laymans terms I think you can play scores, but you have to have a basic understanding of theory to do so...
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,705
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom