Playing the saxophone Hit The Road Jack

Where is this backing track that purports to be Hit The Road Jack in a major key?


It might to some people. Blues can often consist of minor melody over major harmony, kind of intentional dissonance (or what some people might think is dissonant but can work because if the genre)

Not sure what you mean. Do you mean how to tell the difference between G major and E minor?

From the melody and harmony.
TBF @Pete Thomas not sure its major or minor LoL but it's here


"Not sure what you mean. Do you mean how to tell the difference between G major and E minor?

From the melody and harmony".

Do you mean just by listening to it...??? is it crazy that one key sig can be either major or minor..thought that the key sig would define the key...am I deviating...
 
If it's the Ray Charles. version then it's minor. As mentioned the original song is written and performed in a minor key.
is it crazy that one key sig can be either major or minor..thought that the key sig would define the key
A key signature tells you nothing about whether a tune is major or minor. All it tells you is the default sharps and/or flats.

But please start a new thread on this, and not take other ones off topic, thanks

But ideally you need to get some very very basic theory lessons.
 
is it crazy that one key sig can be either major or minor..thought that the key sig would define the key...am I deviating...
Several people explain the Major/Minor and key signature issues, nicely, in this thread:

 
If it's the Ray Charles. version then it's minor. As mentioned the original song is written and performed in a minor key.

A key signature tells you nothing about whether a tune is major or minor. All it tells you is the default sharps and/or flats.

But please start a new thread on this, and not take other ones off topic, thanks

But ideally you need to get some very very basic theory lessons.
understood re the thread...its just sometimes easier in the context of the thread conversation, I dont mean to take it off topic...my initial post was sort of regarding the key sig which indicates e minor or G major. I guess that's what I meant by the key sig telling you whether its major or minor...it's just that I have found the other songs I have done more definitive i.e. it has 4 sharps so it is e major guess i haven't as yet associated the fact that it could also be c#major...I won't start another thread but will get into your book on chords....
 
This piece seems to originally have been in Ab minor. Understandably to avoid the 7 flats of the key signature, it is often transposed to A minor to simplify it. I have also seen in in G minor and F# minor. I suspect those depend on what instruments or voice you are transposing for.
 
Several people explain the Major/Minor and key signature issues, nicely, in this thread:

yep thanks for that @mizmar.... 😉 don't know how this one got back here..I think it's more prevelent in this song as most of my other efforts haven't bought me in contact with minor scales..theyre more upbeat..if I had the song and the score in the same key it would have been simple..Found a few good websitesso got some direction on reading now..
 
You seem to think you need lessons to have lessons. How would anyone ever learn anything? It's so easy to explain everything musical on a piano.
but what would I ask?? I'm only just starting to think I'd get something out of sax lessons ..I'd end up having so many lessons on piano I'd be able to play it..LoL..at least now I'm aware of a difference in patterns between major and minor scales, can read a bit, understand the importance of chords... i'd have some understanding of what i was being taught... definately a valuable piece of info tho..
 
.I won't start another thread but will get into your book on chords....
No, I think my book assumes very basic elementary knowledge. First you need a teacher who can teach you the very basics of music theory, or a book eg grade 1 music theory or a course. But I believe this has been said before…
 
This piece seems to originally have been in Ab minor. Understandably to avoid the 7 flats of the key signature, it is often transposed to A minor to simplify it. I have also seen in in G minor and F# minor. I suspect those depend on what instruments or voice you are transposing for.
Hi thanks, thats the key that K.V has it in...trouble is it goes down to low for a saxophone so e minor was the next best thing...trouble is finding a good backing track I can only find G major...Hense the BIAB thread..
 
Last edited:
No, I think my book assumes very basic elementary knowledge. First you need a teacher who can teach you the very basics of music theory, or a book eg grade 1 music theory or a course. But I believe this has been said before…
and acted on @Pete Thomas I am reading, playing to dot's and trying to move on.. I would just like to put this song and a backing track to bed..Happy with the score I have in e minor hence trying to find out whether BIAB would resolve the issue of a complementary backing track, or whether the K.V version of it in G major would suffice..suppose the thread should close before it wanders, but again thanks all I have some direction for my reading and a context to fit it to...
 
Last edited:
Happy with the score I have in eb minor hence trying to find out whether BIAB would resolve the issue of a complementary backing track, or whether the K.V version of it in G major would suffice..
Please read what was written. It isn’t G major!
 
Please read what was written. It isn’t G major!
LoL I know its e minor...but initially asked as all the notes are the same whether it would sound ok as K.V only have it in majors (I think) or the key of G...I'll play it tomorrow and find out...the issue with it in ab minor is that it goes of the scale of the sax...can play it an octave higher...
 
Last edited:
LoL I know its e minor...but initially asked as all the notes are the same whether it would sound ok as K.V only have it in majors (I think) or the key of G...I'll play it tomorrow and find out...the issue with it in ab minor is that it goes of the scale of the sax...can play it an octave higher...
So apparently there are only happy songs on Karaoke since they only do major keys. How can you tell from looking at just the key signature whether it's major or minor? Inquiring minds want to know.
 
So apparently there are only happy songs on Karaoke since they only do major keys. How can you tell from looking at just the key signature whether it's major or minor? Inquiring minds want to know.
Lol no they do minor songs but can't get this one in the key i want..guess the only way by looking is the chords do they form g or e minor. As you know im not that advanced. Otherwise its by sound i guess..its just a pain trying to match the backing track to a score. The original is in Ab minor lots bs. It also is quite a hard play all bottom end. I think there are also a couple of low As..
 
Lol no they do minor songs but can't get this one in the key i want..guess the only way by looking is the chords do they form g or e minor. As you know im not that advanced. Otherwise its by sound i guess..its just a pain trying to match the backing track to a score. The original is in Ab minor lots bs. It also is quite a hard play all bottom end. I think there are also a couple of low As..
I followed your link to the K.V. and saw this:

So why not just try different keys until you get what you want. Use your ears and your horn a little bit until the key you choose matches what you play off your score. As we've suggested many times, if it's written too high or too low, just play it down or up an octave. Better yet, switch to iReal or BIAB so you can change the key at will and not be stuck with an MP3 that can't be changed. You could even learn the tune in multiple keys which is a great exercise for your musical development.

There's no publisher on earth who would change this tune (or any minor tune for that matter) to a major key. So you don't have to worry about that.

As always, a little theory or piano, which you continue to resist with all your might, would make your process of finding and learning tunes SOOOOO much easier. In fact, all of the tunes I've ever seen you post about are very simple melodies which would be very easy to pick out by ear and either memorize or write down yourself. So there's really no need to buy charts for most of this stuff. Try this, pick any random note on your horn, and play "Happy Birthday" by ear. Now pick another random note and play it from there. Repeat until you've tried all 12 notes of the chromatic scale. This is how you build your ears and stop relying on charts for simple tunes.
 

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,079
Messages
578,702
Members
8,136
Latest member
peterdehelegrote
Back
Top Bottom