Reeds Help me choose 6 new Alto reeds

I'm still wondering at using a 1½! For me, anything less than a 2½ doesn't give me enough to work with to get the high notes out properly. I wouldn't bring this up and I understand that everyone is different but you did ask for recommendations for alto reeds! I would start out by buying a couple of reeds ½ strength higher than what you are used to and see what that does for you but don't just blow a couple of notes and make a snap decision! It's going to feel different and probably be harder to play at first. Your embouchure will adjust however. The point is there is no "magic reed" that will immediately pop out at you! At this stage of your development you need to give each reed a proper amount of time and one or two scales isn't going to do the trick!

I'm intrigued by your saying that you play the soprano sax. From my perspective (and I came from exactly the opposite spectrum playing bari's) the embouchure gets tighter as the size of the mouthpiece gets smaller. I would think that going to an alto would free your embouchure up allowing for playing of at least the same strength reeds as what you played on soprano! (This is total speculation on my part and I may be completely off but it is what I have experienced with the four sizes of saxes I play.) Just as an FYI, I play Rico Royal 2½ and Vandoren and I find them both acceptable. I am moving up to 3's on alto and C-tenor and yes, it takes more breath support and I have to work harder but the trade off in what I'm able to do is worth it!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm still wondering at using a 1½! For me, anything less than a 2½ doesn't give me enough to work with to get the high notes out properly. I wouldn't bring this up and I understand that everyone is different but you did ask for recommendations for alto reeds! I would start out by buying a couple of reeds ½ strength higher than what you are used to and see what that does for you but don't just blow a couple of notes and make a snap decision! It's going to feel different and probably be harder to play at first. Your embouchure will adjust however. The point is there is no "magic reed" that will immediately pop out at you! At this stage of your development you need to give each reed a proper amount of time and one or two scales isn't going to do the trick!

I'm intrigued by your saying that you play the soprano sax. From my perspective (and I came from exactly the opposite spectrum playing bari's) the embouchure gets tighter as the size of the mouthpiece gets smaller. I would think that going to an alto would free your embouchure up allowing for playing of at least the same strength reeds as what you played on soprano! (This is total speculation on my part and I may be completely off but it is what I have experienced with the four sizes of saxes I play.) Just as an FYI, I play Rico Royal 2½ and Vandoren and I find them both acceptable. I am moving up to 3's on alto and C-tenor and yes, it takes more breath support and I have to work harder but the trade off in what I'm able to do is worth it!

It all depends on your tip opening on your mpc.

Brian
 
I'm still wondering at using a 1½! For me, anything less than a 2½ doesn't give me enough to work with to get the high notes out properly. I wouldn't bring this up and I understand that everyone is different but you did ask for recommendations for alto reeds!

I'm intrigued by your saying that you play the soprano sax. From my perspective (and I came from exactly the opposite spectrum playing bari's) the embouchure gets tighter as the size of the mouthpiece gets smaller. I would think that going to an alto would free your embouchure up allowing for playing of at least the same strength reeds as what you played on soprano! (This is total speculation on my part and I may be completely off but it is what I have experienced with the four sizes of saxes I play./QUOTE]

Hi Steve!

I've never played a 1 1/2 reed either but John has only just started back again after a number of years back in the 90's, and on other posts he has highlighted than he has found it hard to get a sound out of anything harder so has started low. John did start on Soprano but just plays Alto now.

Interesting the point you make about moving from Soprano to Alto - I play 3 strength on sop, but generally only 2.5 on alto and 2 on tenor, but I find that it does depend significantly on tip opening (I play 5 on sop, 6 on alto and 8 on Tenor).

Kind regards
Tom
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hey Tom!

I'm shooting in the dark as I don't have experience with soprano sax. I agree that the tip opening is crucial. Since he is a beginner, I would suggest a "middle of the road" mpc such as a Yamaha 4C, Graphtonite B3, Selmer C* (my personal favorite), etc... The point I was trying to make is that he's wanting a great sound out of a Rico 1½ or even a Vandoren 1(!!) I just don't think he's going to be happy with any reed at those meager strengths!

I am just going from my own experience but I have found that moving up ½ strenth as you progress opens new avenues of performance expression. It forces you to become a better player! Yes, there is a point where there are diminishing returns (and 3 to 4 is right about there!) He mentioned that the tone with 2½ reeds is "breathy." Well, that's really not a surprise. A harder reed is going to give a "breathier" tone until your embouchure adapts! It is easy for the beginner to say, "Ugh! That doesn't sound as good as my old reed!" and they'd be right....to a point! The problem is that with reeds that soft, it's almost impossible to get out the highest regular notes (let alone altissimo!) without them collapsing!

