Playing the saxophone Help - I'm sharp over the break and more so in the altissimo range

OK here's my plan:
1) Do mouth piece exercises for 2 to 3 mins a day
2) Get a longer neck strap to change angle of mp and mouth
3) Open throat and relax embouchure as much as possible
4) Record the entire chromatic scale on keyboard, long notes, 3 octaves from low Bb to top Bb, and try to play in tune with this everyday doing spot checks with tuner

Tenor is definitely a quite different beast to the alto...and if the above plan doesn't work there may be a YTS 32 for sale in 3 months!
 
OK here's my plan:
1) Do mouth piece exercises for 2 to 3 mins a day
2) Get a longer neck strap to change angle of mp and mouth
3) Open throat and relax embouchure as much as possible
4) Record the entire chromatic scale on keyboard, long notes, 3 octaves from low Bb to top Bb, and try to play in tune with this everyday doing spot checks with tuner

Tenor is definitely a quite different beast to the alto...and if the above plan doesn't work there may be a YTS 32 for sale in 3 months!

That would be a tragedy, never give up! If you give up, the Devil, or whatever is cocking things up in this world, WINS 😡

John.
 
It doesn't matter what brand of saxophone it is, Yamaha or Conn Wonder, if the mouthpiece doesn't have the right volume (in this case - it is too small) at the position on the cork you use for tuning, the D2-F2 range will be sharp to the lower octave, every time. It is an acoustical fact. Larry Teal's chart showing the average intonation of 35 (or however many it was) saxophonists, where this range is typically sharp, is demonstrative of most players having mouthpieces that are too small for their horn. Nothing more.

If your mouthpiece volume is correct for your instrument, the lower register will over-blow a very, very good octave, without any conscious effort from the player, using a steady embouchure. This (together with the upper register, mouthpiece frequency alignment) is the #1, most important thing that every player should know AND solve for themselves, if they aspire to get anywhere on the instrument.

The importance of fine tuning the mouthpiece volume/frequency to the requirements of the instrument is, for the acoustical results, just as important and essential as fine tuning the played pitch of the instrument for musical performance in an ensemble. Being "close" to "in tune" never makes it, and the difference between close and "spot on" is astounding.


Once that acoustical match is made, then the myriad of overtone/embouchure exercises will really be effective. The beginner will make progress at a phenomenal rate. The developed player will be set free. Attempting to "learn" to play, using a poorly matched mouthpiece, will lead only to the frustration of developing bad physical AND mental habits to compensate for the mismatch, and then more bad habits to compensate for the compensation, and so on. Do yourself a favor and examine the suitability of the mouthpiece.
 
thanks MM, really interesting. But the tendency is for smaller chambers for brightness. Does that mean players have to live with intonation problems to get the sounds they want?

Not at all. The brightness you describe comes predominantly from the baffle design and shape of chamber side walls. The volume of the mouthpiece includes everything in front of the neck opening. That leaves a lot of options for making adjustments, that don't change the basic style/characteristics of the mouthpiece.
 
What happened to, "I'm sharp going over the break...." then? If playing D1 - D2, is a good octave, why is D2 sharp when playing A1, B2, C#2, D2?
Sorry I think a misunderstanding - the tone quality is good but the tuning is obviously sharp (so perhaps in that sense, not a good octave). Do you mean where you play low D, and get the D above it without using the octave key?
 
If it is the Mouthpiece then that would certainly be the best way to solve the problem. How do you know how much to increase the volume of the MP by though - is there a formula?
 
Sorry I think a misunderstanding - the tone quality is good but the tuning is obviously sharp (so perhaps in that sense, not a good octave). Do you mean where you play low D, and get the D above it without using the octave key?

A good octave = perfect octave = in tune octave. I'm only talking about intonation. If your middle D is sharp to your low D, and everything else (embouchure, horn mechanically) is OK, then the mouthpiece volume is too small. The register key should have only a very minimal effect on the D2 pitch.
 
If it is the Mouthpiece then that would certainly be the best way to solve the problem. How do you know how much to increase the volume of the MP by though - is there a formula?

Pull the mouthpiece out until your D1/D2 octave is in tune (with itself. Disregard the A=440 pitch center). Do not make any embouchure adjustments. Leaving the mouthpiece there, play the C#2/C#3 octave. Do not make any embouchure adjustments. How is the pitch of C#3 to C#2? Sharp? Flat?
 
OK Thanks for this Martin. D1 / D2 is now perfect (although I have to make a conscious effort to not tighten up on D2, other wise sharp). Talk about temperamental - for C#3 to C#2, C#2 can be a bit sharper than C#3, although sometimes the same. For Eb 1 to Eb2, Eb2 is +20 sharper. Also Eb2 is +20 sharper than Eb3. G sharp 2 is also 20 cents sharper than G sharp 1. The difference gets more pronounced as I blow and warm the sax up more. I also got my wife to read the tuner for me so I couldn't adjust by looking (e.g. get needle centred).

One point to also note is that based on how much the needle can move around (is quite sensitive Korg CA-30 tuner) when I hold a note makes me think that I just haven't done enough long notes practice (which is true, I don't like practicing long notes). Thanks.
 

Similar threads... or are they? Maybe not but they could be worth reading anyway 😀

Social

New! Social Feeds

Look out for the navigation icon:

Follow CafeSaxophone

Latest Song of the Month

Trending

Forum statistics

Topics
32,074
Messages
578,642
Members
8,134
Latest member
banjo
Back
Top Bottom