Playing the saxophone Help with Transcribing Arrangements for Big Band

rhysonsax

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,417
Location
Surrey, UK
Over the last few years I have built up skills in transcribing improvised solos - usually for saxophone, but also bits and pieces for voice, flute, bass, piano, trumpet etc.

I have also tried a few times to transcribe all the instrument parts into Sibelius 7 for some big band arrangements that I really like. In each case I have managed to work out the key signature(s), structure, tempo and then the lead parts (trumpet 1, trombone 1, alto 1) and mostly the bass too.

But every time I have stalled when it comes to being sure about the chord changes and particularly hearing / working out the harmony parts in each section.

Any suggestions for people out there who could finish these off with me (I wouldn't mind paying a bit) ? To be clear, the transcriptions would not be for selling or recording, just to be played by the big band I am a member of.

Here are the first two on my list:
View: https://youtu.be/BU55q7sZcP4


View: https://youtu.be/YjznYLquuVc



Rhys
 
Last edited:
An arrangement of "Secret Love" is on
www.jazzstudies.us

It should give you a basis to work from to
transpose, simplify or embellish that piece.

Harmonising something can be very personal.
Once you have the bones, flesh it out as complicated or simple to suit your taste.

That seems to just be a chord chart rather than a band arrangement ? I have already got close to the recording's chord changes by transcribing the bass part, looking at various lead sheets and trying to hear the harmony in the recording.

Just to be clear, I want to have this very Quincy Jones "Secret Love" arrangement that he wrote for Dinah Washington, not just any good arrangement of the song. I have searched and it doesn't seem to have ever been published and I haven't found any existing transcription of it. That's why I am transcribing it myself, but have hit my current limits in terms of hearing and guessing the way Quincy harmonised the horn lines.

Rhys
 
But every time I have stalled when it comes to being sure about the chord changes and particularly hearing / working out the harmony parts in each section.

Any suggestions for people out there who could finish these off with me (I wouldn't mind paying a bit) ? To be clear, the transcriptions would not be for selling or recording, just to be played by the big band I am a member of.
I feel your pain! I've never been able to do this, however when I was at college there were a couple of whizz kids who were transcribing Glenn Miller arrangements and they could hear all the inside lines perfectly - and you know how that saxophone section blended.

All I could do was hear the top line and basically what you are saying, ie bass line and chord chart and then voice the sections according to my arranging and orchestration skills. Which have very gradually got better.
 
I feel your pain! I've never been able to do this, however when I was at college there were a couple of whizz kids who were transcribing Glenn Miller arrangements and they could hear all the inside lines perfectly - and you know how that saxophone section blended.

All I could do was hear the top line and basically what you are saying, ie bass line and chord chart and then voice the sections according to my arranging and orchestration skills. Which have very gradually got better.

Thanks - at least I'm in good company.

Alas, I have no orchestration skills and not much in the way of theory. I really want to pinch Quincy's orchestration skills and he probably knocked out this arrangement of "Secret Love" in an afternoon.

Rhys
 
Thanks - at least I'm in good company.

Alas, I have no orchestration skills and not much in the way of theory. I really want to pinch Quincy's orchestration skills and he probably knocked out this arrangement of "Secret Love" in an afternoon.

Rhys
Well given you are transcribing the melody you can actually learn much of what you need to get close from here:


And/or I do give lessons/consultation in arranging either in person or Zoom

Because block voicing close harmony follows fairly strict rules especially if it's the earlier QJ I believe. The ear part of it I can't teach but it's basically identifying the basic methods of 3/4/5 part close and open block voicing, ensemble voicing, unison, counterpoint. Then do your best to recreate from the rules. Unison is easy, 4/5 part close block is easy. Open voicing and ensemble slightly trickier but all you need tell people is you adapted QJ's arrangement rather than transcribed it.
 
Last edited:
I once had to transcribe a dozen or so older Count Basie arrangements. I was paid though quite badly, actually it was less than a copyist would get for producing the parts, which I also had to do. It was payback for a big favor the bandleader had done for me.

What worked for me was to get the lead lines right, and maybe the bottom note of the section, then fool around with a cheap electronic keyboard until I found a voicing that created the same texture I heard in the recording. I used an organ sound for saxes, and a generic brass sound for trumpets and bones.

Can’t say I got everything exactly right, but they sounded right.
 
I’ve transcribed a lot of harmony parts over the years, starting with Supersax when I was a kid . Even though I’ve gotten pretty good at it, it still takes me a very long time. If I were to get paid for it I’d have to charge far more than I would to write a chart from scratch. In other words, writing your own arrangements that are pretty close, as Pete suggested, will be quicker and easier. That way you can focus on transcribing just a the few juicy bits you really love.
 
I’ve transcribed a lot of harmony parts over the years, starting with Supersax when I was a kid . Even though I’ve gotten pretty good at it, it still takes me a very long time. If I were to get paid for it I’d have to charge far more than I would to write a chart from scratch. In other words, writing your own arrangements that are pretty close, as Pete suggested, will be quicker and easier. That way you can focus on transcribing just a the few juicy bits you really love.

Yep. There’s no way that one could compete with the price of buying a full chart.


“Transcribing juicy bits” (love that phrase) is the way to go for personal development.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,073
Messages
578,599
Members
8,133
Latest member
walthang
Back
Top Bottom