For me personally, I have trouble with anything over a high E if I don't at least have a 2½ (and a new one at that!) The reed will sometimes collapse on me! Whether I stay with a 2½ or go up to a 3 is debatable (and very much dependent upon my choice of mpc!) I'm just wondering how much of a choice is available when one is discussing 1 or 1½ strength reeds? That's why I advocated trying to move up ½ strength and working with it for awhile. I really do think that he will find that to be more of a help than changing brands of reeds at this point! Still, it's just my opinion and he can do whatever he feels best.

Interesting point about lowering the reed strength while moving to larger instruments! I wonder if it's because we are approaching playing multiple sizes of saxes from different directions? Of course, I play all my saxes at 2½ right now! I am starting to play a 3 on C-tenor (using a tenor Graphtonite B3) because it helps me with the higher notes. I still prefer a 2½ with my Selmer 5E for alto but then that's a smaller mouthpiece so go figure...
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Hi, just an update, (thanks for all the advice BTW) right.... using yani hr 6, rico 2 and rico jazz 2m are both fine for me, I can play up and down the sax, no prob, bottom b bflat straight to top F, no effort at all (not like the sop I had) on the sop I could not get top palm d.e.f. unless I put a size 3 reed on, then all my other notes went breathy, so I went back to a 2.5 or 2,and gave up on the altisimo notes! My uncle/teacher has used a Selmer c** and a 1.1/2 reed for 50 years he tells me. (He is good, with a good tone) he played with small and big bands most of the time. I think my Yani hr 6 is wider than the C**. I am not a complete beginner, I played 1992 - 1996, then only started again a few months ago. I am happy with the yani hr6 and strength 2 reeds, it is just that I wanted to try some diffent reeds out of interest, then settle on one make etc and stick to it.
 
Hi John!

Ah, now I have a better understanding of your situation! If you can get all the notes out without trouble, great! I've always liked Rico Royals. Are there better reeds on the market? Yep. They're also quite a bit more expensive! It's cheaper to "buy by the box" but you'll likely have two or three "dogs" so purchasing individual reeds after you have given them a thorough inspection would be my suggestion.
 
Howarth of London sell the following Alto Reeds:

info RIGOTTI 'Gold' alto sax reeds Box of 10 £17.35 Buy

info RICO 'Royal' alto sax reeds Box of 10 £19.65 Buy

I am aware that Rico Royal are not that cheap, and others are not that expensive.

If you look on the Reeds Direct website you will notice that 10 Marca Jazz reeds cost £19.30. 10 Rico Royal reeds cost £19.85. If economy was a concern I'd be happy to buy either the Rigotti or Marca reeds to save a bit of cash.........;}
 
Hi John,

I would definitely recommend trying several different lines, as they all have slightly different dimensions. This can make a big difference for a player. You will naturally gravitate to one or two primary brands that work for you. I would try to start with a 2 at the lowest strength if it isn't too uncomfortable.

There is Rico Reserve, Rico Royal, La Voz, Hemke, Select Jazz, and Plasticover you could try....

ADMIN NOTE: KristenMcKeon appears to be an employee of D'Addario = Rico/Lavoz/Hemke
 
Love the new Avatar, but does remind me of Ronnie Corbett without specs!

Reed choice is very subjective. I would certainly recommend getting a box of reeds and preparing a few of them (say 4 or so) by soaking them first in luke warm water, and following the method outlied on the Alexander Superial Website: Alexander Reeds-Breakin In I use this method and my reeds usually last 6 months and more.

If I was recommending six reeds they would be:

Marca Jazz, Rigotti Gold, Alexander DC, Francois Louis, Rico Jazz Selects & Alexander NY. I would say that I have yet to find a bad Marca Jazz reed - they have all played excellently (I use them on Sop, Alto & Tenor).

Reeds Direct ( http://www.reeds-direct.co.uk/instrument/reeds/alto-saxophone.html ) have the best prices, but some others can have decent sale items ( eg. Page Not Found ).

Ordered today, I will give them a test and let you know which I get on with the best. (I know there could be a bad example amongst them, but I have to start somewhere) Thanks for your suggestions.......
ALEXANDER SUPERIAL 'DC'

ALEXANDER SUPERIAL 'Classique'

ALEXANDER SUPERIAL 'NY'

MARCA 'Jazz' alto

RIGOTTI 'Gold'

RICO 'Hemke Premium'

RICO 'La Voz'

RICO 'Jazz Select Filed'

FRANCOIS LOUIS 'Excellence'

all strength 2
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,076
Messages
578,678
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom