Saxophone beginners Help with reading rhythm (Body and Soul)

Messages
701
Location
USA
If I don't know a tune from memory I have trouble hearing the correct rhythm when reading the sheet music unless the tune is simple, I've been browsing past threads and found some good ones, like counting Rhythm, Sight Reading Tips, and Reading Rhythms.

However I would really appreciate if anyone could look at this particular tune I'm working on and tell me if I have it right?

It's Body and Soul, here is the beginning part and there are a few measures where I've penciled in what I think is the rhythm.

PXL_20240113_225136030~2.webp


For some of it I marked a long line on the beat and a short line on the off beat. I didn't mark a line if no note starts on the on/off beat if that makes sense, that's why some bars don't have four 'on beat' marks.

I have listened to a few different versions of this song but haven't found one that seems to help with those bars I marked up, any suggestions also are welcome.
 
Since most recordings of this tune are jazz, you will never find one that follows the sheet music exactly.

Your markings are correct, the problem is that figuring out the rhythms while also actually keeping track of the pulse is difficult. Add in fingering the note in question, and it’s easy to get lost. This stuff takes time and consistent practice to learn.

One thing that helps is to tap or clap the rhythm until you have it down. That way you aren’t struggling with fingering at the same time. Then try singing the tune (don’t worry, no one else can hear you) following the time. Keep working on it, you’ll get there!
 
My rhythm keeping is still a struggle.

Apparat from playing with a recording or demo, I have another tool. I use. Ta-ka-di-me - in this case, just ta-di. ta on the on-beat and di, the off-beat. So, the above bar 18 would be something like
- di ta di ta dii di | ta dii di ta dii di | etc.
Then, "sing" that, clapping on each beat, on 1 and 3 or 2 and 4, give or take a metronom.

The method really comes into its own for more complex situations
 
Last edited:
Learn the words and sing them through the horn.
It's a difficult melody. No good listening to instrumentals, they often don't get it "right".
The emphasis and key shifts for the middle eight. There's usually a lot of "expression" going on.
Concert Db to boot. Not an easy key to hear.
Took me ages, decades, to get it under my fingers. Sometimes you just have to busk through it and pick it up where you can. It will eventually come.
Listen to Ella Fitzgerald and Tony Bennet. They stick faithfully to the melody and lyric as written.
Patience and persistence. It's an advanced showpiece, so it's going to take a while to get your ear, head and fingers round it. 😉
 
This was for me one of the hardest things to get to grip with. I could play 1/4 notes, eighth notes (quavers) and dotted versions of them no problem, it was this kind of syncopation that got me.

So what I did was think


Four 1/8 notes is do be do be (do)

Screenshot 2024-01-14 at 16.00.51.jpg


If I slur the middle two I get do be oo be

Screenshot 2024-01-14 at 16.01.15.jpg

So even though 2nd and 3rd are the same note (technically it would be called a tie) I can think of them as one note.

Especially if I change the oo to ee

Screenshot 2024-01-14 at 16.01.22.jpg


And another way of writing it is instead of the 2nd and 3rd eighth notes it is one quarter note so run be and ee together so it really is one note, and you just imagine it crossing the beat. (syncopation)

Screenshot 2024-01-14 at 16.01.29.jpg


And there you go.

If you are trying to sound it or tap, just count the quarter notes not the eighths (quavers) so don't think of the "ands" let them just go by. So you would tap your foot on the do and ee.
 
1st written bar of notes 4th note is a mistake - it's a D - as you have later on. At bar 18 it might be better to write it with a key change to B major (concert D). It is a key change and the chords here are a F#7 to B(maj7). This next 4 bar section is in B major. The next four bars are coming back to the Cm again (though the home key is Bb). As I say, it follows the harmonic structure and besides, it's horrible to read without the key change.

The swing thing "ain't necessarily so" unless you are playing in an older style (but heck, you can do whatever takes you of course). Much playing of this will be straight 8ths (as it's a ballad) or triplet 8ths or even 16ths.

A quick Google of Stephane Grappelli from way back when shows him taking the even 8ths etc approach too. There aren't rules for this - and it's easy to get sucked into thinking that there are stringent rules around improvised jazz - the even and swung 8ths can be mixed.
 
1st written bar of notes 4th note is a mistake - it's a D - as you have later on. At bar 18 it might be better to write it with a key change to B major (concert D). It is a key change and the chords here are a F#7 to B(maj7). This next 4 bar section is in B major. The next four bars are coming back to the Cm again (though the home key is Bb). As I say, it follows the harmonic structure and besides, it's horrible to read without the key change.
Wouldn't be so bad the ♭s are enharmonically incorrect as well as making it difficult to read.
 
My teacher has suggested I work on Rhythm in isolation, doing to similar exercises.

Yes. There’s an excellent book by Fred Lipsius “Reading Key Jazz Rhythms”.

Aside from that, this transcription of Body and Soul especially lends itself to looking at the figures that occur in two-beat sections. It‘s a matter of developing rhythm vocabulary, rather than counting and subdividing each beat. Divide each measure into halves, then look at the recurring rhythms. Once you start recognizing the patterns, you no longer have to think as much.
 
My teacher has suggested I work on Rhythm in isolation, doing to similar exercises.
I think it's hard to know which exercises just build slowly and which break the back of a weakness... I've done various things, but now I'm following the Mastering Rhythm course linked below and feel it's done me lots of good... But no magic bullets!
1/ It's still under development.
2/ I've actually rewritten the exercises to fit my understanding of takadimi but that's a personal choice.
3/ full disclosure, I've no commercial relationship to the site to disclose

 
Last edited:

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,070
Messages
578,532
Members
8,132
Latest member
LouisJR
Back
Top Bottom